Thursday, June 2, 2011

Florida's welfare drug-screening law

Please summarize and discuss the different perspectives on Florida's new law on welfare drug screening.  Make sure to share your own opinions and make sure to comment on others. Please use citations and have at least 2 sources as your references.  Also, make sure to comment on another person's blog too.

25 comments:

elizabeth said...

The new law that will be put into affect July 1st this summer is the requirement for drug tests on adults applying for welfare, if qualified. Individuals have to pay for the screenings themselves. “A positive test means they would lose a portion of the family's welfare benefits for three years and be referred for treatment.”(Stjoechannal). As for those who fail, “ may designate another individual to receive the benefits on behalf of their children” (CNN). This bill so far has been approved by half of the lawmakers. There are many good arguments for the pro’s and con’s of the bill. An example of a supporter is the governor of Florida, Scott, “ It’s the right thing for citizens of this state that need public assistance. We don’t want to waste tax dollars. And also, we want to give people an incentive to not use drugs” (CNN). But, “Others argued the bill unfairly assumed that people receiving welfare take drugs” (wwltv), and that it’s “downright unconstitutional” (CNN). My comment on the bill is that if everyone trying to apply for it now is going to get tested then the rest who already have it might as well get tested. But it can also be a good bill because it can encourage people to get off drugs. Over all I guess they should just do it, I don’t think its harming anyone, and if anyone thinks it will, let me know so I can change my mind..

Recourses
http://stjoechannel.com/fulltext-news?nxd_id=201127
http://www.cnn.com/2011/POLITICS/06/01/florida.welfare.drug.. (the handout)
http://www.wwltv.com/news/local/122068024.html

noelia said...

The Supreme Court repeatedly held that the drug screening is a “search” that violates the forth amendment which implies “ The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures , shall not be violated”. Now the supreme court has approved the ability of the government to “mandate random drug tests in a few limited circumstances”(Huff Post Politics). The people who are tested positive, “will lose a portion of their welfare money for three years and they will be referred to treatment“(St. Joe Chanel).

I believe that this law should be effected because there are people who work hard in this country which are the people who pay their taxes and who don’t get any help from the government who are basically giving money to people who do nothing but sit at home and do drugs. I understand that there are some people who really need the money who for some valid reason truly need the money but others just want it to support their habit.

I agree with Elizabeth Foster’s opinion because she says that it could encourage people to get of drugs because then they might reflect and see that they are not going to get the same amount of money and they wouldn’t be able to support their families.

References:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/adam-winkler/tea-party-drug-tests-for_b_870370.html

http://stjoechannel.com/fulltext-news?nxd_id=201127

Deanna =) said...

We now are discussing Florida’s Welfare drug screening law which Rick Scott on Tuesday signed legislation requiring adults applying for welfare assistance to undergo drug screening. Republican supporters say it is necessary to ensure that Temporary Assistance to Needy Families money is used properly to care for Florida’s poor children, not to pay for illegal drug habits. Anyone who tests positive for a controlled substance would be disqualified from receiving cash benefits for a year. However, they would have a one-time option to reapply within six months if they seek substance abuse treatment, according to the bill.
This bill is good for many reason also it will help clear things up and the government’s money isn’t going towards drugs which are really selfish.”It's the right thing for citizens of this state that need public assistance. We don’t want to waste tax dollars. And also, we want to give people an incentive to not use drugs.” I believe the government has every right to feel this way and step up and make a law that will teach people a lesson. Also about the children are suffering because of the parents and nows the perfect time to take action; I hope drug screening law will help prevent the misuse of Welfare.
I agree with both Elizabeth and Noelia, It could help some people get off drugs because they may realize they actually need they help or the welfare check, This bill may enforce them to quit their habits but in the end it might benefit them and still get support from the government.
http://www.abcactionnews.com/dpp/news/political/drug-testing-for-welfare-benefits-closer-to-florida-law
http://www.cnn.com/2011/POLITICS/06/01/florida.welfare.drug.testing

Gerald Tinnis said...

As of June 1st, the Florida Department of Children and Family Service will be required to make adults take drug tests before applying for welfare. This is because of Governor Rick Scott signing a legislation requiring adults to apply for drug tests if they are to apply for welfare. There are a lot of people who agree with this decision being made and as well as people who disagree. For example, someone who is for this law may feel as if the welfare money received by those who applied for it could be used to purchase drugs instead of providing for their families. Since there isn't a specific way to know how the money is really going to be used, making it required to take a drug test before applying for welfare can make assumptions less and proof of bad usage of the money more evidential. Someone who is against this law may feel as if it is unconstitutional to have a requirement of a drug test before applying for welfare because it is and invasion of personal privacy. Personally, I am in the middle of the two sides of this topic. I do feel as if this requirement is necessary because anyone could easily apply for welfare and use the money received for drugs without anyone knowing. With that being said i can also argue that maybe the reasoning for applying for welfare could be for the simple fact that they are in a situation where they are recovering from drug related problems and need a little money to provide for their family. I agree with Elizabeth in terms of the law encouraging people to get off drugs because that could be a beneficial outcome. But even so, there is a 50/50 possibility that the money received from welfare could be used towards drugs instead of against it, This why i remain in the middle in my opinion.

References:

http://www.cnn.com/2011/POLITICS/06/01/florida.welfare.drug.testing/index.html?iref=allsearch

http://stjoechannel.com/fulltext-news?nxd_id=201127

Zazil said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Zazil said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Zazil said...

Governor Scott from Florida recently signed a bill that makes welfare users take a drug-screen test in order to receive their welfare money. The law went into effect on June 1, 2011. Gov. Scott believes that this way the people who are applying for welfare will stay off drugs. He also adds that this is a better way to take care of their family. Many believe that the “law violates welfare recipients’ fourth amendment right” (Newser) and the ACLU of Florida “has signaled it might sue over the law.” (Miami Herald) Gov. Scott still believes that it is unfair that Florida tax payers are paying for drug addicts drugs. He also adds that this is “the right thing for taxpayers.” (CNN) Under this law adults applying for welfare are required to take a drug test, and if they fail the drug test they “may designate another individual to receive the benefits on behalf of their children.” (CNN)

On the video we heard in class Gov. Scott was asked why are they being treated as suspect and he replied that they are not being treated as suspects that it is normal procedures and that all tax payer have to do drug test in their job and, "what is fair to them should be fare to someone who is getting free money from the government."(CNN video of Newster) I believe that if there is no probable cause as to why they need to be tested then they should not have to get tested. I feel like their privacy is not being respected. I also believe that they will be spending a lot of money by testing the urine, hair, or blood, for drugs when they could be using that money for things such as a rehab facility so that people who do want to quit can have the option to do so for free. Then again the welfare drug test can also encourage people to get off the drugs like Noelia, Elizabeth, and Deanna stated. Even thought I don’t agree with them fully (because people who are hooked on drugs need a lot more help than just realizing that they have lost their welfare benefits it can help them realize that they need help to quit their habits) it can be a first step.

Reference:

http://www.newser.com/story/119958/florida-to-drug-test-welfare-recipients-under-new-law-signed-by-rick-scott.html

http://www.miamiherald.com/2011/05/31/2244532/scott-signs-welfare-drug-testing.html

http://articles.cnn.com/2011-06-01/politics/florida.welfare.drug.testing_1_drug-testing-drug-screening-tanf?_s=PM:POLITICS

yaritza said...

The question may arise concerning what is welfare, and the simple answer is that welfare state is a government that provides for the total well-being of its citizens and is akin to socialism. However, very few true welfare states exist. The United States is a good example of this as it provides some social insurance or entitlement programs to its citizens but does not espouse socialism. As socialism and democracy cannot go hand in hand, therefore, it is impossible for the United States to be one of the true welfare states. The United States does make efforts to provide for persons in need through a myriad of social service programs known as welfare.
Welfare is a form of helping many people that are in need of help financially for many reasons. But sadly not everyone uses this many people take advantage of this help to fulfill their personal needs. Due to this many are concern about what the money that welfare provides is being use for. And starting July 1st this summer there will be a new bill that would require Floridians applying for welfare benefits to first pass – and pay for – a drug test is on its way to Governor Rick Scott’s desk. Republican supporters say it is necessary to ensure that Temporary Assistance to Needy Families money is used properly to care for Flor Scott, who campaigned on the issue, is expected to sign the bill.
Scott, who campaigned on the issue, is expected to sign the bill. “This is an effort to stop this cycle of drug abuse,” said Sen. Steve Oelrich, R-Gainesville, the Senate sponsor. However, some Democratic opponents said it singles out a specific group of people. “This whole bill discriminates,” said Sen. Chris Smith, D-Fort Lauderdale. “It’s only testing people on TANF. There are a lot of other people that get money from the state.”
Anyone who tests positive for a controlled substance would be disqualified from receiving cash benefits for a year. However, they would have a one-time option to reapply within six months if they seek substance abuse treatment, according to the bill .To prevent children from losing out on benefits, if a parent tests positive for a controlled substance, the DCF would be able to designate a “protective payee” to receive cash assistance benefits on the child’s behalf, according to the bill. The designate would also have to pass a drug test.
Oelrich compared the testing to boarding an airplane. Everyone gets screened, he said, not just people who are convicted smugglers or known terrorists. Southwest Florida senators Garrett Richter, R-Naples, and Lizbeth Benaquisto, R-Wellington, who represents a portion of Lee County, both voted in favor of the bill.
I believe that this bill is a really good idea, because this is only going to help the people instead of harm them. I also think that they should test everyone not only the new people applying for welfare, because probably theirs people that are using drugs currently. I agree with Elizabeth this is a way to encourage people to get off drugs because people need their money and they will get off drugs to be able to receive the help they get.
Reference:
http://www.abcactionnews.com/dpp/news/political/drug-testing-for-welfare-benefits-closer-to-florida-law
http://stjoechannel.com/fulltext-news?nxd_id=201127

lorena said...

Florida’s governor, Rick Scott, had singed a new law requiring drug testing for welfare recipients on May 31st, 2011. He states that, “it’s the right thing for citizens of this state that need assistance. We don’t want to waste tax dollars. And also, we want to give people an incentive to not use drugs”(CNN). This kind of law will affect many people who fail the test because it will designate another individual to receive benefits on behalf of their children. On the other hand, there some Democrats who believe that this law is unconstitutional. Rep. Alcee Hasting articulated, “if governor Scott wants to drug test recipients of TANF benefits, where does he draw the line? Are families receiving Medicaid, state emergency relief, or educational grants and loans next”(CNN). So it seems that both side have their differences but it shows in Alcee’s statement how he criticizes the governors action.

In general, people who don’t have jobs or are unable to work take welfare. These people are taking it from those who work day and night. In my opinion I believe that this bill will be very affective in many ways. They should be drug tested for the reason that some of them use the money to buy drugs and not for the right reasons.

Another way it can be affective will be because, like Elizabeth stated, “he bill will be good because Itcan encourage people to get off drugs.” This will be a very good idea and why wouldn’t it work? plus, they are taking money from those who work while they in their houses doing absolutely nothing.
References:
http://articles.cnn.com/2011-06-01/politics/florida.welfare.drug.testing_1_drug-testing-drug-screening-tanf?_s=PM:POLITICS

http://stopthedrugwar.org/chronicle/2011/may/31/florida_welfare_drug_testing_bill

angel said...

Last week Florida's Governor Rick Scott signed a law requiring all adults who take welfare to undergo a drug test. " It's the right thing for citizens of this state that need public assistance. We don't want to waste tax dollars. And also, we want to give people an incentive to not use drugs". (CNN Politics). Stated Scott. this law will take effect in July 1st. Meaning now that if your going to apply for welfare you have to undergo a drug test. In my opinion this bill could be good and bad because in a good way this is making people use the money for what is needed not for other things they want to do. But it could be bad in a way too because this is like violating peoples personal rights just because the government is giving you money you have to get tested for drugs. I don't think this makes it right ether. Now Governor Scott stated that this could be a good way for people to stop using drugs. In my opinion i could say that he must be out of his mind people are not going to stop using drugs just because welfare is giving them drug tests now. Governor Scott also stated another good point "taxpayers shouldn't be required to finance someone's drug habit" (huffingtonpost). But according to Huffington Post "It's unlikely to pass--and even if it does, that law, like Florida's, is almost certain to be struck down in court" (huffingtonpost). In my opinion this is due to the fact that they are violating peoples personal privacy.

Roudia Elysee said...

As I do some research about Florida's welfare drug-screening law, I found a lot of amazing information and different responses on whether if a person who gets welfare be drug tested or not? As I read from articles to articles, I have noticed that the reason why states across the country are now trying this process and it is because “the effects of the economic crisis gripping the land, some legislators are engaging in the cheap politics of resentment as a supposed budget-cutting move”(StopTheDrugWar). As, a result to that, at least six states bills have been filed that would require people seeking public assistance and/or unemployment benefits to submit to random drugs testing, with their benefits at stake. For example, some states that had filed out bills to force people in seeking public assistance to undergo random drug test and forgo benefited if they test positive are Arizona, Hawaii, Missouri, Kansas and Oklahoma, as for West Virginia, “in which both groups are targeted”(StopTheDrugWar).

In Florida governor Rick Scott, who is fully for the welfare drug-screen measure, believes that it is the right thing. He stated “It’s the right thing for citizens of this state that need public assistance. We don’t want to waste tax dollars. And also, we want to give people an incentive to not use drugs” (CNN). As for ALCU Drug Policy Litigation Project head Graham Boyd at the time also said “This ruling should send a message to the rest of the nation that drug testing programs like these are neither an appropriate or effective use of a state’s limited resources” (StopTheDrugWar). However, some people believe other wise when it comes to this bill. Some people believe that it is a bad policy because of discrimination while others thinks it a waste of money. According to Frank Crabtree WV ACLU “This is a really bad policy, these are the most vulnerable people in our society, and their children are even more vulnerable. These are people of whom the legislature has no fear. They have to deal with the problems of daily life to such a degree that they are not politically active, and that makes this bill just seem like a bullying tactics” (StopTheDrugWar). Similarly, as for the national affairs director for the Drug Policy Alliances, Bill Piper acknowledged that “these bills are a waste of money at a time when a governments don’t have money to wastes, they’re extremely discriminatory in that they focus on someone smoking marijuana, but don’t address at all whether someone is blowing his check on alcohol or gambling or vacations. The bottom line is that even if someone is using drugs, that don’t mean they should be denied public assistance, health care or anything else to which citizens are entitled. These bills are unnecessarily cruel and they show that some politicians still think it’s in their best interest to pick on vulnerable people with substance abuse issues.”(StopTheDrugWar)

I disagree with the law and I disagree with Elizabeth, Noelia, Deanna and Gerald. Like Bill Piper stated above, they are extremely discriminatory in that they focus on someone smoking marijuana, but do not address at all whether someone is blowing his check on alcohol, gambling or vacations. If someone is using drugs, that does not mean they should be denied public assistance, health care or anything else to which citizens are entitled. Furthermore if people have the right to collect welfare or unemployment, they all have the right to spend it how they choose to. For example, some may choose to spend it on bills, foods, expensive shoes, and schools while others could use it to gamble or spend it on vacations. I would like to know should the government decide how every penny of unemployment or welfare is spent? What about people on unemployment who grow and smoke their own weed for free?

*Reference:
http://articles.cnn.com/2011-06-01/politics/florida.welfare.drug.testing_1_drug-testing-drug-screening-tanf?_s=PM:POLITICS

http://stopdrugwar.org/chronicle/2009/mar/20/feature_bills_require_drug_testi

Brandi Phillips said...

Recently in the state of Florida Governor Rick Scott has approved the Welfare Drug-Screening bill which people have called unconstitutional and a violation of rights. Others call the new bill necessary and should be in place to make sure tax payer’s money goes to good use. The bill requires all welfare recipients to have a drug screening to be able to receive government assistance; if they fail another recipient can receive assistance if children are involved in the matter. People who support the bill believe that people shouldn’t take advantage of the state’s welfare anymore and abuse the privileges they have. They also think that the restrictions on welfare would encourage people to abandon uses of drugs to keep their benefits. Florida Governor Rick Scott believes the bill is “the right thing for citizens of this state that need public assistance. We don’t want to waste tax dollars. And also, we want to give people an incentive to not use drugs” (CNNPolitics). However, there are some people who do not agree with the bill as the Governor does. Others think that the bill is a violation of ones privacy in their personal life. They also believe that it is a direct hit to the children that are being supported off of the program that are in need. Also some democratic representatives don’t agree with the bill costing tax payers $1 million, and the people being kicked off the program would struggle even more with their life’s causing more trouble in the state (TheColumbiaDailyTribune). In my opinion I think that the bill should be passed because people abuse it and not use the welfare as intended. However, I don’t think the bill should be passed because there are people who do illegal drugs but need the assistance to support their family members. Also I don’t think they should because I don’t think a child should be punished for his or her parent’s mistakes in their life. This is why I agree with Gerald because there are a lot of different reasons why people depend on government assistance and we can’t always determine if they are all right or wrong; therefore I am in the middle.

References:

http://www.columbiatribune.com/news/2011/may/10/welfare-drug-testing-measure-goes-governor/

http://srticles.cnn.com.2011-06-01/politics/florida.welfare.drug.testing_1_drug-screening-tanf?_s=PM:POLITICS

veronique said...

Welfare is a privilege bottom line period. Many other countries do not have it and are to live with out government help. Even if it means living without food, cloths, cash benefits etc. Now for the US to provide welfare is something that should be respected and grateful for. In Florida of this year a new law that will be put into affect July 1st this summer is the requirement for drug tests on adults applying for welfare. A drug test should be taken into consecration in this case we have people who abuses the right of having welfare. Whether it’s taking the welfare in supporting their old habits or giving it way to get other things in return for it, but better yet having a food stamp card adding people who don’t live with you to increase the income on it to support yet again habits. Many people may argue and say what the state of Florida is doing is wrong because not everyone on welfare is choice but the lost of a job, they lost their home etc. They also may say it goes against the person’s personal space. It was reported in the Miami Herald that, “The wasteful program created by this law subjects Floridians who are impacted by the economic downturn, as well as their families, to a humiliating search of their urine and body fluids without cause or even suspicion of drug abuse, said Howard Simon, executive director of the ACLU of Florida. Searching the bodily fluids of those in need of assistance is a scientifically, fiscally, and constitutionally unsound policy.” The other perspective is we waste millions of dollars in supporting habits not only that tax payers are giving money to help those who may had put themselves in that situation. In addition, that anyone can not only sign up for food stamps and get it when the person can be using them in the wrong. Florida is offering cash welfare assistance and is only looking for the good to come out of it there’s nothing wrong with that. Senate sponsor Steve Oelrich states, “This bill is all about trying to break the cycle of drug dependency and using taxpayer dollars to buy illegal drug,” If it means breaking the cycle of waste money and giving to those who will be reasonable well take any mean necessary. I agree with Nolie many people do work hard and to see there hard work support a habit is a waste. If I work hard all my life than to see money go to waste I would be upset highly.

http://www.politifact.com/florida/promises/scott-o-meter/promise/600/require-drug-screening-for-welfare-recipients/
: http://www.miamiherald.com/2011/05/31/2243581/fla-gov-scott-signs-welfare-drug.html#ixzz1X2AkGyx5

Vanessa Bertrand said...

Florida's welfare drug-screening law is that "Thousands of the state's poorest Floridians will have to take a drug test if they want to qualify for welfare assistance, under a new law signed by Gov. Rick Scott Monday," (Orlando Sentinel). The reason for this law is that many people believe that their tax money shouldn't be used for those who are just going to use public money for drugs. They believe it is unfair to subsidize drug addiction. On the contrary "Democrats and advocates for the poor say the requirement could violate individuals' constitutional rights to privacy," (Orlando Sentinel) causing this to become a civil issue.

I agree with Elizabeth's comment "We don’t want to waste tax dollars. And also, we want to give people an incentive to not use drugs," (CNN). Therefore, i believe that Florida's law is a good idea. Taxpayers shouldn't have to contribute to someones drug addition. I mean, if your not taking drugs, why are you afraid to take the drug test or think its an invasion of privacy??

References :
http://articles.orlandosentinel.com/2011-05-31/news/fl-scott-signs-drug-testing-bill-20110531_1_welfare-recipients-cash-assistance-temporary-assistance

http://www.cnn.com/2011/POLITICS/06/01/florida.welfare.drug.. (the handout)

Nadine Jean said...

The Governor of Florida has signed a law that requires drug testing to be taken for any welfare candidate. Gov. Scott’s, of Florida, opinion is, "While there are certainly legitimate needs for public assistance, it is unfair for Florida taxpayers to subsidize drug addiction. This new law will encourage personal accountability and will help to prevent the misuse of tax dollars." (NY daily news) Though it seems as the Governor is trying to take actions for the taxpaying people, it can be taken as an invasion of privacy. According to Rep. Corrine Brown, “investigating people when there is probable cause to suspect they are abusing drugs is one thing, but these tests amount to strip searching our states most vulnerable residents merely because they rely on the government for financial support during these difficult economic times.” (CNN) At first I agreed with the law 100 percent, and thought what can you possibly disagree about? Though as I did more research into the laws I learned if such a law that strips personal rights is passed, then this would be giving the government the freedom to violate one part of the Constitution. This pretty much gives them the power to violate all parts of it. The Sixth Amendment, for Privacy of the Person and Possessions, pretty much says why this law is not right according to the Constitution. It states, “The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.” (Law2) So therefore, I would disagree with the law if it violates a person’s rights according to the Constitution. Though, if Gov. Scott sets restrictions to the law that gives probable cause to why a person should be drug tested then the law would be fine. I agree with Elizabeth to a certain extent, there is some benefit to the law but the fact that it’s a blatant violation of our Constitutional rights makes me believe that the law is wrong.
Reference:
http://www.nydailynews.com/news/politics/2011/06/01/2011-06-01_florida_gov_rick_scott_signs_law_requiring_welfare_recipients_to_take_drug_test_.html
http://www.cnn.com/2011/POLITICS/06/01/florida.welfare.drug
http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/conlaw/rightofprivacy.html

Fabiola Privat said...

Recently, a bill has been signed in Florida saying that applicants must get tested for drugs before receiving welfare assistance. People who test positive will be ban from state assistances for six months, and if it reoccurs the second time, then they are ban for three years. But as always there are people who believe that this type of structure is need, while others do not.

The Governor Rick Scott says that "The goal of this is to make sure we don't waste taxpayers' money" (MiamiHerald). He feels as though this bill will save money and not be used on people that do not use it for good. He also believes that it is “going to increase personal responsibility, personal accountability. We shouldn't be subsidizing people's addiction" (MiamiHerald). So by signing this bill, he hopes that people would learn to not use drugs, and make a better life for themselves. But there are people like Howard Simon, the executive director of the ACLU of Florida, who believe that this bill is not necessary. Simon claims that Scott is “giving ugly legitimacy to an unfortunate stereotype that has been in this country for a couple of decades -- that all welfare recipients are a bunch of drug abusers” (CNN). Basically, Howard believes that he is creating sterotypes on the people of his own state. He also says that Scott has “demonstrated his dismissal of both the law and the right of Floridians to personal privacy by signing into law a bill that treats those who have lost their jobs like suspected criminals”(MiamiHerald).

I agree with Howard Simon when he says that it invades the privacy of the people, because it will be there money to do what they want with it. But I also think that Governor Scott was right for signing the bill. The haed earn money from tax payers go to the government programs, so if it I illegal for hard working people to use drugs then applicants should not get it for free. And I also agree with everyone else who said that it will get people off of drugs if they really need the money. So in the end, government assistance should only be given to the people that will need it and use it for good, not to commit illegal activities.





Reference:
http://miamiherald.typepad.com/nakedpolitics/2011/05/scott-signs-bill-forcing-drug-tests-on-welfare-recipients.html

http://www.cnn.com/2011/POLITICS/06/05/florida.welfare.drug.testing/

Bill said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Bill said...

Seems that Florida is trying a new approach to weed out welfare abusers. Florida Governor Rick Scott signed a law that required adults on welfare to undergo drug screenings. Scott's reason for this new law is that it is "unfair for Florida taxpayers to subsidize drug addiction"(CNN), suggesting that some people on welfare are taking advantage of it to support their drug use, which other people also agree with. Others, however, feel that this new law is an invasion of privacy and as a representative stated, this law "is not only an affront to families in need and detrimental to our nation's ongoing economic recovery, it is downright unconstitutional"(CNN). A law that is designed to punish those who take advantage of the system, yet it also helps them out. This law is pointless in so many ways. The only good idea from this law is that it would discontinue support for those that are using welfare for their drug habit. However, where it fails is that one, money would have to be spent to do these drug testings and two, those who fail the testings are sent to rehab, where more money is being spent on the drug user. This is where I agree with Zazil, that more money is being spent in doing these things and it contradicts Scott's statement because this law would still be supporting those drug users in some way.

References:
http://articles.cnn.com/2011-06-05/politics/florida.welfare.drug.testing_1_drug-testing-tanf-welfare-recipients?_s=PM:POLITICS

elijah said...

Starting on July 1st Florida will start a new law that will give adults applying for welfare a drug test to see if they are qualified. According to Florida because of this, "people have to pay for their own screenings"(CNN). So far this law has been approved by mojority of the lawmakers. The law has been passed for many reasons. One reason according to Rick Scott who had signed the legislation on Tuesady "It is unfair for Florida taxpayers to subsidize drug addiction"(CNN).

Some people think that Governer Scott new law was kinda insalting to the unwealthy. Such as five Democrats from the states congressional delegation. Soon after the bill was signed the five Democrats had issued a joint statement attacking the legislation, by calling it "downright unconstitutional"(CNN). Rep. Alcee Hastings feel like "Governor Scott's new drug testing law is not only an affront to families in need and detrimental to our nations ongoing economic recovery, it is downright unconstitutional"(CNN). Rep. Corriine Brown feels like the test "represent an extreme and illegal invasion of personal privacy"(CNN).

I believe that Florida shouls enforce the law because some people get welfar when they realy dont even need it.

Necolette said...

The new law in florida states that all Welfare recipents must undergo a requiered drug test governer Rick Scott supports it by "Its the right thing for citizens of this state that need public assistance. We dont want to waste tax dollars. And also, we want to give people an incentive to not use drugs." On the other hand Howard Simon executive director of the ACLU of Florida disagrees and may sue over the welfare law as well. "what (Scott) is doing is giving ugly legitimicy to an unfortunate stereotype that has been in the century for a couple of decades- that all welfare recipients are a bunch of drug abusers."

I agree with governer Rick scott when he said we want to give people an incentive to not use drugs, this bill will maybe insure the drug users to not apply personally and make it known that what there doing is wrong and against the law. This will state that abusing government programs and tax payers money is a crime and cannot and will not be tallorated.


References:http://www.cnn.com/2011/POLITICS/06/05/florida.welfare.drug.testing/index.html
http://articles.cnn.com/2011-06-01/politics/florida.welfare.drug.testing_1_drug-testing-drug-screening-tanf?_s=PM:politics

jose said...

The new law in Florida states that all Welfare recipients must endure a required drug test governor Rick Scott says "unfair for Florida taxpayers to subsidize drug addiction," Gov. Rick Scott on Tuesday signed legislation requiring adults applying for welfare assistance to undergo drug screening.”(CCN)”under the law, which takes effect on July 1, the Florida Department of Children and Family Services will be required to conduct the drug tests on adults applying to the federal Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program. The aid recipients would be responsible for the cost of the screening, which they would recoup in their assistance if they qualify. Those who fail the required drug testing may designate another individual to receive the benefits on behalf of their children.”(CNN). I agree with the bill because its not fair if drug addicted people have welfare because their dirtying the American name.

http://articles.cnn.com/2011-06-01/politics/florida.welfare.drug.testing_1_drug-testing-drug-screening-tanf?_s=PM:POLITICS

tarahn said...

As of July 1st of this year a new law will be passed that mandates that there be drug screenings for those who are applying for welfare services , according to CNN “ as for those who fail the drug screening it may designate another individuals to receive the benefits on the behalf of their children “. this law I becoming controversial because many lawmakers are approving the bill, many people are saying that the bill violates the 4th amendment which protects people from being subjected to unreasonable searchers, while on the other hand others are saying that this bill is helping welfare to give their services to people who actually need it and not to drug addicted individuals.

In my opinion I think this law is great, this law allows welfare to actually give their services to those who actually need it and not to those who are taking advantage of the system. To many times in my community have I’ve seen people abuse what the government has giving us weather is be cheating the system, accepting unemployment with no intentions of looking for a job, or accepting disability checks when you arent really disabled, so I completely agree with Elizabeth, Neoeli, and Deanna because this bill allows people to be accountable and it could potentially motivate people to get off drugs .


http://www.cnn.com/2011/POLITICS/06/01/florida.welfare
http://stjoechannel.com/fulltext-news?nxd_id=201127

Jocelyn S said...

On July 1st of this year, the “Florida Department of Children and Family Services will be required to conduct the drug tests on adults applying to the federal Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program” (CNN.com). What this means is any person who is applying for welfare in the state of Florida will have to participate in a drug screening, and pass, in order to receive any government money. Gov. Rick Scott defends his signing of the law stating "It's not right for taxpayer money to be paying for somebody's drug addiction” while speaking with a CNN reporter. Many hard working tax payers agree with Governor Scott while others strongly disagree. Some of the people that disagree would be Howard Simon, the executive director of the ACLU (American Civil Liberties Union) of Florida shares that What (Scott) is doing is giving ugly legitimacy to an unfortunate stereotype that has been in this country for a couple of decades -- that all welfare recipients are a bunch of drug abusers," he later goes on to say that the law is just “downright unconstitutional” (CNN.com). Personally I feel like the law should definitely be in effect! I mean normal people pay their taxes so less fortunate children and families can a little better life then what they’d normally would have, but some adults are just too irresponsible and miss use the money they are given. Just as Elizabeth and Noelia stated this law could cause a lot more people to get off drugs and stay off. I think it will have a very positive outcome.
http://articles.cnn.com/2011-06-05/politics/florida.welfare.drug.testing_1_drug-testing-tanf-welfare-recipients?_s=PM:POLITICS

muller said...

As of July 1st the new Florida that’s going to be past about welfare recipients need to be tested for drug is a positive solution to what is happening because some people that get welfare take drug. According to Gov. Scott “It's not right for taxpayer money to be paying for somebody's drug addiction," (CNN). That why I think this is a great law and people should accountable about how they should they should they use their money? I think the consequences such as the ” Applicants for the federal Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program who test positive for illicit substances won't be eligible for the funds for a year, or until they undergo treatment. Those who fail a second time would be banned from receiving the funds for three years” (NY Daily News). Therefore Gov. Scott said "On top of that, this is going to increase personal responsibility, personal accountability”(CNN). Therefore the Governor really wants to make sure people are using the money in a right. The people that receive welfare an don’t take drug probably think it a waste of time.
That’s why I agree with Elizabeth that this “can also be a good bill because it can encourage people to get off drugs.”

Reference:

http://news.blogs.cnn.com/2011/06/05/florida-government-defends-requiring-drug-tests-for-welfare-recipients/

http://articles.nydailynews.com/2011-06-01/news/29627456_1_aclu-objects-welfare-recipients-rick-scott

Anonymous said...

Just recently Governor Rick Scott signed a new law in Florida. The new law was that anyone who wants to be on welfare must pass a drug test. The reason why Gov. Rick Scott signed this law was because he didn't want to waste tax dollar and he wants to make sure that people on welfare are not taking drugs."It's the right thing for taxpayers," Scott said after signing the measure. "It's the right thing for citizens of this state that need public assistance. We don't want to waste tax dollars. And also, we want to give people an incentive to not use drugs."(CNN) Also those who are applying for welfare must pay for the drug testing out of their own pocket but if they pass the test then they will receive their money back. If they don't pass the test then they will not be available for welfare, “Those who fail the required drug testing may designate another individual to receive the benefits on behalf of their children.”(CNN) Not everyone is content about this law because an attorney for AFSCME believes that the drug testing will only cost the state more waste of money, "We have a chief executive saying I want to put perhaps millions of dollars out of my state budget to pay for unnecessary, unconstitutional drug testing when he have an economic crisis, when we have budget slashes. It is disappointing," said Alma Gonzalez.(WSJ) This new law will take affect on July 1st and there is plenty of controversy whether this law is actually necessary.

I agree with Necolette about how people will feel the need not to use drugs anymore. I believe that the intensions of this law is for a good cause and to secure that the right people are on welfare.


Reference:

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303745304576359780327686022.html

http://articles.cnn.com/2011-06-01/politics/florida.welfare.drug.testing_1_drug-testing-drug-screening-tanf?_s=PM:POLITICS