Friday, June 3, 2011

Indiana's new law on abortions

Please summarize and discuss the different perspectives on Indiana's new law on abortions in Planned Parenthood.  Make sure to share your own opinions and make sure to comment on others. Please use citations and have at least 2 sources as your references.  Also, make sure to comment on another person's blog too.

27 comments:

Brandi Phillips said...

Indiana’s new law that regulates on the extent of medical care that people receive from Medicaid is very controversial in the state. The bill requires people who want an abortion to pay the full cost and the government’s Medicaid will not cover it on any conditions. Some people believe that the government, who funds Medicaid, should not support recipients aborting a pregnancy. People also think that the government is paying too much money to support recipients for their own absurdity. On the other hand, people believe that if a person cannot afford to have their own insurance, how will they be able to afford an abortion? A person who does not supports this bill might say that the government should support schools and take care of the economy then waste money on abortions that are not as important as the education and economic growth in our country. However, a person who opposes of the bill might say that if the people can’t afford regular health care then what are the chances of them supporting a child? Also the bill states that under any condition Medicaid will not cover abortions. This means even in extreme cases like rape, when a woman becomes pregnant she cannot receive an abortion. Many people disapprove of this bill such as the Obama Administration. The Obama Administration thinks the bill goes too far and is restricting Medicaid beneficiaries from there services that are provided to them (CNN). Also Medicaid Administrators believes that “Indiana’s plan will improperly bar beneficiaries from receiving services,[that] Federal law requires Medicaid beneficiaries to be able to obtain”(TheWashingtionTimes). I agree with the Obama Administration and the Medicaid Administrators because if you provide a Federal service to the people then they should receive full service of what the program offers. The restriction trying to be put on by the bill is unfair to many underprivileged people that the government supports. Overall, they are all people and should have a choice and not have to be restrained by their economical state or lack of support from their state.

References:
http://cnn.sitie.printthis.clickabillity.com
http://www.TheWashingtonTimes.com

veronique said...

“Abortion is the intentional termination of a pregnancy after conception. It allows women to put an end to their pregnancies, but involves killing the undeveloped embryo or fetus.”
So that means get rid of a fetus or an embryo that has not become a human yet. Here’s the problem Indiana’s new law state, “Anyone who seeks an abortion should pay the fee and their Medicare will not cover it on any circumstances. This was already an issue back in 1971 when the government had of India had the Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act. This would permit abortion to be performed only when the pregnancy poses a risk to the life of the pregnant woman, or, of grave injury to her physical or mental health, or, when there is a substantial risk of the child being born. There are two sides to this story one side is abortion is bad because its taking a life from one who has not even experienced it yet or the fact its murder how ever you look at it. In addition, the person should have known what was going to happen. Another may say why bring a child in the world you can’t even afford or bring a child in knowing the risk of things genetically it can inherit like a disease or something. Nevertheless, honestly if the government does not agree with it that are they to say no to someone who can’t afford the abortion. If the parent is not stable to bring a life into the world to make matters worst and put your kid through it wouldn’t that be wrong. I agree Brandi a person should have a right to live their life and not be held back. I would rather the person wait until they are at a stable setting before bringing life in.

http://blogs.expressindia.com/showblogdetails.php?contentid=394265

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/the-full-extent-of-indias-gendercide-2288585.html

angel said...

On May 10 2011, Indiana's Governor Mitch Daniels, signed a law that would prohibit abortions. Meaning that the state's health care would no longer cover abortions. If a female decides to have an abortion she has to pay it with her own money. for this law the state would now be forfeiting the portion of the medicaid which is $4 million annually according to CNN. (CNN). Moreover, Cindy Mann the official who surpervises medicaid said that the states could not exclude doctors, and clinics from medicaid “because they separately provide abortion services.” (Newyorktimes). On the other hand, we have Mr. Daniels who states "I supported this bill from the outset, and the recent addition of language guarding against the spending of tax dollars to support abortions creates no reason to alter my position." (CNN). When you hear arguments like both of these its hard to choose which side you on because you don't know which one its right or wrong.

In my opinion i think this law is going over the limit because not everybody's living the same way. not everyone has thousands of dollars to go pay for an abortion. That's the problem with the government they don't think about other people they just think about whats good for them. Example lets say a young girl in her teens gets raped her parents are poor living in the state of Indiana, you think shes going to be able to pay for an abortion ? whats going on with the U.S and approving all these laws that violate our rights.

overall, i agree with Brandi's statement and how we both believe The Obama Administration is right on saying that this goes too far.

References:

http://www.cnn.com/2011/POLITICS/06/02/indiana.medicaid/index.html

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/02/us/politics/02clinic.html

lisa said...

Indiana has enforced a law that keeps woman who rely on Medicaid from getting the coverage that they need for abortions, meaning that they will have to pay the full price from their pockets. This law prevents women who can afford the abortion, from continuing with the procedure if you’re after your 20th week of your pregnancy, “with exceptions for the life or health of the mother,” (CNN), because doctors are required to tell patients that the fetus can feel pain at fertilization. People who approve this law believe that a woman should be going through the right circumstances so she won’t get pregnant to get an abortion. Indiana's government also believes it has a right to determine how it will manage its Medicaid program and to select the providers it will partner with, and the federal government, or Obama, should let them.
This law is the same old controversial debate that has been going on for years, and the same beliefs apply. This is not about health care services at all, this is about abortions, and people who are pro-life are ecstatic. Schneider, an Indiana Republican said as a statement on Wednesday, "The case made by Planned Parenthood is nothing more than a false alarm and their claims that women will go without health services are false, our new law will allow Planned Parenthood to continue to receive taxpayer funding if they simply stop performing abortions. The decision is now theirs to make.” (HuffPost Politics). One thing is for sure, the Republican Governor of Indiana, Mitch Daniels, is 100% for this law. He, “signed the bill restricting abortions and taking funds from Planned Parenthood, which among other services provides abortions, on Tuesday, and the law went into effect immediately,” (Reuters).
I agree with all three posts before me, if you are not ready to raise and afford a child, you can’t possibly afford an abortion. Women should have the right to decide if they want to keep the baby, and I believe it is absurd that the sneaky government officials of Indiana has found away to take that decision from them because they know, these low-income women will not afford the abortion. Also, I agree with the Planned Parenthood that forcing doctors to give information that is not a fact nor relevant to the patient can be misleading, and violates free-speech protections with the First Amendment (USA Today). Thus, I hope someone stops this law in Indiana before other states who are pro-life, follow their example.

References
http://articles.cnn.com/2011-05-11/justice/indiana.anti.abortion.law_1_medicaid-patients-indiana-abortion-law-abortion-services?_s=PM:CRIME
http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/05/11/us-indiana-abortion-idUSTRE74A84720110511
http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2011-05-11-indiana-planned-parenthood_n.htm
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/05/11/planned-parenthood-indiana_n_860618.html

Makayla said...

Although I don’t believe in abortion, whether one chooses to be pro-life or pro-choice is their decision. It is unjust for a community to deny a young woman a choice about her own body due to their personal beliefs. If a young girl was attacked and raped, why deny her the right to abort the baby? What young woman would want to nurture a child whom is a product of rape? A newborn bill passed in Illinois, permits to clinics to ask women if they want to see “the ultra sounds of their unborn fetus and remind them that life begins at conception, and that her fetus might feel pain” (WBEZ91.5). The rules of the bill are made to make the woman feel guilty and to hopefully prevent them from making an uninformed decision. The bill also states, that Planned Parenthood is asking the government to support abortions for both woman who can’t afford it and can’t also. That is where I disagree, if a woman can afford it she should be able to pay for it on her own, but if she can’t, she should be supported regardless of people’s personal beliefs. The bill is requiring both classes of women to come up with the money on their own whether they can afford it or not.

If a woman is unable to afford an abortion, how the hell is she suppose to be able to afford raising a child? As I stated before, what if it is a young girl with not job or type of income, what is she to do?

I agree with Brandi about the Obama’s Administration and Medicaid Administrators, all patients should be approved regardless of their beliefs.

http://www.wbez.org/story/abortion/indiana-illinois-legislatures-consider-new-abortion-laws
http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2011-05-11-indiana-planned-parenthood_n.htm

noelia said...

The new Indiana law restricts Medicaid possessors from getting abortions unless they are able to pay it from their own money. The provision does not only violates Medicaid rules but it also violates the free speech right of health care providers because they are not able to provide their opinion or ideas regarding the law.

Many, are not able to pay for the abortion themselves which is why Medicaid was able to pay for it, but now the new law is preventing Medicaid from paying. With this said, it is obvious that if Medicaid is paying for the abortion is because the person cannot pay for it.

I believe that the law is absurd because an abortion is too expensive and most women cannot afford it. What if someone got raped and they can't afford it? Are they obligated to keep the baby even if they don't want to? I don't believe it is fair that they would have to pay for it. In the other hand, those who just want an abortion because they did not used protection, should pay for it because that was their mistake.

I agree with Lisa in full in her opinion when she states that "if you are not ready to raise and afford a child, you can’t possibly afford an abortion". therefore, Medicaid should keep paying for it.


References:
http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2011-05-11-indiana-planned-parenthood_n.htm

http://cnn.site.printthis.clickability.com/pt/cpt?expire=&title=admin...w.cnn.com%2F2011%2FPOLITICS%2F06%2FO2%2Findiana.medicaid%2Findex.html

Vanessa Bertrand said...

Indiana's new abortion law is so the government would not have to pay for anyone's abortion but for them to fully pay for it themselves. Thus, "The law would cut off about $2 million of the $3 million Planned Parenthood of Indiana receives annually in federal funds and make Indiana the first state to prohibit the use of Medicaid at Planned Parenthood" (usatoday). Taxpayers (and many that don't believe in abortion) think that they should not be putting out money for others to have abortions. although there are people that stand by helping those who cant afford to get an abortion like Planned Parenthood, who "calls the bills an assault on women," (WBEZ). they believe it is not right for the people who cant afford it or even worst, the people who were raped ans cant afford it.

I agree with Angel on the point that many people cant afford to get an abortion and this law isn't fair to them. on the other hand, for those who don't believe in Abortions due to religion or something, they should have a choice if their taxes should go to that. so I'm pretty much in the middle, its not fair to not help the people who cant pay for their abortions if their in hard times, and its also not fair to force people who don't believe in abortion to pay for people to have one.

References :
http://www.wbez.org/story/abortion/indiana-illinois-legislatures-consider-new-abortion-laws

http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2011-05-11-indiana-planned-parenthood_n.htm

Zazil said...

Abortion is a very controversial topic both in politics and among people. Some believe that abortion means killing a baby while others argue that the fetus is not a child yet since it cannot survive without the mother. On May 10, 2011 Indiana’s Governor, Mitch Daniel, signed a law that “cuts off state and federal money for Planned Parenthood clinics providing health care to low-income women on Medicaid.” (New York Times) This law “makes Indiana the first state to prohibit the use of Medicaid at Planned Parenthood.”(USA today) Planned Parenthood has challenge this law, but Sue Swayze, a legislative director of Indiana states, “we’ve done some legal research ourselves and think that it’s going to stand.” She then adds, “It might actually, […] become a model for the rest of the country” (USA Today) In addition, medical professionals have to tell the patients that want to get an abortion that “life begins at fertilization and that a fetus can feel pain at or before 20 weeks gestation” (USA Today) and many feel that this information is false and misleading. Moreover, the administrator of the federal centers for Medicare and Medical Services states that, “Medicaid programs may not exclude qualified health care providers from providing series that are funded under the program because of a provider’s scope of practice.” (CNN) In other words, he believes that not all federal funding should be cut from a clinic only because they provide abortion services.

I personally believe that it is a women’s choice to get an abortion, and that money should not be a barrier. In other words I believe that the bill is classist, it is only discriminating against the poor. Kids are very expensive and people who want to get out of poverty should have an option to get an abortion. It is not fair that someone who has money to afford an abortion can get one. Life has many challenges and like Veronique said, if the parent is not stable to bring life into the world, it will make matters worse to put your kid through it, and it would be wrong. If you are not prepared for a child you should not be force to keep it, and that should be a personal decision. I don’t understand why the government has to be so involved with the decisions people make about their lives.

References:
http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2011-05-11-indiana-planned-parenthood_n.htm

http://articles.cnn.com/2011-06-02/politics/indiana.medicaid_1_medicaid-funds-federal-medicaid-money-medicare-law?_s=PM:POLITICS

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/02/us/politics/02clinic.html?ref=medicaid

Nadine Jean said...

In Indiana, a current controversial topic is on abortion. Indiana has “a new law that would keep low-income women from using federal Medicaid benefits to receive any kind of reproductive medical care from Planned Parenthood.”(CNN) As usually there will always be people to disagree or fight against a law. In this case, the officials in the Obama administration feel that Indiana’s new law violates the federal rules. The law also has its effects meaning it “bars state agencies from entering contracts or making grants with entities (besides hospitals) that perform abortions. It also breaks any such existing contracts. That means that Planned Parenthood facilities in the state lose $2 million in federal funding funneled through the state, including about $1.3 million from Medicaid funds allocated for family planning.”(CBS) This law would not just mean people who don’t want to have babies because of whatever their situation may be, had a slip up where there was no condom or the condom broke, or those who are too young wont get the help but also means women who get raped would also not get the help. There are many opinions along with this law that are based on the beliefs if women should have abortions or not.

The Libertarian Party Platform says, "Recognizing that abortion is a sensitive issue and that libertarians can hold good-faith views on both sides, we believe the government should be kept out of the question. We condemn state-funded abortions. It is particularly harsh to force someone who believes that abortion is murder to pay for another's abortion. It is the right of the woman, not the state, to decide the desirability of prenatal testing, Caesarean births, fetal surgery, and/or home births.” (Anti-abortion) As many people may feel like the Libertarians, I agree to an extent that women should not have to pay for something that is against their beliefs. Though I do feel maybe the law should have less strict regulations. I do not think women who have been raped or is really not emotionally ready should have to suffer because some people believe that abortion is murder, or if some people do not agree with abortion either. A child should be brought into this world with a stable home, parent and love. We have enough children without homes that are in the world. Instead of caring so much about who has to pay for what we should care for the future of the children. I do agree with Vanessa when she says “its not fair to not help the people who cant pay for their abortions if their in hard times, and its also not fair to force people who don't believe in abortion to pay for people to have one.” I am also in the middle, because I feel that I can understand both sides’ opinions, I am not really for abortion but I can not persecute someone for what they believe.

References:

http://anti-abortion.info/

http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-503544_162-20065368-503544.html

http://articles.cnn.com/2011-06-02/politics/indiana.medicaid_1_medicaid-funds-federal-medicaid-money-medicare-law?_s=PM:POLITICS

shana said...

The new law in Indiana is preventing Medicaid funds to help pay for abortions. Many people think it is wrong because if someone is going through hard times or just really don’t have what it takes to provide for that baby, they should at least help. Especially if a serious experience with rape or incest or danger to the life of a pregnant woman accrued and you just don’t have enough to pay for an abortion. However, others may say if you’re willing to have a baby because you were “messing around” and just want an abortion then they should pay for it because it’s not like you don’t have control of what you do and when you do it. But if you’re ready that’s a different story but I’m on both sides of this situation. In addition, Obama goes against this as he is “attempting to block Indiana from enforcing a new law that would keep low-income women from using federal Medicaid benefits to receive any kind of reproductive medical care from Planned Parenthood” (CNN.com). Also, other opponents of the new law say “it violates federal law by depriving Medicaid patients of their choice of health care provider” (CNN.com) I don’t think this is fair and it is going to far when there are many people in need for some help an d just taking away their Medicaid patients don’t help anything. I think there should be a law to have people tell/show there living conditions and if its bad they should give them the money to have an abortion but not completely denying abortion services overall because not everyone lives the same. Meanwhile, this law also, prohibits state agencies from entering contracts with or making grants to “any entity that performs abortions or maintains or operates a facility where abortions are performed.” It also terminates existing state contracts with such entities (nytimes.com). This law has restricted a lot of things that I don’t think were a big problem in the first place but to the government it probably was just because of the rates of people that wanted an abortion last year.

So, that’s why I agree with angel when he said that the government only thinks about what’s good for them, especially when it has to do with money and the community. I also agree with noelia’s statement when she said she don't believe it is fair that people would have to pay for it and on the other hand, those who just want an abortion because they did not used protection, should pay for it because that was their mistake. Overall, this law shouldn’t be in effect because it’s not helping anyone its just making things harder to handle.

Reference:

http://www.cnn.com/2011/POLITICS/06/02/indiana.medicaid/index.html

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/23/us/politics/23abort.html?_r=1&scp=2&sq=administration%20says%20indiana%20law%20violates%20medicaid%20rules&st=cse

kiki said...

Indiana's new law discussing the end to medicaid fundings is an important topic to many people. On Friday, Gov. Mitch Daniels signed a "bill cutting off Medicaid financing for Planned Parenthood, a move that lawmakers in several states have begun pondering as a new approach in the battle over abortion"(newyorktimes). Abortion is very controversial amongst many and for the state of Indiana to cut off funds for many residents on Planned Parenthood makes it difficult. "Federal law prohibits Medicaid money from being used to pay for abortions except in cases of rape, a threat to the life of a mother or incest"(newyorktimes). Cases like Rape is very urgent. It is a good thing that Gov. Daniels promoted this decision that rape would be an acception. This new law is also getting in the way of woman's personal choices in terms of their health care providers. As "New American" says, "Because one element of Indiana’s new law blocks certain Medicaid funds from being spent at abortion providers, federal officials claimed “impermissible restrictions” were being imposed on the “freedom” of recipients to choose their health care providers"(newamerican).

In my opinion, i feel like this new law being established is completely unnecessary. I think that getting an abortion is 100% a woman's choice. Many woman today have their choices to whether or not they should get an abortion. Some woman get pregnant on accident and they don't intend to have a child and an abortion is the way to go. Others however are trapped in cases like rape or incest and getting an abortion is their only option. That is why i believe that the new Indiana law is wrong and unjust. Like Angel says, i think that the government is not worrying about anyone else's problems but their own. They're only concerned about what is best for themselves.

References:
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/30/us/30indiana.html
http://thenewamerican.com

Roudia Elysee said...

As Makayla stated although I do not believe on aborting, I believe that no matter what decision a person had made, it is unjust for a community to deny a young woman a choice about her own body due to their personal beliefs. According to CNN “new Indiana law limiting access to abortion services remains in effect after a federal judge Wednesday denied a request for a restraining order from Planned Parenthood.” The bill cuts off all government Medicaid funding to Planned Parenthood and other private abortion providers in the state. It also bans abortions after the 20th week of pregnancy, with exceptions for the life or health of the mother.

However, the Obama Administration disagree with the law, so they sent a letter to the state of Indiana refusing to accept a new law that denies state-directed funding for businesses and organizations performing abortions, except for hospitals or ambulatory surgical centers. Medicare and Medicaid Administrator Donald Berwick wrote to Patricia Cassanova, the director of Indiana’s office of Medicaid Policy and Planning, “Medicaid programs may not exclude qualified health care providers from providing services that are funded under the program because of a provider’s scope of practice,” and “Such a restriction would have a particular effect on beneficiaries ability to access family planning providers.”(NationalRightToLifeNews).

I agree with Brandi and Makayla as well as the Obama’s Administration and Medicaid Administrators; all patients should be approved regardless of their beliefs. As Makayla stated, “If a woman is unable to afford an abortion, how the hell is she suppose to be able to afford raising a child?”, In other words that is just adding more struggle and more kids on poverty to the society, especially if the mother has to keep it due to the fact that she had no kind of assistance to had it gone before it had been transformed.

*Reference:
http://articles.cnn.com/2011-05-11/justice/indiana.anti.abortion.law_1_medicaid-patients-indiana-abortion-law-abortion-services?_s=PM:CRIME

http://www.nationalrighttolifenews.org/news/2011/06/obama-administration-refuses-to-accept-new-indiana-law-denying-state-directed-funding-to-organizations-performing-abortions/

elizabeth said...

On May10th of this year republican governor Mitch Daniels signed a new law regarding Medicaid into affect. The Indiana law prohibits state funds to businesses and hospitals that perform abortion. The law also, “It prohibits state agencies from entering contracts with or making grants to “any entity that performs abortions or maintains or operates a facility where abortions are performed.” It also terminates state contracts with such entities.” So basically any clinic that has anything to do with abortion will not get funds. As a legislative director for Indiana Right to Life, Sue Swayze, approves the law saying, “This isn’t about health care services, this is about abortion.” Aside from Sue’s views, administrator of the federal centers of Medicare and medical services, Dr. Donald M. Berwick’s views are “The state law imposed…” Becky Cockram who is president of Planned Parenthood of Indiana also agrees saying, “This decision is devastating.”
My views on this subject are that they are going around it the wrong way. They can help stop abortion another way other than not funding important places like hospitals. When reading about the law in democracyforums.com I was angered when I came about, “The law could improve Daniels’ status among social conservatives as he considers standing for president in 2012. Advocates are touting Indiana as the one of the most "pro-life states in the nation" and have praised Daniels for signing the law.” I think its ridiculous what people now do for publicity. I’m not too sure if he is really for the law but its still wrong. I agree with Angel, there are many stupid laws and this is one of them.

Recourses
http://www.democracyforums.com/frontpage/index.php?s=indiana
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/02/us/politics/02clinic.html
http://www.boston.com/news/nation/articles/2011/05/12/indiana_abortion_law_allowed_to_take_effect/

jaminha said...

In Indiana, a law is being enforced that will prevent women with low income, to receive federal Medicaid benefits for an abortion, meaning that woman will have to pay for an abortion with their own money. Although the Obama administration is trying to prevent the law, state officials still insist on enforcing the law. But the Obama administration are not the only ones who have an opinion on this issue. Dr. Donald M. Berwick, who is the administrator of the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, says "The freedom of choice, is generally guaranteed by the federal Medicaid law." (New York Times.) This means that patients have the freedom of choice when it comes to abortion. i personally think if a woman with low income needs money for an abortion, Medicaid should be able to provide it for her. If a woman can not even provide for herself, how is she supposed to provide for a child? Its understandable that the government would like to save money, but by taking away Medicaid benefits, they are letting a child be born into the hands of a woman who can not provide and take care of the baby.

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/02/us/politics/02clinic.html?_r=1&scp=1&sq=indiana%20medicaid%20law&st=cse

http://articles.cnn.com/2011-06-02/politics/indiana.medicaid_1_medicaid-funds-federal-medicaid-money-medicare-law?_s=PM:POLITICS

Bill said...

Abortion is yet again under the scope of debate, this time its a law passed in Indiana that prevents low-income women from using medicaid benefits to have an abortion. So regardless of income, all women will have to pay for abortions. Indiana passed this law to show how far "Republican-led states are willing to go in pressing their tough new anti-abortion agendas"(stltoday). This law allows Republicans to enforce anti-abortion law, starting in Indiana. However, this law could cost Indiana because it might "forfeit the portion of the federal Medicaid money [Indiana] receives for various family planning services"(CNN). Not only does this law prevent any aid to women that cannot afford abortions, it could also punish the million of low-income families in Indiana. I think this law is just a struggle between Republicans and Obama. The Republicans are trying to defy Obama with this law as well as impose their belief that abortion is wrong and try to shut down anything that will allow it. This is the Republicans way of gaining back power they lost because if it works in Indiana, then they'll implement it in every other state.

References:
http://articles.cnn.com/2011-06-02/politics/indiana.medicaid_1_medicaid-funds-federal-medicaid-money-medicare-law?_s=PM:POLITICS
http://www.stltoday.com/news/national/article_89212b6b-1292-597e-a798-bcf0d37a3935.html

sade said...

I've been doing some research and I came across some information about Indianas new law on abortion, it talks about how people who want abortions have to pay the entire cost with cash up front.And that the states health crae will no longer cover abortions. One source says "It is illegal to use federal money to pay for abortions. Planned Parenthood has argued that the law could cause 9,300 Medicaid patients to lose their preferred provider to receive other, non-abortion services, such as contraceptives and cancer screening."(reuters) So basically they see it as a proble for Federal money to be used for abortions. "The Obama administration has declared Indiana’s new law that withholds some public funding for Planned Parenthood of Indiana illegal and is warning other states that some of their Medicaid funding will be in jeopardy too if they pass legislation barring any qualified health care provider."(patriotupdate) Regardless of what the President and other people with power say, the community still has an opinion and alot of people feel different about this whole topic. one person says "Yes I am in favor of abortion and I am ok if my tax money goes to fund abortions because if a mother can't afford an abortion she is likely not be able to raise the child, so who will raise that child will be my tax payer money until that child is an adult.
But the Ignorant Church People, Tea People and Gop are so stupid to thing otherwise and as always have no clue.
Instead of fixing our economy and unemployed situation they want us to spend more of our tax money raising those kids." another person who does not agree with the law says" How about they cut ALL Federal money to that state! If it hadn't been for Planned Parenthood 22 years ago I would be dead from uterine cancer now and not alive to enjoy my children and grandchildren! Planned Parenthood is so much more then just abortions!"
While others feel otherwise.
"The state argues that federal law forbids Medicaid to cover abortions in most circumstances and that the joint federal-state health insurance program indirectly funds abortions because the organization's financial statements show it commingles Medicaid funds with other revenues"(yahoonews)

so now we get the point. the people who are against the law are against it because stops alot of good benefits besides abortion, and because some people cant afford abortions so how are they going to afford a kid. people who are for the law... you know, I really didnt find much about that to be honest.

but truthfully, i dont agree with the law at all. I agree with Brandis quote...
"Overall, they are all people and should have a choice and not have to be restrained by their economical state or lack of support from their state."
iits crazy, the government should be worrying about more serious issues that dont invlove hurting those of low income , wouldnt you agree ?



"http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/06/06/us-abortion-indiana-idUSTRE7555FI20110606

http://patriotupdate.com/7542/obama-administration-calls-indianas-ban-of-planned-parenthood-illegal

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20110606/ap_on_re_us/us_planned_parenthood_indiana_13

elijah said...

Today I’ve read an article about Indiana enforcing a law that presents pregnant girls from getting money from the government to get an abortion. Based on this law the Obama administration is attempting to block Indiana from enforcing the new law that would keep low-income women from using federal Medicaid benefits. Then they had ended up acted on it by sending a letter to the state officials. Despite the Health and Human Services actions Indiana officials indicated they would continue to enforce the law. Based on what I’ve read I have to agree with Indiana because I feel like why should the government pay for something that they did. I also feel like if they didnt on their own then they should be able to deal with it on their own.

References:
http://cnn.site.printthis.clickability.com

jose said...

There’s been lots of controversy and disputes on Indiana’s new law on abortion, which is a state law to cut off public funding for Planned Parenthood. Fisher and Ken Falk of the American Civil Liberties of Indiana want a request blocking the law the case will be ruled by U.S. District Judge Tanya Walton Pratt, “Time is of the essence," Pratt said, noting that Planned Parenthood has said June 20 is the day it expects to run out of funding to provide general health services such as breast exams and Pap tests to 9,300 patients on Medicaid, the state-federal health insurance program for the needy.”(Kansascity.com) Law signed by Governor Mitch Daniels on May 10 would cut off about $1.4 million in Medicaid funds to Planned Parenthood, but Falk and Fisher agreed on $5.3 billion in Medicaid funds to the state could be at risk since Medicaid Administrator Donald Berwick rejected changes in Indiana's state Medicaid plan brought on by the law. Berwick told Indiana Medicaid Director Pat Casanova last week that federal law says beneficiaries can obtain services from any qualified provider. Obama’s administration disagrees on the new law by saying, “would eliminate the ability of Medicaid beneficiaries to receive to receive services from specific providers for reasons not related to their qualifications to provide such services.” (CNN).Even though I don’t necessarily agree on the laws for abortion because of the way that there getting rid of a human life this way. I disagree with this law because what if the parents of the child are not ready to be parents or have a low finance and cant take care of the baby and don’t want to put them for adoption that’s the only way they can rid of the baby, it should the parents decision what they want to do with the baby not the governments.

mayra class said...

By the current events articles we have been reading in class a common theme has been citizens wondering how their tax money is being used. And in Indiana the new law on abortion was passed were the person has to pay for their own abortions. Citizens believe the government is paying to much of unnecessary things and we should be focus on spending our money wisely. Now many people think this is a good law so that those who get abortions will now think twice about getting one since now they would have to pay the full amount which is a lot. The con would be many people think your are killing a human being since its an embryo. And the pro would be something teens or even some adults are not ready to deal with the consequences of having a baby they are a lot of work and money that many people might now have at that moment. I agree with brandi and the others who say we should have have this law abolished because as many have said something women are not in the right state of mind to bring a child into the world. And its better to stop the problem before something worse happens. Even though I think that you shouldn’t be having sex without protection if you don’t want a kid because everyone knows that if you use protection you have a lower chance of getting pregnant.
Reference:
http://www.buzzle.com/articles/pros-and-cons-of-abortion.html
http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2011-05-11-indiana-planned-parenthood_n.htm

Deanna =) said...

Indiana's new law on abortions and Medicaid is becomming a very big dean in Indiana. In a letter to Indiana officials, Dr. Berwick said the state law “would eliminate the ability of Medicaid beneficiaries to receive services from specific providers for reasons not related to their qualifications to provide such services.” For years, federal law has banned the use of Medicaid money to pay for abortion except in certain cases. The Indiana law goes much further. It prohibits state agencies from entering contracts with or making grants to “any entity that performs abortions or maintains or operates a facility where abortions are performed.” It also terminates state contracts with such entities. The law does not apply to hospitals. In a bulletin sent Wednesday to state officials around the country, Cindy Mann, the federal official who supervises Medicaid, said states could not exclude doctors, clinics or other providers from Medicaid “because they separately provide abortion services.” Medicaid is financed jointly by the federal government and the states. When a state wants to modify its Medicaid program, it must amend its state Medicaid plan. The changes are subject to federal review and approval. Republican Gov. Mitch Daniels was designed to keep clinics run by the private group from performing abortions, because any that did so would lose virtually all Medicaid-funded business But Indiana officials indicated they will continue enforcing the law. Planned Parenthood said that under the law, women who rely on Medicaid coverage could no longer receive services at any of the group's 28 centers throughout Indiana.

I believe that there should be no such law because anyone has their own personal right to do what they want, It’s like they’re taking away your voice your rights because an abortion is very serious and a decision of a life time which at the end of the day it’s your business, and to take that right away is a violation of a women’s rights. Also some people need Medicaid especially if they don’t have as much money to afford it they should stop sending federal money to India if they’re going to proceed with this law. I agree with everyone this law is very silly.
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/02/us/politics/02clinic.html
http://www.cnn.com/2011/POLITICS/06/02/indiana.medicaid/index.html?iref=allsearch

yaritza said...

A controversial new Indiana law limiting access to abortion services remains in effect after a federal judge denied a request for a restraining order from Planned Parenthood. The brief ruling from Judge Tanya Walton Pratt in Indianapolis means the law signed by Gov. Mitch Daniels, a potential 2012 Republican presidential candidate, can continue to be enforced.
The bill cuts off all government Medicaid funding to Planned Parenthood and other private abortion providers in the state. It also bans abortions after the 20th week of pregnancy, with exceptions for the life or health of the mother. This creates many obstacles for any woman to think about abortion as an option.
Because of the law, the state would potentially forfeit about $4 million annually in federal grants for various family planning services. Daniels had said, “Non-abortion women's services would still be available in the state.”
Pratt, who was named to the bench last year by President Obama and is the state's first African-American jurist, indicated she will need more time to consider whether the law should ultimately be allowed to stand. She said, “The process could take weeks. But her refusal in the meantime to put things on hold does not give abortion right supporters much encouragement.”
Planned Parenthood of Indiana called the law "unconscionable" and said refusal to stop enforcement at least temporarily during appeals would hurt low-income women who need family planning services
The measure specifically blocks the Indiana Department of Health from signing contracts with any group performing abortions, with the exception of hospitals and ambulatory surgical centers. Planned Parenthood said, “That under the law, women who rely on Medicaid coverage could no longer receive services at any of the group's 28 centers throughout Indiana.”
"We are deeply disappointed that the judge decided not to stop this unconscionable law from impacting Hoosiers seeking preventive, reproductive health care," said Betty Cockrum, president of Planned Parenthood of Indiana. She estimated $2 million of the roughly $3 million in organization's current annual government funding would be eliminated. Medicaid is a nationwide health program for low-income patients, funded primarily by federal money but administered by the states. Opponents of the new law, HEA 1210, said “It violates federal law by depriving Medicaid patients of their choice of health care provider.”
I believe that this law is unfair because there are many people that in need of an abortion for several reasons and can’t afford to pay for it. I think a better law would be making a woman prove that she has a good reason to abort and then helping her financially. Because if the kid is going to have health issues, it would mean that is mandatory to keep it and that’s unfair. I also agree with Vanessa those who do not believe in aborting should have if choice if their taxes should go towards abortion or not.
References:
http://articles.cnn.com/2011-05-11/justice/indiana.anti.abortion.law_1_medicaid-patients-indiana-abortion-law-abortion-services?_s=PM:CRIME
http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-503544_162-20065368-503544.html

Necolette said...

The new Law in Indiana violates Medicaid rules,it keeps private groups from performing abortions because any that did so would lose virtually all Medicaid-funded business. This controversial Law was allowed to go into effect last month by a federal judge, planned parenthood had sought an injunction at the time to block enforcement until appeals could be filed but was unsuccessful. Because of this new Law the state would potentially forfeit the portion of the federal Medicaid money it receives for various family planning services, about $4 million annually.The Obama administration said that goes too far. The state law" would eliminate the ability of Medicaid beneficaries to receive services from specific providers for reasons not related to their qualifications to provide such services." I agree with the Obama administraion low-income women cannot pay for the procedure and should have the oppertunity to have an abortion if they chose. It is unfair if only the wealthy can be provided the services, i think its more about saving money than helping the people.
References:http://cnn.site.printhis.clickability.com/pt/cpt?expire=&title=Admin...W.cnn.com%2F011%2FPOLITICS%2F06%2F02%2Findiana.medicaid%2Findex.html

lorena said...

Many people have different opinions about the new law passed in Indiana which violates Medicaid rules. According to CNN news, “the Obama administration is attempting to block Indiana from enforcing a new law that would keep low-income women from using federal Medicaid benefits to receive any kind of reproductive medical care from planned parenthood”(CNN). Women’s that are covered with Medicaid need to pay for having an abortion based on the Indiana law. The law also, “requires doctors in the state to inform patients that life begins at fertilization and that a fetus can feel pain at 20 weeks. Physician groups complain that provision violates the free speech rights and health care providers”(usatoday). So, many people would ask themselves, how would they pay for abortion if they have low-income? What about if you don’t have the money to do an abortion, do you really need to pay even if you cant even afford to take care of a new born? I understand is a very big responsibility.

I agree with this bill because if people chose to have sex, then they will have to deal with the consequences. Many have sex without protection knowing what this might lead to but they don’t care. Now things have changed in this state now that they would have to pay for having an abortion, oh well, even though you have low-income, is still killing a human being. First of all, you should not be killing them even if you ready or know because you knew it was coming. In another hand, if you get rape, is another story but you should never kill a human being. Aborting can cause mental and physical risk during your life time. I understand people would say how would they take care of the child, think about it, your in the United States where you can get a lot of the government help.

I disagree with a lot of my classmates, I don’t think, for what ever reason it is, a woman should abort, is a human being!!! Even though people have the right to decide what to do with their body, I don’t think abortion should be acceptable. I agree with Mayra in some way because why are you having sex without protection? They should use the money for other thing instead of paying for a woman to have an abortion, what about economics issues?

http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2011-05-11-indiana-planned-parenthood_n.htm
http://cnn.site.printthis.clickability.com/pt/cpt?eexpire=&title=admin...w.cnn.com%2F2011%2POLITICS%2F06%2FIndiana.medicaid%2findex.html

Gerald Tinnis said...

Federal officials are trying to block an Indiana state law targeting Planned Parenthood signed by governor Mitch Daniels. This law was signed for clinics who perform abortions to lose Medicaid funding. The people who are affected by this law are women with low income which receive medicaid benefits for any reproductive medical care from Planned Parenthood. People against this law would argue onto how a young teen who has been impregnated would come about taking care of herself not to mention a baby soon to come. There is no way someone could be ready to take care of a baby if they aren't able to take care of themselves. With that being said why would federal officials take away funding only being used to better the lives of those who need it? Someone who is for this law would argue that the government is paying to much for these conditions and rather the women who want the abortions to pay for abortions themselves fully. Personally I feel as if this law should not be passed. Humans make mistakes and tend to learn from those mistakes. By taking away aid used for helping out these people where is the hope for a better future? Also, it seems as if only the people who have low incomes are being forced into having less options of what they want to do appose to the people with higher incomes, due to low income people only being affected. I agree with Lisa when she talks about how "if your not able to raise a child how can you afford abortion".

References:

http://edition.cnn.com/2011/POLITICS/06/02/indiana.medicaid/index.html

http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2011/06/02/administration-says-indiana-law-violates-medicaid-rules/?iref=allsearch

muller said...

What is abortion? Abortion is the deliberate termination of a human pregnancy, sound crewel. That’s one reason why I like what Indiana is doing. The law doesn’t want the state to pay for abortion. If the government pays for abortion they would spend as much money they could be spending giving it to the Indiana scholarship program. According to this article I read “The program will need to spend more than 300 percent of its 2007 budget to meet the estimated need of scholars in 2017” (Indiana daily student). Therefore if this law passes it going to be beneficial but it going to cause people there jobs. That’s why the Judge Tanya Walton ruled against it; Gov. Mitch Daniels signed the bill if it passed it would of” forfeit about $4 million annually in federal grants for various family planning services”(CNN).

That’s why I disagree with most of my class because before u get to the abortion stage there’s other thing in America that u could do to make sure you don’t get pregnant like birth control pills, condoms and the 100% effective way abstinence. There you don’t have to take a life because you were irresponsible.

Reference:

http://www.idsnews.com/news/story.aspx?id=76799

http://articles.cnn.com/2011-05-11/justice/indiana.anti.abortion.law_1_medicaid-patients-indiana-abortion-law-abortion-services?_s=PM:CRIME

Anonymous said...

 A dispute between Indiana and federal Medicaid officials over the state's new abortion law cutting off some public funding for Planned Parenthood should be resolved by government administrators. The Indiana Senate approved two bills dealing with reproductive issues, “The bill cuts off all government Medicaid funding to Planned Parenthood and other private abortion providers in the state. It also bans abortions after the 20th week of pregnancy, with exceptions for the life or health of the mother.”(CNN) Indiana the first state to deny Medicaid funds to Planned Parenthood for general health services. The state argues that federal law forbids Medicaid to cover abortions in most circumstances and that the program indirectly funds the procedures because Planned Parenthood's financial statements show it commingles Medicaid funds with other revenues. “Planned Parenthood and the ACLU argue that forcing doctors to give information -- information they claim is not factual or relevant to the patients and can be misleading -- violates First Amendment free-speech protections.”(usatoday) Not everyone is satisfied especially Betty Cockrum, president of Planned Parenthood of Indiana, "We are deeply disappointed that the judge decided not to stop this unconscionable law from impacting Hoosiers seeking preventive, reproductive health care,"(CNN). This affects the annual government funding and they could possibly be eliminated.

I agree with Gerald because humans do make mistakes. It's not fair that there is a law that will deny someone from an abortion just because of certain circumstances the person went through. It's going to be hard on the people who have low-income and cant afford to have a child and that is how some people suffer having a child.


Reference:
http://articles.cnn.com/2011-05-11/justice/indiana.anti.abortion.law_1_medicaid-patients-indiana-abortion-law-abortion-services?_s=PM:CRIME

http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2011-05-11-indiana-planned-parenthood_n.htm

Darrell said...

The Indiana Abortion Law now has a policy where abortions aren't covered by any federal income at all. It is left up to the families to raise their own money for the operation which is expensive for the average family. Many believe this is an okay policy because they don't think their money should help some teenager with an abortion because the teen was being irresponsible. On the other hand, many see this as a negative step the state is making because they see it in the circumstances of a rape.

I think personally this is wrong. It does cost a lot to get an abortion. The Price varies from anywhere between $300 - $950. There are many reasons why an abortion is needed. For example, what if the female is raped and cannot afford nor can their body handle the impact of a child? She's not able to get an abortion now.

http://www.plannedparenthood.org/health-topics/abortion/in-clinic-abortion-procedures-4359.asp