Friday, May 27, 2011

Perspectives on illegal immigration

Please summarize and discuss the different perspectives on recent bills concerning illegal immigration in the United States.  Make sure to share your own opinions and make sure to comment on others. Please use citations and have at least 2 sources as your references.  Also, make sure to comment on another person's blog too.

40 comments:

Necolette said...

The new illegal immigration bill in south carolina has been a controverial topic,there has been different reactions and opinoins towards this illegal immigration bill. House speaker Bobby Harrell said" This bill gives our state's law enforcement officers another valuable tool to use in the day-to-day fight they wage to enforce our immigration laws." The new bill would allow police to ask for citizenship documentaion from anyone they stop or detain for another reason. It also allows them to hold a person who fails to provide documentaion until their citizenship status is determined. Many people think that immigrants abuse the laws of America, it is known that if a women who is pregnant comes to the U.S from another country legaly or illegaly, and haves her baby here then her baby is an American citizen. She then can collect unemployment and welfare because her baby is a citizen of the country. The director of the University of South Carolina's Consortium for Latino Immigration Studies said, that "the bill has potential to break up many Latino families. That is because many Latino families are made up of family members who are legal and illegal residents."(The Kasen Law Firm, LLC blog).

I think that the new immigration law in South carolina is nessicary, it will prevent multiple immigrants being in the United States illigeally. I also think it puts a big emphasis on immigrants, this bill also helps the immigrants who want to visit the U.S and file for a visa to get into the U.S. Additionally this provides the enforcement to deporting illegal immigrants here in the U.S and giving back the jobs of to the U.S citizens. immigrants stay here to provide a better life or because they like America, but it isnt fair if they're here illegally and taking rights and oppertunities away from the true citizens.

References:http://www.charlestonimmigrationlawyer.com/2011/04/south-carolina-women-demonstrate-against-immigration-bill.shtml

http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20110525/us_nm/us_immigration_southcarolina

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/24/us/politics/24immig.html

shana said...

In South Carolina the illegal immigration bill was approved and this bill was to simply ask anyone that police stops for their citizenship documentation. Also, allows that police to hold anyone that doesn’t provide that documentation when asked until their citizenship status is resolved/given. The South Carolina law “would make it a crime to travel within the state without proper documentation or to transport or harbor (house or hold) any undocumented person within the state. It also punishes employers who hire undocumented workers.” (yahoo.com). So, not only where they checking on people traveling from they country to the US but also those who have a job but don’t have document to prove that they actually had an approval from the government. In addition, Arizona signed the bill as well. I think it is good to have an illegal immigration bill because I don’t see the harm in it. They just want to make sure these people that are traveling have permission from the United States government. Everyone should have a fair/equal chance to come but just not legally. Opponents say that “Hispanics, in particular, who were not long ago courted by the Republican Party as a swing-voting bloc, railed against the law as a recipe for racial and ethnic profiling” (nytimes.com). Also, Democratic Representative David Mack said, “I believe this bill is racist, its mean and its punitive.” (yahoo.com). In my opinion I don’t think this is racist, because they are just looking out for their country just like anyone else would. It is out of respect and protection for their own country but it’s not about where you are from or who they don’t want in the US. For example: Crimes could be involved and someone could have just came here and never been checked or don’t have insurance and they come to the hospital for sick child. Many other ethnic groups are trying to get into this country legally, but it’s only right if they just follow through the system so that they are allowed in the United States with no problem. It shouldn’t just be against certain ethnic groups but for all to have a restriction, in which is going through they documentation system. It wouldn’t be right if they just came here legally to because it would be like they are getting special treatment. At the end of it all we're all immigrants’ just not all illegal immigrants and regardless in general we shouldn't discriminate against any group of people because of their ethnicity.

I agree with necolette because it does help and it is fair for those immigrants to actually be able to come into the US. Also, shes right about the jobs and opportunities that are taken away from US citzens because of legal immigrantion that come to get that job that people from the US are trying to get if they had a chance. So, that is another affect they have on the US as well and thats why the illegal immigration bill should take place.

Reference:

http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20110525/us_immigration_southcarolina

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/24/us/politics/24immig.html

Deanna =) said...

The Supreme Court today upheld a 2007 Arizona law on employer sanctions and employment verification, finding that the Arizona law was expressly authorized by a provision of federal law. The decision does not apply to or address other state or local immigration laws, such as Arizona law SB 1070. The new law licensing penalties on businesses that have knowingly employed workers who are not lawfully authorized to work in the U.S. but only if the federal government confirms the lack of employment authorization. We’re deeply disappointed that the Court has allowed this law, which has proven to have serious economic ramifications for Arizona's workers and employers, to remain in effect. However, the ruling does not grant states the right to enforce immigration law - the issue at the heart of current legal challenges to SB 1070, Arizona's racial profiling law. State legislators considering this decision a free pass to enact and implement legislation targeting immigrants are gravely mistaken.” Even before Obama became President Politicians have hid their intentions, not to reduce illegal and legal immigration. 1.. They would have made illegal entry a felony, just like Mexico 2. They would have data a base in airports, to chase down visa overstays 3. They would have fully funded the 2006 Secure Fence act, to be constructed as a 15 foot double layer border barrier, adorned with nasty razor wire which was under funded from the start. It makes no sense to remove the 1500 military from the border in June. The should be manning the fence with 5000 more soldiers 4. There would be 5000 US troops on the frontier with Mexico to stop the criminal carnage from spilling over and threatening landowners in all four Border States. 5 E-Verify "Attrition" program would not have been emasculated by the good old boy, Senator Harry Reid of Nevada. All business owners caught employing illegal immigrants must go to prison as their stealing jobs from the 9-Million American out of work.


I think the new law is like legal discrimination. I feel as if you look like a illegal immigrant your going to be attacked or harassed , even if your innocent. Who’s business is it that someone who came to America for what ever reason to either better their life get better jobs and support their families to stop that will if you don’t have documentation that supports their citizenship status. Also I think this law is more of a crime then being an illegal immigrant its and open invitation to discriminate anyone. I disagree with the immigration bill.

More Immigration Laws!! Current Events Reading
http://www.kpbs.org/news/2011/apr/05/supporters-rally-arizona-style-immigration-law/
http://www.aclu.org/immigrants-rights/supreme-court

Roudia Elysee said...

The topic of new illegal immigration bill in South Carolina in which allow police to ask for citizenship documentation from anyone they stop as well as it allows them to hold a person who fails to provide documentation until their citizenship status is determined, has everyone talking. According to Alipac NC is now added to the list of over 30 states that have passed state laws restricting illegal immigration. However, “we did not originally expect our Battle for NC efforts to manifest in any legislation this session. The most we had hoped to accomplish was to show the public who was responsible for our illegal immigration crisis on the state level” (ALIPAC.US)

As we all know, this law has gotten everyone talking. A pro might argue that having this law is a good thing because it would protect the US economic way. According to an anonymous pro stated that “our Government has allowed the invasion of 30 million criminals in direct violation of Article IV, Section IV of our Constitution. they force American tax payers to pay Billions to provide Welfare, Prison cells, Educate the invaders children, free medical care, massive document fraud, & are destroying our schools, hospitals, communities, culture while Robbing, Raping, Killing & Assaulting American Citizens” (Charleston.TheDigitel.com). However, a con like Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger would state that “that the claim by some conservative activists that illegal immigration is to blame for all of the state's fiscal problems is ignorant and bigoted." (Charleston.TheDigitel.com)

As in my perspective I believe that immigration laws has given people, especially cops to much powers and also it is very ignorant as Gov.Arnold Schwarzenegger stated. I hate when people blame immigrants for every little thing that happened in our society when deep down it is more than that or little do they know that the person who is a citizen / born in this country has done as much damaged as any other “immigrant” people would have. Like Deanna say its like legal discrimination. Why tag a certain group of people, it seems that they would only tag the person who they scent to be an immigrant. I believe that if they want to add this law why not searches everyone, you would never know the person that you do not scent to be an immigrant might be the one. It is not about the look! However, I disagree with Nicolette because immigrants does not took our job away , they do not even have that much opportunity as a citizen would and the jobs that they haves are the one that citizen of this country would not dare to do anyways and plus we owe it to them, because we the US always interfere with them so all they can ask for is a place to stay and have opportunities because you guys know darn well that mostly all of the things that we have here were being taking away from their land so once again why not share and compromised !

Reference:
- http://charleston.thedigitel.com/politics/immigration-debate-takes-new-tone-south-carolina-b-25416-1126
- http://www.alipac.us/article1391.html

Vanessa Bertrand said...

To get a better understanding on immigration laws we can take a look at the Arizona state immigration law that "aims to identify, prosecute and deport illegal immigrants," (newyorktimes). Those who are against it, like President Obama, said the law "threatened to undermine basic notions of fairness that we cherish as Americans, as well as the trust between police and our communities that is so crucial to keeping us safe," (newyorktimes). Though those for the law that believe it has been a benefit to them as citizens stated "people are just ignorant. The new law has been in effect for three months. It is so much quieter here. Before the law illegal immigrants could get away with just about any misdemeanor that was not violent and they knew it" (immigrationlawinarizona).

Personally I am in the middle about this topic. On one hand we all are immigrants of this land except for the native Americans. We also claim we are the land of the free and invite people to come over. Although on the other hand I agree with one thing Ricari said in class which was, why can't they go through the system?? I think that immigrants should come here legally also, but the U.S. is being really inconsiderate about the amount of time they have them wait to be approved. Its appropriate for people to wait in line, but could you blame them if they find another way to get to where they want if the line they were in wasn't moving??

References :
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/24/us/politics/24immig.html

http://www.immigrationlawinarizona.com/2011/05/05/the-immigration-law-in-arizona-artical/

mayra class said...

Immigration has always been an issue here in the United States before it uses to just be because of different illness. Over the years we have tried to limit the amount of people entering. Take a few minutes to actually notice the numerous amount of people that come from different places into the United States on a daily bases. Many would have the same opinion as Anceila who states on Friday “We are all Immigrants” The cliché is overdone people need to come up with a new line. Honestly, how many times do we need to hear this it doesn’t make a difference in my mind if I was or am an immigrant. In my case I’ve seen a lot of people from Dominican Republic come here to use the government knowing that they have houses in DR that’s they don’t need to be here but they use “FOOD STAMPS” to send food over there knowing that they don’t need it. And the funny thing of this all they don’t work of course more immigrants want to come over sounds like a perfect deal get food stamps free housing and money for yourself and your kids get free lunch sounds like a good deal to me. And that’s what makes me so upset because you’re just taking up space for those who actually want to live here. A lot of immigrants live here because they think life here is easy but what not all but a lot do is sell drugs. This corrupts our communities our teen’s and even adults which results in violence. The money from the drugs are being reported so of course our economy goes down. Melanie brought a grate point on Friday when she said many people come here just to have their baby so that they would be citizens that need to go you should be from where ever your mother is because you don’t have American blood you have where ever you came from. Maybe this way kids wouldn’t be so lost on where they come from and be proud and not confused teens who assume that being American is who they are. I agree with the article more immigrant laws we need to restrict people from coming in for our own good. America need to move forward and we can’t of were too busy providing to others. Only in 2010 we deported 350,000 immigrants this is still not counting the ones hiding the ones in jails the ones with fake papers. We need to do something before it becomes too late to go back .
Reference
Ms. Miranda’s packet More Immigration Laws!!
http://news.medill.northwestern.edu/chicago/news.aspx?id=157904

mayra class said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Makayla said...

For those that are against illegal immigrants, the common arguments would be “their taking up our health care, their taking all the jobs, this isn’t their land”. SHUT UP! America belongs to no one; in case you weren’t informed our multi-ethnic culture has been labeled as an “American Mosaic” meaning we have more than one background. Call my crazy, but it’s pretty much impossible to be a diverse country if we all come from the same place. I understand that some may believe that the illegal immigrants are taking advantage of our entrance policies, but it is our job to come up with a more strategic strict process without discriminating.

In April of 2010 it became legal in the state of Arizona to stop and question pedestrians that physically looked to be of “illegal immigrant decent”. Ignorant right? Yeah I know. This law goes against everything that America stands for. How are we to be a country of equality and liberty if we are making it legal to racial profile one another? Yes the counterargument of our resources running out has been heard. But hear this, these immigrants have come to our country and done nothing but industrialized it. From the Chinese immigrants who boosted our transportation with railroads for trains, to the African American slaves who unknowingly bred to inventors; such as Garret Morgan who invented various things such as, the first human-hair straightener, a gas mask and traffic stop light. Why complain about people who have contributed so much to our society today. It is even those illegal immigrants who take on the jobs that no one else wants to take responsibility for. From scrubbing rich people’s floors, to being a garbage man—the moral of the story is they have worked harder for their keep than those who are legal citizens and do absolutely nothing with their lives. I agree with Roudia, the illegal immigrants are not taking away our jobs or using up all of our health care, they are simply making a living for themselves. It urks my nerves that people who are nothing more than couch potatoes have the ordasity to complain, just because they see someone else taking advantage of an opportunity that they chose to ignore.

http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/subjects/i/immigration-and-emigration/arizona-immigration-law-sb-1070/index.html?scp=1-spot&sq=arizona%20immigration%20law&st=cse

http://www.illegalimmigrationstatistics.org/

Nadine Jean said...

Immigration can be a very sensitive topic considering we all have our own personal beliefs and immigration circumstances’. Slowly the government is becoming harsher on illegal immigrants as laws, bills, and reforms have been ‘put on the table’. Although, many of the laws have not been fully enforced this leads the governments of certain states, for example South Carolina, to create laws that involve Illegal Immigration Enforcement Units. Just recently in Phoenix, Arizona, “Gov. Jan Brewer of Arizona signed the nation’s toughest bill on illegal immigration into law on Friday. Its aim is to identify, prosecute and deport illegal immigrants” (NYTimes). As such a bill has been thought about being put in place I ask my self why illegal immigration matters so much to the citizens of America? I would imagine that we as citizens, that get to live a decent, luxurious life compared to the standards of people in other countries have to face with, that we would want to share our freedom with others too. Though, many people who are pro-immigration laws have feelings that do not consist of sharing a life with those who do not come into their world legally. Many citizens feel as if their hard times with finding jobs and taxes going up are because of illegal immigrants taking the jobs they could have possibly had. Also paying taxes for people who are getting to go to school for free, and who do not have to pay taxes of their own They are also helping our economy too. They buy things and when they buy whatever it is they also pay tax. These taxes add up eventually, so its not like they are just here taking up space they contribute to our diversity, new cultural experiences and etc. Though, I don’t see what the big deal is. In reality the jobs that these people do are the only jobs that can possibly get considered they are not documented. These are also the jobs that many citizens of the US would never even think about no matter what there situation is. What does not make sense to me is if we all some how have ancestors that has came to America back when there probably was no Visas and Green cards I don’t understand why should we should be so selfish and take away the same chances our ancestors got from others. It does make sense why not file to come here legally but, not everyone has family that can help make them in their cause. Also if people were not in situations that allowed them to just pull out money for their arriving to the U.S I am sure they would not be in difficult living situations in their own country in the first place. If we want people to not come illegally to the U.S we should try to help their country so that would not be in consideration, but we should not treat people like they are worth less if we don’t choose to help. Agreeing with out own president, Barack Obama says,” I think the American people have a generous instinct. They understand that we're a nation of immigrants. But if those folks are going to live in this country, they have to be put on a pathway to citizenship that involves them paying a fine, making sure that they are at the back of the line and not cutting in front of people who applied legally to come into the country” (CNN). I understand why people would want illegal imparkation laws to be harsher, though we shouldn’t penalize these people for wanted a better life. We should be flattered that people think we are living that better life. There are also many people who were brought here as a child they should not be penalized for their parents doings. Illegal immigrants should have a chance to become legal. This is a topic that I believe should not even be an issue. The most of us are all family members of people who have migrated here too.
I personally disagree with my classmates Necolette and Shana. The lack of jobs for citizens I doubt is because of illegal immigrants but is a way for citizens to have something to blame their failure on.

Refrence:

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0610/19/lkl.01.html

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/24/us/politics/24immig.html

elizabeth said...

“What I can guarantee is that we will have in the first year an immigration bill that I strongly support and that I’m promoting,” Mr. Obama said in an interview with the Spanish-language broadcaster Univision in 2008” And quite frankly many Latinos are angered because they believe he hasn’t done much of anything. Over the past year, new bills have been passed that have gotten the public stirred up. For example the bill that widened the police’s power, allowing them to stop anyone who they think looks like an immigrant and even hold them if they don’t have proof of citizenship. The Supreme Court has also backed another one recently, “The US Supreme Court has upheld a law in the state of Arizona that imposes penalties on businesses that hire illegal immigrants.” I know there are many perspectives such as, there should be even more laws to get the immigrants out since they take all our jobs and the population is increasing rapidly. On the other hand, others might think, only the Native Americans have the right to say everyone else is an immigrant since they were here first. As for me, I stand in the middle. I agree with Nicolette, bills regulating immigration are very much necessary and won’t let too many people come in. But I also think its wrong, its racist for the police to just stop who ever they think looks like an immigrant.


Recourses
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-13567783
http://thecaucus.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/05/10/obama-courts-latino-voters-with-immigration-speech/

Brandi Phillips said...

The Arizona immigration law has many ups and Downs the law states that if an law enforcement officer suspects a person of being an illegal immigrant they have the right to stop and detain them, this also requires all aliens to carry their papers at all times. Some think that the law is necessary and would help the economy and would bring down the crime in Arizona. Others like “Critics, including immigrant advocates and the American Civil Liberties Union of Arizona, say they are concerned the law will foster racial profiling, arguing that most police officers don't have enough training to look past race while investigating a person's legal status” (CNN). Although many Americans believe in the American dream and wanting to be a part of the “best” nation in the world they also believe it should be done illegally. Americans look towards the improvements to their country and what they can offer to it to make it a better place. Letting illegal immigrants come and fill U.S prisons that are maintained by tax payers and instead of officers fights criminals that are legal the have to fight the ones who are not who are destroying the country. This gives the American supports the chance to retaliate and focus on America problems not the illegal immigrants so if they can get rid of one big problem they can focus on the others. Also supporters of the Law may say that anyone can come to America and fallow their dreams but there is a process that has to been and that America isn’t just closing down there walls just restraining them. A non supporter of the might say the law is unjust can is a violation of someone’s right to privacy and is against a person civil’s rights. Non supporters might say that the authority given to police officers cannot be trusted and may be abused by the officer’s view of racial society. This would give people a right to judge base on looks which can’t always be what they seem. People who are not legal immigrants think this is a direct attack towards cretin people such as Hispanics in Arizona. American citizens are calling the law an “open innovation of harassment and discrimination against a certain group of people” (NewYorkTimes). Non- supporters call it un-American and want the law to be abolished immanently. In my opinion I am a non-supporter of then law America should own up to its problems not shut others out and blame it on them. People searching for the American dream that crated this country why restrict them now that it seems things are getting hard. Also discrimination comes into play with this law. Why just because I look a certain way should I be stop to prove I’m a citizen? It is unfair because only one group is being targeted there is not neutral jugement on who is legal and who isn’t it is legal racial profiling in a country where everyone is supposed to be equal and have the same rights. This goes to show how America still is an unfair country and does not fallow is constitution that all men are equal, so why not immigrant men? I also agree with Makayla that immigrants contributed to the American culture and society that we all know today from the things we used to the way we dress immigrants have influence us in many ways. So why would be betray them in such as way as this law ?

Ebony Beech said...

In April 2010, Arizona signed off on what is considered to be the nation’s toughest law on illegal immigrants. The law, known as SB1070, sparked a controversial nationwide debate. Police officers have been granted the privilege of detaining whoever they suspect to be an alien until that person can prove citizenship. This right was granted when the law SB1070 was passed. What impact did this law have on Americans, the answer varies depending if you’re for the bill or against it, “supporters call it a success, and opponents say it has been a disaster for Arizona's image and economy” (News Busters).
Opponents of SB1070 say the law seems to open the door to racial profiling, since the great majority of illegal immigrants to the U.S. consist of Latin American Hispanics. You can expect challenges to this all the way up to the Supreme Court. Critics say, “it was ripe for abuse, implicitly discriminatory and probably unconstitutional as well” (New York Times). The E-Verify law is another law toppled on top the already present laws oppressing immigrants. Civil liberties groups argued that E-Verify law “creates a presumptive bias against hiring Hispanics” (New York Times).
Even though the amount of people against the law is far greater than the amount for it, there are still people who believe this law was the best thing to have happened to the state of Arizona. Supporters believe it is essential to deport all illegal immigrants in order for America to prosper as a whole. They feel as though immigration is the reason behind America’s current downfall. I however fail to believe that America is in the state that it is today based on a “weak immigration system.” America’s problems cannot be pinpointed on one specific thing; it is more along the lines of a concoction of different issues.

Reference:
http://newsbusters.org/blogs/matthew-balan/2011/04/21/npr-arizona-dropped-bomb-illegal-immigration-debate-sb-1070
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/30/opinion/30douthat.html?_r=1&ref=todayspaper

noelia said...

Today, it is said that immigrants come to this country to rob and to take away public resources. These accusations are not only false but reckless. Immigrants come here to work as hard as they can even if it takes doing the dirty work no "legal" person wants to do. If the government keep making these accusations and keep making these laws, they are going to regret it because the immigrants help a lot in an everyday life of a "legal" person.

The government is trying to kick out all the, Latino immigrants I'd say, because of the job crisis the United States is experiencing. Instead of making an attempt of making new jobs, they try to go the easy way by getting all the Latino immigrants, and I say Latino immigrants because they are the only one who can be targeted as immigrants because of their physical appearance, out of the country.

Also, I would compare this to what Hitler and the Nazi's where doing to the "non-Aryans". They are dehumanizing these people where now they have to turn themselves in because of lack of documentations. Or perhaps turn in your sister, your mother, son, daughter, anyone. The only thing they have left to do so that history repeats itself it start killing them like Hitler did with the "non-Aryans" as a final solution. Is that what they are trying to do? get to a final solution to end illegal immigration?

It could also be compared to the segregation era. Where millions of black people where being dehumanized by whites. They are being racists with the illegal immigrants and once again history repeats itself.





References:

http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20110525/us_nm/us_immigration_southcarolina

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/24/us/politics/24immig.html

http://www.usimmigrationsupport.org/illegal-immigration.html

Fabiola Privat said...

Yes, it true that a new bill has been approved by South Caroline, which will allow police forces the right to ask people for their documentation of citizenship. But it will also permit the arrest of people who fail to prove immigration status, without release until proven legal. Part of this controversial topic deals with police stopping or detaining people for another reason. One reason being is if that person racial fit the illegal immigrant suspicion. The bill was made for multiple reasons; a simple one is the fact that people are illegally coming to the U.S. Ever since Arizona passed this law, a lot of emotions were stirred and massive amounts of protesting occurred.

House Speaker Bobby Harrell says, “It has become abundantly clear that if we want something done about illegal immigration, we're going to have to do it ourselves” (Fox4kc.com). It is very clear that he believes that immigration problems could be fixed with this bill. But many people are for but other are strongly against this bill. A person who is widely open to the bill is Roan Garcia-Quintana, and his hope that it will put a stop to the increase of violence. Garcia- Quintana exclaims that “We already have our own criminals. We don't need to import criminals." In addition to the violence, Illegal immigrants have the tendency to stress the economy by abusing the government aid and getting jobs under the table. As great of a country the U.S is, people abuse the things that it has to provide. For instance, an illegal immigrant can come to the U.S pregnant to have her baby, but only so that her child could be eligible for aid service that she could also use. People who come here illegally may also had the idea of working under the table, because the will not have a social security number. But this does not make our economy and better because they will not be paying taxes, while those who are here legally are. On the other hand people who are against this bill argue if the bill is constitutional. Even Democratic Representative David Mack believes that “this bill is racist, its mean and it's punitive” (Fox4kc.com). The main reason to oppose this bill according to many people is the obvious fact that it is an example of discrimination.

Though I am fully against discrimination, I feel like the bill is an efficient way to go forth about illegal immigration. But unfortunately it is not the best way to handle the situation in such a controversial way. I agree with the people who say that the law will stop job opportunities form being taken way from people who are here legally. But I also agree with Roudia when she says that the bill will give the police too much power, especially the power to be as racist as they want. There is a right way to go about the immigration problem, but that will have to be figure out by the people who are strongly worried about it, but until then, racially profiling people is not the right answer.


References:
http://www.fox4kc.com/news/politics/sns-rt-us-immigration-souttre74o0om-20110525,0,4486444.story

http://www.newsmax.com/US/illegalimmigration-NikkiHaley-Arizona-law/2011/05/23/id/397374

Anonymous said...

Illegal immigration in the United States seems to be a big concern. There are many people migrating to the United States and it seems to be a problem. In Phoenix, Arizona, Gov. Jan Brewer signed a bill on illegal immigrants which allows police officers to identify illegal immigrants and possibly deport them back to their country. This was a very brave move because just before she had signed the bill, President Obama called it “to undermine basic notions of fairness that we cherish as Americans,” (nytimes) which he believes will cause less trust between one another. When the bill was finally signed, it was said that it was going to take affect in August of 2010 and a few believe that this will be a “open invitation for harassment and discrimination against Hispanics regardless of citizenship status.”(nytimes) This has caused many questioning on how exactly this would work out, some agreed with the bill and many didn't. Recent studies have shown that in the United States there are about “12 to 15 million undocumented workers”(usliberals). The reason why so many have left their countries were due to poverty, unemployment and lacking food to feed their family.

Illegal immigration in the United States is a very controversial topic. There are always two sides to every story and honestly, I can't pick a side. I do believe that people should be able to come to the United States to have a better life, a opportunity they never had. But then again, the United States must find ways to keep the country on it's feet, which will cause more laws that would be more strict. I must agree with Ebony about how “America’s problems cannot be pinpointed on one specific thing.” Immigration may be a situation going on in the U.S but I don't think it's the main problem. I do believe there are ways of fixing this, and I can honestly say everything isn't always going to be fair because it never is. I wish everyone in every country had the same opportunities but sadly that isn't the case.

Reference:

http://usliberals.about.com/od/immigration/i/BushImmiReform.htm

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/24/us/politics/24immig.html

lorena said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
lorena said...

More immigration laws had been pass during the pass years. This laws can be overwhelming but others see it as something normal. For example, we can see the that in May 24th, 2011 it was passed, “a comprehensive illegal immigration bill that would allow police to ask for citizenship documentation from anyone they stop or detain for another reason”(news). This law also holds any individual who denies to show their documents until their citizenship is approved. Immigrants are being affected by this law because they wont be able to have jobs. According to the South Caroline bill, “the law would make it a crime to travel within the state without proper documentation or to transport any undocumented person within the state. It also punishes employers who hire undocumented workers”(news). Furthermore, this law can be oppressive to those who come to the United States in hope of having a better life for their family. Also, Undocumented individuals cant no longer have freedom in their own state if this bill keep spreading. Unfortunately, the state of Arizona also passed a law against illegal immigrants. This bill, “its to identify, prosecute and deport illegal immigrants”(news). This bill is very threatening because innocent people are being punish and deported to their country for no reason. Additionally, they have to carry “their alien documents at all times and requires police to question people if there’s reason to suspect they’re in the United States illegally”(CNN.com). Its depressing to see how this law can affect those who come to this country for a better opportunity. This bills can be so discriminated at times because some stop people who “look” illegal and ask them for their documentations.

I strongly disagree with this laws. Many people in the United States who are here legal are so for this kind of law because they think the illegal immigrants are taking way their jobs. This is very false, many come to work and this will better the US economy. One good thing is that, “president Obama says he is planning another push for immigration reform in the coming weeks and months. He met with congressional Hispanic Causus about the issue earlier this week”(Public Radio). I hope President Obama can do something and pass an immigration reform so it can help those who come here for a better life. I don’t understand why there’s so many people who agree with this laws. We all illegal because this country doesn’t belong to no one, even to those Americans who think they own this country. Their family once immigrated to this country, and yes, they did started low, now they have become citizens of the United States. Specially those who are who are born here believe that this is their country, which it is but they have their family who once came here illegally. I believe that they should pass laws that targets those who come here to do nothing or those offenders who keep coming in to create more violence. This kind of laws are also separating families. People are so cruel, like I don’t know what they would think if they were in their shoes. Come on, be realistic, your not going to tell me that your entire family are legal in this country?

I agree with what Roudia stated, people think that illegal immigrants are the only one doing harm, which is wrong because those who are here legally can also do it too. I also agree with Noelia, how history repeats itself, because they are being racist with this kind of laws. Some say that they want to make this world a better place, but how? With this none sense that is going on in this cruel world. In another hand, I disagree with Necolette because she believes that illegal immigrants are taking away rights and opportunities from true citizens, but I don’t understand how? Most of them come here for a better life because they could not get those kind of resources in their own country.

Resources:

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/24/us/politics.24immig.html

http://newsyahoo.com/us_immigration_southcarolina

Public Radio *

Kevin Fernandes said...

This week there has been more animosity goin on between people who are for immigration and people who are not. This whole thing is evolved around the new South Carolina rule which police are able to ask for citizenship documents froma anyone they stop or detain for another reason. There are some Americans who are all for this and believe basically its not rite for immigrants to invade America and try an take their hard earned jobs or they are sayin that the immigrants come here and are not doing the jobs that ordinary immigrants would be known to do. The people who are for this new rule are all for it simply because the think that every immigrnt should come to America by following the correct procedure which is to apply for a visa and wait for how ever long it takes to come and then be able to go to America without having to worry about new bills like this one being passed. The people who are anti this bill are in support of immigrants because they agree that being poor in other countries is nothing like being poor in America considering when people are poor in other countries what they go through and can not have but in America when some one is poor they get helped and have a better chance of surviving. Thats why some immigrants come here and not only for that reason but to better their life which is a good thing not all immigrants are bad ones. I am not in support of this bill either because along with the other Americans this bill is wrong and is similar to the black codes which was made before to keep blacks down and this bill is being made to keep all immigrants down. I also believe that police being able to randomly check people for there papers is uncalled for first because its not like people are going to carry around there papers in there back pockets and this bill is also bias because of course the police will be askin for papers from those who "Look" as though they are immigrants. I believe that makeing people carry there papers to proove the belong here is history repeating its self because this can date back to when Hitler made jewish people crry around there documents or wear the star of david on there arm to identify them selves which was also bias. To end the topic and really say why im not for this bill is because when America was founded it was founded by people who did not have a visa who also could have been related to us which could make us all immigrants. The South Carolinas House of Representatives obviously have no respect or no clue about great ancestry to create a bill like this.

Refrences:

More Immigration Laws article

Melodie Miranda

angel said...

on Tuesday May 25,2011, South Carolina House of Representatives approved a Immigration bill that was supposed to target Undocumented Immigrants. Not specifically any Immigrants but the ones who transport drugs and narcotics into the US. but what they are doing is that their actually targeting the ones that just come here for a living. The whole point of this Immigration bill is that the police has the right to stop you and ask your for your citizenship documentation. Now if we look at it the highest rate of Undocumented immigrants we have in the U.S are Latinos. In my opinion this is discrimination because if the police sees two people walking and one of them is Hispanic and the other is Caucasian you know for sure he is going to ask the Hispanic looking one for documentation. The Cop could probably ask the Caucasian person for documentation as well just to make it seem like he is not discriminating. Moreover, Nikki Haley "the U.S.-born daughter of immigrants from India, who has expressed her readiness to sign this bill"(latino.foxnews.com).

Overall, this Immigration bill would not grant anything to this state because this is affecting the Immigrants who come here for a better living. You really think this is going to stop narcotics from coming into the U.S? you must be out of your mind. There would always be a way to smuggle drugs into the U.S some how no matter what the government does. In my point of view i think this is just an excuse for the government to get rid of Undocumented Immigrants because certain people believe they are taking up their jobs, not paying taxes, and more. But lets say you were an Undocumented Immigrant and you came from a really poor country would you want to go back over there? were you cant even get clean water ? were people fight over food ? were you don't even have a roof to sleep under?. Lets send you back over there since you want to be sending people back to were they came from. >:)

(http://www.fox4kc.com/news/politics/sns-rt-us-immigration-souttre74o0om-20110525,0,4486444.story)

(http://latino.foxnews.com/latino/news/2011/05/25/anti-immigrant-approved-s-carolina-lower-house/)

lisa said...

The recent bills passed on illegal immigration are a tough one. This bill allows for an officer, when you get pulled over for any reason, to ask for your documentation of citizenship, and keep you detained until it is provided. Just recently the South Carolina House approved a bill, similar to the Arizona immigration laws, called South Carolina Immigration Compliance Act of 2011. This bill also also punishes companies or businesses that hire illegal immigrants (SC State House). People against the immigration laws can argue that illegal immigrants work jobs that most Americans wouldn’t think twice of doing, that deciding who is an illegal immigrant can only be done by racial profiling, that illegal immigrants do pay taxes when they buy goods, therefore helping the economy, and that America is supposed to be about freedom (Illegal Immigration Statistics). Hundreds of illegal immigrants have families they need to provide for and America is holding up a big welcoming sign. For example, the National Endowment of Humanities website specifies on the meaning of the Statue of Liberty: “It is the Mother of Exiles, greeting millions of immigrants and embodying hope and opportunity for those seeking a better life in America. It stirs the desire for freedom in people all over the world. It represents the United States itself, (NEH).”
Then on the other hand, people who are for the bill can say that there are many Americans who do not have job, or have gotten laid off that need to support their families, but can’t find a job because they are taken by the illegal immigrants. Also, they say that the crime rate goes up because illegal immigrants, that illegal immigration cause for overpopulation, which is why countries have quotas, and that we are supporting them with our taxes, like providing them with an education (Illegal Immigration Statistics). Some even say that if illegal immigrants are as hard working as they say, why not work hard to get to the US illegally? I am not encouraging illegal immigration to continue, but I do encourage that the ones already living in America and are not doing anything illegal, besides the obvious, should not get deported.
Like Vanessa said, I’m mostly in the middle, both sides have valid points and have every right to be mad. Most young Americans feel like Nadine and say that they don’t see the big deal, but this affects every single one of us.
References
http://www.scstatehouse.gov/sess119_2011-2012/bills/3148.htm
http://www.realclearpolitics.com/news/ap/politics/2011/May/24/sc_house_approves_illegal_immigration_bill.html?utm_medium=twitter&utm_source=twitterfeed
http://www.illegalimmigrationstatistics.org/weighing-illegal-immigration-pros-and-cons/
http://edsitement.neh.gov/lesson-plan/statue-liberty-meaning-and-use-national-symbol

Kyane said...

I start my blog with the first amendment is that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press, or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.” (Bill of Rights) The Bill of Rights gives the people the right to have its freedom but not only do other states agree with the immigration laws but the United States has this hatred towards immigrants as if these are a different species. My opinion is that immigrants should not be treated as these threats but also to not pass the law of the law enforcement being able to stereotypically arrest people who fit the criteria. I found a person who perspective was “How would a law enforcement officer determine “reasonable suspicion” other than basing this suspicion on the color of someone’s skin or their ability to speak English?” (Arizona’s Anti- Immigration Law) Why should we give the law enforcement a law to supposedly stop immigration when it’s like an undercover way to racially hunt down people? I agree with Lisa it’s a middle opinion for me because it’s illegal to have people here because it can be dangerous for our nation to be over populated but also its very disrespectful that we treat immigrants with a sort of non- human factor.

http://www.ushistory.org/documents/amendments.htm#amend14

http://www.immigrationpolicy.org/perspectives/arizonas-anti-immigration-law-also-anti-faith

kiki said...

The Immigration Laws issue is a big concern in the US today. The new bill in South Carolina that was addressed on May 24th discusses the pros and cons of illegal immigrants. Some people argue that immigration laws should be passed because it "allows police to hold a person who fails to provide documentation until their citizenship status is determined"(more immigration laws packet). Others however believe that the immigration laws is not right and should not be allowed. As representative David Mack says "I believe this bill is racist, it's mean and it's punitive"(more immigration laws packet). As for the Arizona Ruling on illegal immigration, "an Arizona law punishing employers for hiring illegal immigrants was an energy boost for state lawmakers across the country who have proposed bills this year to curb illegal immigration" (newyorktimes). A hand full of states, not only Arizona, have passed laws that is similar to this issue.

In my opinion with this controversial topic, i don't really have a side. I'm half and half with this one. As my fellow classmate Vanessa says, we are all immigrants on this land somehow and it would not be fair to limit our rights just because we flew in from another state/country that is not the US. However, it will be more organized and less complicated if immigrants apply for documentation and a visa much quicker so things would be less hectic. There are a lot of immigrants today and for the Supreme Court to deal with that it would make sense why so many people would want to pass these immigration laws.

References:
http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20110525/us_nm/us_immigration_southcarolina
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/28/us/politics/28immigration.html?_r=1&scp=1&sq=more%20immigration%20laws&st=cse

veronique said...

Immigration has become one of the US problems to the point laws have been made and illegal acts have been down. Now in order to limit people from moving country to country other countries limits how many people can go a year. There are two sides to the story many people may say we as the United States was founded upon immigrates and the other may say they take opportunities to those who live here. Let’s be honest even though we were all once immigrates and needed one person from our family to move so we could live a suitable life now there are laws. In order to keep the US in order we most have law abounding citizens it doesn’t mean the people from another country are bad but if we visit another country aren’t we suppose to come custom to their rules and way of life. The US is only doing what is right for its people so that in the end it benefits us. The US like another country would only do what they believe is right to help their own. In addition, not every immigrate who comes in wants to change their life or come for an opportunity. I agree with Mayra not every immigrate who comes wants to better their life but to find illegal ways in trying to make fast money. The US Immigration Support states, “Some immigrants also move to a foreign country to give their children a better life. In countries like the United States, children of illegal immigrants automatically gain citizenship.” I agree but it also states the come because of illegal activity. I mean hey its two arguments that have good and bad but I believe take any means action if necessary if it means saving or helping the lives of many.

http://nation.foxnews.com/illegal-immigration/2011/05/31/dnc-chair-republicans-believe-illegal-immigration-should-be-crime


http://www.usimmigrationsupport.org/illegal-immigration.html

Bill said...

Immigration has been apart of America since the beginning. As of lately, immigration laws are being passed and enforced, increasing the debate over whether these laws are discriminatory or protecting America. Those for these laws are stating that this for the good of America, former border patrol officers say that immigration laws are “designed to protect Americans and U.S. society from things that are seen at the time as dangerous or bad for us” (NAFBPO). However, those against it feel that these laws are discriminating against ethnic groups. Even Obama is against states having their own immigration laws, stating that it "would be chaotic for states to create their own immigration policies"(fox). These immigration laws are either helping or hurting Americans and I could not care less. I just do not care whatsoever.


Reference:
http://www.nafbpo.org/nafbpo_whylaws.html
http://latino.foxnews.com/latino/politics/2011/04/27/obama-states-immigration-laws/

Zazil said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Zazil said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Zazil said...

It seems like immigration laws have been become very controversial debate here in the United States. In 2010 Arizona’s governor Jan Brewer signed an immigration law, which is known as SB 1070. This law made it legal to for law enforcements to stop anyone who looked suspicious of being an undocumented, which mostly targets Hispanics. This law brought up the debate of whether or not racial profiling will become a problem, Ms. Brewers response is, “racial profiling [will] not be tolerated.” (New York Times) Many other states have followed in Arizona’s footsteps. South Carolina recently “(May 24th, 2011)” (Yahoo News) passed a bill that allows law enforcements to ask for documentation, when they have been “stopped or detain for another reason.” (Yahoo News) In addition, this law also allows law enforcements to “[punish] employers who hire undocumented workers.” (Yahoo News) David Mack, a Democratic Representative believes that this “bill is racist, it’s mean and it’s punitive” (Yahoo News) I agree with David Mack, this bill is very racist, when you have someone who fits the profile of undocumented immigrant it is very hard for someone not to make a stereotype, therefore it becomes racial profiling.

I agree with angel’s statement “this is just an excuse for the government to get rid of Undocumented Immigrants because certain people believe they are taking up their jobs, not paying taxes, and more” it is true that many who are against Undocumented Immigrants feel threaten. I feel that this is the same way Native Americans felt when the pilgrims came to the United States and stole all their goods and built a country out of what they had taught them. Many say history repeats itself and maybe Hispanics are a threat to Caucasians in the sense that Hispanics are coming, quickly growing as a population. Caucasians came to the United States and over threw Native Americans that lived here; they made it their own country despite the fact that someone already lived in that land. Everyone is an immigrant, and there shouldn’t be rules about who should be allowed into a country and who should not. We are all human and we should all be treated the same.

Reference:

http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20110225/us_nm/us_immigration_southcarolina

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/24/us/politics/24immig.html

Necolette said...

I agree with Deanna, the new illegal immigration bill in South Carolina is almost a form of discrimination against other ethnicities. The police having the power to ask for legal proof of citizenship could seem harsh but it has to be done for the safety and proper way to handle things.

Briana Martinez said...

Some believe immigration laws are a form of discrimination, while others believe it's a way to be mindful of those that were born in America. Resources are definitely limited, and there are times when you have to be selfish. Every immigrant should become a citizen of the United States the same way. Immigration laws are helpful for our government to keep track of people. Of course it's no ones land but there is absolutely nothing you can do about it. Don't waist time debating about "everyone is technically an immigrant." And do not be a hypocrite.
The South Carolina illegal immigration bill allows "police to hold a person who fails to provide documentation until their citizenship status is determined" (Huffpost Politics). The bill is just a way to be sure of things. Many have tried to change the government's flaws, but have failed. If you're not an immigrant, you shouldn't be worried.

Resources:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/05/25/south-carolina-immigration-bill_n_866729.html

sade said...

Illegal Immigration Bill :


In Arizona, the illegal immigration law was passed in april of 2010, based on my research i found that the law
" Makes it a crime under state law to be in the country illegally by specifically requiring immigrants to have proof
of their immigration status. (Los angeles times) i found another quote that said "Both proponents and critics alike said the law
was the broadest and strickest immigration measure in generations (new york times) i feel that the immigration law is just
like the Domino theory due to the fact that once one state does it, another is sure to follow, after Arizona, Georgia
followed the Arizona law, and afterwards South Carolina did the same. Some people feel that the immigration law
is like an "open invitation for harassment and discrimination against hispanics regardless of their citizenship status." (Nytimes)
however other people feel that the law is a good thing. one person, unnamed says "This is presumably a good thing because it would help the US be able
to control how many people are in the country and to know who those people are. Second, it might make the general public's anger decrease --
they might be happier once there seems to be less breaking of the law."
personally i could care less, I agree with Vanessa, we are both neutral about the whole situation.
if they were to stay or to go. they are not effecting me. But those who are doing harm to our country should go, but if not leave them alone.


http://latimesblogs.laimes.com/washington/2010/04/arizona-illegal-immigration-law-jan-brewer.html


http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/24/us/polotics/24immig.html


http://learning.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/04/26what-do-you-think-about-the-new-arizona-immigration-law/


http://www.enotes.com/law/discuss/what-advantages-disadvantages-arizona-immigra-84049

sade said...

oh & i agree w/ Vanessa again about how she said we are all immigrants of this country.

Gerald Tinnis said...

Recently an illegal Immigration bill has been approved by South Carolina's house of representatives. This bill gives police police permission to request citizen documentation from anyone they stop or apprehend. This type of power allows police to arrest anyone who lacks such documentation until their citizenship can be proven. Someone against this new bill would argue that
it is an open invitation for harassment and discrimination against hispanics regarding their citizenship status. They would also argue that Arizona's new law uses a vague reasonable suspicion standard, allowing selective immigration enforcement through racial profiling. This would lead to constitutional violations so long as the law is in place. Someone who is for the immigration law would argue that the law itself was designed to mimic federal immigration laws. Since illegal immigrants are already required to register and carry documents with them there should be no reason why this new immigration law should affect them. Since illegal immigrants are in terms of violating he federal immigration laws, being arrested is simply furthering the penalties they've earned. This also explains my reasoning onto why i agree with the new immigration law. I also agree with Necolette when she states that the law will prevent multiple immigrants being in the United States illegally.

References:

http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20110525/us_nm/us_immigration_southcarolina

http://roomfordebate.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/04/26/will-arizonas-immigration-law-survive/?ref=politics

lorena said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
lorena said...

i agree with Zazil and Angel, yes we all human and no one should be considered more than others because we all equal. Also, in a side note, theres many students who come to the U.S to have a better education which will make this country the place of opportunities.

muller said...

As South Carolina passes the new immigration bill you have to look at the Arizona state immigration law. The Arizona law was past to protect their citizen as GOV brewer said "I remain steadfast in my belief that Arizona and other states have a sovereign right and obligation to protect their citizens and enforce immigration law in accordance with federal statute,"(msnbc). That what influenced South Carolina to take on this law? With this law in place it will it will help the economy as I read on Necolette blog it said that Immigrants were talking from the government in for of food stamp and I agree with that because there using tax payers money.

As I look at the South Carolina law I think is modern version of discrimination. If you look immigrant you’re going to be bothered, even if you’re innocent. Whose fault is that immigrant came America for whatever reason to both better their life get better jobs and support their families. A lot the is cause Sen.Martin, who is a co-sponsor of the two Senate bills, says “illegal immigrants cost the state a lot of money” (charlotteobserver). That’s why this current situation goes both ways.

Reference:

http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/42537304/42796152

http://www.charlotteobserver.com/2011/01/03/1951774/sc-immigration-law-idea-has-some.html

elijah said...

A new illegal immigration bill has been approved by the South Carolina's Representatives approved. This illegal immigration bill would allow police to ask for citizenship documentation from anyone they stop. The law will also make traveling within the state without proper documentation a crime. According to House Speaker Bobby Harrell thinks "it has become abundantly clear that if we want something done about illegal immigration, we're going to have to do it ourselves"(NEWS). Bobby Harell also stated that "THis bill gives our state's law enforcement officers another valuable tool to use in the day-to-day fight they wage to enforce immigration laws"(NEWS).

On the other side there are peolpe who thinks its wrong. Such as David Mack a Democratic Representative stated "I belive this bill is racist, its mean and it's punitive"(NEWS). David Mack feels like "South Carolina is too determined to be locked into the Republican national agenda"(NEWS).

I feel like its a good idea because it would stop people from immigrating into the state and doing illigal things.

Jocelyn S said...

Coming from a state where illegal immigrants and their rights have seen strong disagreements throughout the course of years, Florida has recently passed a “watered-down bill to curb illegal immigration. The bill would require the police to make “a reasonable effort” to determine the immigration status of people they arrest and jail, a provision that opponents say is an Arizona-style attack on legal and illegal immigrants” (NYTimes.com). Now, allow yourself time to think on who exactly this bill targeting. Is it the blond haired, blue eyed immigrant from Germany, or the olive skinned man, who’s hands have been hardened from work that Americans themselves are too proud to do? But before I get into my portion of beliefs, let me share a few things to consider. The U.S. has been in an economic struggle for many years now, and quite frankly there are fewer and fewer jobs available to the common American man. Along with that, America is considered such a great nation because every child is offered a free education, and which we all know, is the key to any form of true success. With that said, schools and other necessary government funded programs need our tax money funding allowing the argument that these immigrants aren’t contributing to our nation as they should. But people opposing this bill might debate who are the people that created this land are? I reassure you they were not the indigenous people of North America. IMMAGRANTS left their country and made this land what it is today, ILLEGALLY, who are we to take that right away from ANYONE? The immigration bill passed in Arizona was a bit harsher in its conditions as opposed to the ones Florida was aiming to pass, like allowing an officer to arrest someone upon pulling them over for any reason and the person not having proof of citizenship. After dividing the Republicans in Florida, on June 2nd of this year the law passed “would require employers to screen prospective workers using a federal immigration database” (businessweek.com). Some say that the trend started by Arizona has begun stalling out “immigration laws were introduced in 28 states this year, but passed in just three, Georgia, Utah, and Indiana”(businessweek.com) I cannot say that emigrational laws are neither right nor wrong, for both sides have points in which I must agree with, so just as Lisa said, I stand with Vanessa, in the middle not being able to choose a single side to agree on. Do I believe they should be allowed here, yes, WITHOUT harassment but they should contribute to your nation just as every other American? Absolutely not.
http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/11_24/b4232036298720.htm
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/05/us/05florida.html

tarahn said...

In South Carolina there has been a new law that has been passed; some refer to this as The New Illegal Immigration Law. This law basically states that the police can ask for documentation of people who are suspected to illegal based on probable cause. Some say this law is racist because it causes law enforcement to use racial profiling to essentially convict undocumented immigrants, but on the flip side others are saying that the law enforcement are just trying to keep our country safe and serving justice to those people who are in the country illegally.


In my opinion I think it’s wrong to ask people who are suspected of “looking like an immigrant “for documentation. I completely agree with Deanna because this law basically puts a big target on individuals who look/ are suspected to be illegal immigrants. There are numerous other ways to crack down on illegal immigrants from getting into the country , for example having tighter security on boarders, granted every solutions has it flaws but anything is better then discriminating potentially innocent people.


http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/24/us/politics/24immig
http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0610/19/lkl.

jose said...

South Carolina’s House of Representatives just passed a new immigration bill allowing law enforcement to stop and question them for their citizenship documentations “papers” as much of America calls it, even if they haven’t broken the law just because they might look suspicious. “Proposed changes to South Carolina’s immigration laws would require all businesses to check their workers’ legal status by using a federal database, a move that is receiving little resistance from the business community.” (thestate.com) “The changes also would allow the S.C. Department of Labor, Licensing and Regulation to suspend or revoke businesses licenses, tax licenses and any business documents filed at the S.C. Secretary of State’s office. But the labor department would no longer be allowed to impose fines on businesses that violate the law.”(thestate.com). I don’t agree with this bill because I don’t understand why does the U.S. want to get rid of the immigrants they take all the dirty jobs that we don’t want which are the hardest for the lowest pay and don’t complaint about nothing. What if the cops stopped someone on the road of getting their papers has a clean record and just want to leave a normal American life and the police stops him/her and him/her will get deported and probably lose all they worked so hard for we should only make bill to get rid of the thugs, gangsters, drug dealers ect. Its hard to differ them but we can do it and I also understand theirs too many of them in the country but that’s no the right way to get rid of them.

http://www.thestate.com/2011/06/02/1842770/sc-scrambles-to-make-changes.html#ixzz1OXshNwnY

freiter said...

In the united immigration has always been an issue and has always been a topic of debate but ever since the very controversial Arizona laws as there more widely none as that were brought in to play the debates have been taken to another level because these bills at the most basic levels grants state police and other authorities the power to stop and ask people for there residency papers. And if they can not be proven to be legal citizens in the United States they could be deported with no questions asked.



People who approve of this bill state that the pros are there will be more jobs available for those legal citizens that are out of jobs because they believe that immigrants take up many jobs ,another reason people support this bill its because if we don’t tighten the laws on immigration drug dealers, and even more criminals from more countries will continue invading the U.s. as suggested in the article Should America Maintain/Increase the Level of Legal Immigration? Joe Messerli



Others who go against these bills feel like these laws are unconstitutional and take away our freedom of privacy further more it makes America seem like they are less welcoming of immigrants of other countries and contradicts its foundation,is so harsh that even president barack obama got involved "he called for a federal overhaul of immigration law..... followed up by saying the arizona lawhreatened “to undermine basic notions of fairness that we cherish as Americans, as well as the trust between police and our communities that is so crucial to keeping us safe.”as stated in the nytimes article Arizona Enacts Stringent Law on Immigration written by Randal C. Archibold.

in my opinion i believe that these bills are completely out of line, and my reasons for saying this is because all these laws are doing is making the racial tension between the Americans and the rest of the world worse because these laws just show how hypocritical america. i say this because america wants to stick there noses in everything that they should not be putting it in a perfect example of this is the Israeli and Palestinian conflict there is no need for america to get involved in a civil dispute when it is the u.n's job to resolve this Dilemma . some may argue that illegal immagrants take all the jobs that legal citizens that resign in the united states could have but given the option of being offered a job cleaning toilets in a big building in downtown or being a wealthy persons house maid or working your but off in a field doing hard field work all day for a payment of minimum wage the lower class american would not take the opportunity because of the labor being so hard,or there not being enough benefits why although i agree with the fact it would cut down convicts and drug dealers and drugs getting imported into the country i believe there or other ways of handling that like working more closely with the D.E.A and finding out more affective methods. lastly no matter how u look at this bill being passed all around the country is gonna do more harm then good because your just opening the doors for citizens from the Americas and other ethnicities like middle eastern to be openly harassed and racially profiled by police officers on the daily bases whether leagal or not. i think this bill is just another poor excuse for america to divert from more serious like the the war being fought in the middle east and things in that nature.





REFRENCES:

http://www.balancedpolitics.org/immigration.htm

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/24/us/politics/24immig.html