Sunday, May 22, 2011

Israeli/Palestinian Conflict

Please summarize and discuss the different perspectives on the Israeli/Palestinian Conflict. Make sure to share your own opinions and make sure to comment on others. Please use citations and have at least 2 sources as your references.

43 comments:

Diva_The_Don said...

Today in class we read the article, "A Synopsis of the Israel/Palestine Conflict." While reading many questions and persepectives came up. After the reading we had a pretty productive and successful debate. Some students argued that the people of Israel have the right to take over the native land of the Plestinians because their bible claims so. Others argued that the people of Israle do not have the right to invade land because the Palestinians were their initially.

We also took a step over and oppinionated on Obamas aid to Israle. On behalf of the United States supporting Israle, I do not concur. I understand that it was out of generosity, but this is just creating conflict for the US. The fact that now we are technically involved, is alarming. Not only did Obama contridict himself by coming into the white house in favor of the Palestinians and now supporting Israle, but he is also putting the country on stand-by. By that I mean, we can be part of this big mess anytime. We have enough issues within the country to be taking part of others.

What I dont understand is how the people of Israle are going by the bible, claiming "their land," yet they are fighting and killing people. How are you obeying the bible when your commiting sin?

Vanessa Bertrand said...

On one hand you have the Israelites who believe they deserve the land because it was promised to them by God. On the other hand you have the Palestinians who believe that the land belongs to them because they've been there first. Then on the awkward misplaced third hand you have the U.S. trying to negotiate peace while backing up Israel. The U.S. made the wrong decision. Tue Palestinians are being oppressed, yet we choose to give aid to the oppressors. Many people fail to realize "President Obama is not the negotiator-in-chief for the middle east and to make sweeping demands and characterizations not only hurts the peace process, but damages U.S.-Israeli relations" (cbn.com). Also Israel just can't put limitations on the Palestinians lives when the Palestinians were the natives of the land. But then again it makes sense why the U.S. would choose the Israeli side because it too showed no respect to it's native landers (the Native Americans) in the past.

As my classmates have said, this fight may not end for a long while, because "Palestinian Authority President Mahmound Abbas hs said he will not negotiate until Israel has agreed to cease all settlement construction," (cbsnews.com) which they refuse to do. In my opinion the solution to this problem over land could be involving Europe. The piece of land Israel and Palestine are fighting over should clearly go to Palestine, but Europe should give Israel an equal amount of their land since they are part of the reason many jewish people migrated there and took most of an occupied land. Europe is usually at fault for these type of conflicts due to their history, but they always find a way to sneak backstage.

Reference :
http://www.cbn.com/cbnnews/world/2011/may/obama-to-pressure-Assad-offer-aid-to-reformers-/

http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-503544_162-20022270-503544.htmlhtml

mayra class said...

I've read several articles since we have began this new unit. And this has just concluded my thought that maybe America should mind its own business. To many times we try to control other countries when in our own mother land we are having so many problems and we try to cover our own problems by focusing on other countries when the U.S. should be spending the money here were we need it and not in other places.Religion is a very complex issue all over the world.And threw out the class today during E Block the question came up stating "if they are following the bible than why are they fighting and killing" and alot of people began to pounder on that thought. And if someone who answer that because I myself am a little confuse if this has more to do with religion or more about a group of people wanting a piece of land?

Anonymous said...

Today in class I gained more knowledge about the conflict between Israel and the Palestinians. This war has been going on for quite a while and the situation seems to be very complex. Unfortunately, there hasn't been any progress in resolving this ongoing dispute between Israel and Palestine. Both sides believe that they are entitled to the land. One of the many reason why the war had been initiated was because of the Jews biblical birthright and by the Palestinians, who seek self-determination as shown in (http://www.trust.org). The fight for the land has brought many economic problems for Palestine and as for the territories, they have not gotten any better. As for Israel, they will not give up until that land is theirs, which means they will do what ever it takes even if it means destroying peoples lives. In the article “The Deadly Cost of Home,” it describes how 75% of kids from ages 4-18 in Israel were suffering health problems due to a rocket fire that had hit Israel because of Palestine. This was not the last rocket fire that had struck, so just imagine how many homes had been destroyed. In the end both sides believe that God gave them the land, and that to give it away or to give it up to another people is an insult to God.

This war that has been going on for over 60 years and it has been a never ending situation. I believe that peace will be hard to find again because in this case, both Israel and Palestine will not go down without a fight. I have to agree with Zazil because Israel has initiated a war that they can't even seem to win. I find it very heart wrenching because not only is this war nonsense but they are ruining the lives of innocent people. Each death of a innocent human being leaves a stain beneath the ground. A stain that remains permanent, representing the pain and sorrow of those who past away. This is something no one can take back but I hope the war ends and gives back the healthy life style the innocent people deserve.

Roudia Elysee said...

After reading the article on the conflict between Israelis and Palestinian, I found it extremely ridiculous how two country are causing so much conflicts and deaths for just a piece of land; that I believe that they can just share. According to Roger A. Lee from HistoryGuy.com, The Israelis believe that they are entitled to the land now known as Israel; while the Palestinians believe that they are entitled to the land they call Palestine.Unfortunately, both sides claim the same land; they simply call the land by different names. Furthermore, for religious Jewish Israelis and religious Muslim Palestinians, the belief is deeper still, for both sides believe that God gave them the land and that to give it away or to give it up to another people is an insult to God and a sin. Day and day, the situation had gotten worst. However, they never tend to see the damage and risk it is putting their people into, especially the generation that is growing up into this world. According to the article of “The Deadly Cost of Home”, the outcome of the attack of the Israelis toward the Palestinian were stated, thousand of young children suffering from things like “traumatic stress, living in poverty as well as dropping out of school.”

What I found really shocking is that the president of the United State Barack Obama is supporting such a cruel thing. It is not that it is a bad thing but why would put the United State in such position by siding with Israel, a country who was celebrating their independence day “the fulfillment of their aspiration to have their own land and country” stated by Kristine, while people in Palestinian are crying and going to so much pain like Shana said. Moreover, how could you not back up the country that you favored entering the white house? I just found that really unusual.

As a conclusion, I believe that we are in a very bad position, and this whole situation is just a big mess. Everyone is contradicting themselves and I do not see any end of this, it is not going to get any better; it is only going to get worst, until people start to compromise. Going back to Melanie’s question at the end of her blog, I ask myself the same question, I do not think it is about God at this point, it is all about greed because I know damn well that the bible does not state that people should cause so much tension and take innocent people’s life for just for a piece of land, well it does not say anything about killing PERIOD! This is Ridiculous.

Reference:
http://www.historyguy.com/israeli-palestinian_conflict.html

http://www.voicesofyouth.org/en/post/the-deadly-cost-of-home

Kyane said...

My perspective comes from the late 1800's where the Zionist began to take over the Palestine land. (Synopsis) Once I read that segment of the article where it began with the Zionist taking over I realized that tension will always begin because taking over someone's land is some what messed up but I feel that the Jewish people need their own place to call a home. I continue with information of how "more and more zionists immigrated to Palestine - many with the express wish of taking over the land faor a Jewish state.... (Synopsis) This situation caused more tension because of the Jewish people moving into the Palestine nation. I feel that Israel should develop their own country or atleast try to come some agreement with Palestine. Another isssue I had was the invovlement of the UN. "in 1947 the United Nations decided to intervene... the UN chose to revert to the medieval strategy whereby an outside power divides up other peoplele's land" (Synopsis) Why would the UN want to try a stradegy that failed in the past? Another article I read was the perspective of the Israeli people and how they are being mistreated in their own nation. Why would the article only do a bias story towards the Israeli's rather than the Palestines? (The Deadly Cost of Home)

http://www.ifamericansknew.org/history/

http://www.voicesof youth.org/en/posts/the-deadly-cost-of-home

sade said...

In class on Friday, we read an article called "The Deadly Cost of Home." The summary of this article was about a conflict between the Isralies and the Palestinians and which of the two deserved a land that they both wanted. Based on the Israeliis, they believe that the land belongs to them due to the fact that in the Bible , some scripttures read
Exodus 3:16-17
[16] “Now go and call together all the elders of Israel. Tell them, ‘The Lord, the God of your ancestors—the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob—has appeared to me. He told me, “I have been watching closely, and I see how the Egyptians are treating you. [17] I have promised to rescue you from your oppression in Egypt. I will lead you to a land flowing with milk and honey—the land where the Canaanites, Hittites, Amorites, Perizzites, Hivites, and Jebusites now live.”’

Exodus 23:23-24
[23]For my angel will go before you and bring you into the land of the Amorites, Hittites, Perizzites, Canaanites, Hivites, and Jebusites, so you may live there. And I will destroy them completely. [24] You must not worship the gods of these nations or serve them in any way or imitate their evil practices. Instead, you must utterly destroy them and smash their sacred pillars.

Exodus 23:30-33
[30] Little by little I will drive them out before you, until you have increased enough to take possession of the land.

[31] “I will establish your borders from the Red Sea to the Sea of the Philistines, (The Med) and from the desert to the River. (The Euphrates) I will hand over to you the people who live in the land and you will drive them out before you. [32] Do not make a covenant with them or with their gods.[33] Do not let them live in your land, or they will cause you to sin against me, because the worship of their gods will certainly be a snare to you.”

Joshua 13:1-3
[1] When Joshua was old and well advanced in years, the LORD said to him, “You are very old, and there are still very large areas of land to be taken over.
[2] “This is the land that remains: all the regions of the Philistines and Geshurites: [3] from the Shihor River on the east of Egypt to the territory of Ekron on the north, all of it counted as Canaanite (the territory of the five Philistine rulers in Gaza, Ashdod, Ashkelon, Gath and Ekron—that of the Avvites.
these are just some scriptures in the King James Version Bible that declare that GOD gave the Israelies the land.
However the Palestinians believe that the land belongs to them due to the fact that they were there first. I read an article called "The Origin Of The Palestine-Israel Conflict" on a website called "If Americans Knew" on quote from this reading was "Palestinians have a real grievance: their homeland for over a thousand years was taken, without their consent and mostly by force, during the creation of the state of Israel" So this is basically saying that since they were there first the land should belong to them. I feel however that if the Land was promised to the Israelis by GOD then they should wait to GOD allows his promise to happen rather than to go and take so forcefully. I also feel that if it was so much of a big deal, since they both wanted the land so bad, why not spilt it equally avoiding all of the violence. oh and another thing America really needs to mind its own problems and its own buisness I feel like America always jumps into something, and then at the end they regret it. this also can be prevented if they just handle their own problems.



Refrences :

http://www.israel-pride.com/what-is-the-christian-view-about-the-whole-gazaisrael-conflict/

http://www.ifamericansknew.com/history/origin.html

Briana Martinez said...

Some believe there is no problem with Israelis controlling and taking over Palestine. Others believe that it is not fair and that it is definitely a problem. And because of the conflict, "Palestinians in the West Bank, including Jerusalem, have lived under Israeli occupation since 1967" (BBC News).
Either way, it's a conflict between Israel and Palestine. Not the United States, nor any other country who has a history of interfering. According to a source, "the United States...launched a more sustained 'peace process' in 1991, after the Gulf War" (All About Palestine). I believe everything happens for a reason. People have the tendency to believe whatever the government tells them, and it is one of the reasons why there are many different opinions about this conflict. The United State's government is not worried about the Israeli and Palestinian conflict, our government is worried about how it will effect the United States.

Resources:

Necolette said...

The Israeli palestinian conflict, has been an issue for many years in the middle east. From the article we read in class"The Deadly Cost of Home" writen by a youth writter Kristen, she states" A Home costs dearly indeed and for nearly a hundred years, both the israelis and the palestinians have been paying for it with their lives." This middle eastern conflict has affected the land and the realtionship between the israelis and palestinians but most of all their children. Kristen writes " About 75% of kids aged 4-18 were found to be suffering from post-traumatic stress after rocket fire from palestinian militants targeted their town on nearly daily basis. The youth of both israel and palestine has been greatly affected because the issues of their two countries. The conflict has braught poverty and multiple problems towards the youth for many years.

I believe because the Isrealis have been said to have been"promised" the palestine land, through their "Bible" and also the palestinians who live there will never stop fighting for there land.The fighting will never end between these two countries, without any other interveining country getting involved. Even though it is between the two i still think that president Obama has done the right thing and the U.S should get involved in helping and being allies with Israel,this can hopefuly end the struggle for the people in Palestine.

References:http://www.voicesofyouth.org/en/posts/the-deadly-cost-of-home
http://www.ifamericansknew.org/history/

Kevin Fernandes said...

On Friday i read an article on the Israeli and Palestinian conflict. To be honest i think the conflict will be a never-ending subject. My thoughts are this because Israelis are going to forever think that the land belongs to them since they say words from the Bible basically hinted that the land was promised to them by God according to the passage in "genesis 15:18". Regardless they will take the word of God over anything because of their beliefs and forever believe that land is theirs. Also we have the U.S intervening in the conflict sending the Israelis seven million dollars a day of taxpayer's money, which is only adding fuel to the fire. Also making the Israelis think they are correct about the land belonging to them since the U.S is taking their side. In the other corner we have the Palestinians who have that piece of land the Israelis want but believe since it is owned by them, they feel that this is unjust how the Israelis are trying to invade and take over land that is not theirs and also by passing the Palestinians rights to own property. Israelis are violating the people of Palestine by killing people and dehumanizing children. Also the U.N. Charter is in violation because first of all they took a piece of Palestine and created Israel basically taking land away from them. So i believe that each side will not give in on the passing of the land and this will be a soon forgotten conflict but will still be going on just no talked about as much as it is in the media now.

If I could give my input I would say the whole topic is uncalled for because Israelis had occupied 22% of Palestine in the 1967 war but the law basically said you can not acquire territory by war so it was not claimed as Israeli land only occupied by them along with Egypt. However the Israelis are being greedy because they are fighting over land that can be split in a simple agreement and live in peaceful coexistence as they did before. For centuries there was no conflict between the two, which is selfish of each side that conflict would arise now.

Refrences:

http://www.voicesofyouth.org/en/posts/the-deadly-cost-of-home

http://www.ifamericansknew.org/history/

jonathan said...

After considering both sides of this conflict. I realized that the fighting was originaly over a group of migrating zionist(a small portion of the jewish population). When the indigenous population felt threatend because of the volume of people that were coming in to try and take over the land they fought. Fighting led to bloodshed and tears,as well as it not solving anything. The massacres and killings went against the israeli bible way were violence and killing isnt allowed. Before this became any worse, the United Nations came in and offered a plan were they tried to divide up their land, but it was rejected. Since israel was established in palestine in 1948, it belongs to the arab nations and not to the israeli. To me the palestinian were only trying to contain within what was theirs and the israelis are just trying to make it more than it is.


References:

www.science.co.il/arab-israeli-conflict.asp

http://www.ifamericansknew.org/history/

Makayla said...

Makayla Campbell:

After reading "The Deadly Costof Home" and "A Synopsis of Israel/Palestine Conflict" I came tothe conclusion that the United States is doing too much. I don’t understand whythe U.S is trying to be “Captain Save A Country” when we clearly have our ownissues that we need to focus on. The issues between the Israelis and Palestinesis between them and needs to stay that way. The U.S strives to save everyone,but ends up causing more conflict in the end. Who are we to intervene? As muchas I love Obama and I vouch for him daily, he needs to relax! The drama begandecades ago because the Israelis believe God promised them the land so theyshould be able to have what is theirs. When in reality, the Palestines havebeen their all their lives and worked hard. If I were a Palestine, I wouldfight for my land also. What kind of mess is that, where I’ve lived somewhereall my life and a group of people want to kick me out because some piece ofpaper in a book, promised them what is mine?!?!?! I think not. 





An Israeli Prime Minister MenachemBegin, exclaims the victory of 33 massacres as, “As in Deir Yassin, soeverywhere, we will attack and smite the enemy. God, God, Thou has chosen usfor conquest”(If Americans Knew, p.2). His selective word choice shows that heand his followers have no remorse for the distraught they have brought amongstthe land; God has chosen them, so they shall never give up. The Israeli peoplecontinue to celebrate their victory and believe they are on top through thewords of former Israeli Prime Minister Golda Meir, “There is no such thing as aPalestinian” (If Americans Knew, p.2). Showing that they have moreoverdominated the population and they now rule Palestine. Today the people ofPalestine have unfortunately seen no changes. Majority of the population arekids who spend their lives in refugee camps, with daily torture and executionsfrom the Israeli soldiers. Many debate the controversial topic of the $7million the U.S gives to Israeli PER DAY. Some believe the U.S is turning thecold eye to those in need (the Palestines) by feeding Israeli such amounts ofmoney, daily. America is doing nothing more than helping their habit of abusingpower and torture.





Reference:



http://www.ifamericansknew.org/history/

lisa said...

It’s amazing how I go about my life and not know my history or any current events. In class we are discussing the clashes of the Palestinians and the Israelis, and the whole ordeal is ridiculous. Israeli believe that God gave them the piece of land as their "promise land" so they deserve to have it, and the Palestinians will not give the land up because they were there first.

In the article, “The Deadly Cost of Home,” by Kristine, representing the Voices of Youth, I learned more about the lives lost, the suffering children, the overcrowded schools, and the overall conditions of both states. Regardless at who is at fault, both Israel and Palestine are worrying too much about land, and are forgetting about their people. According to Kristine, in Israel, “90 percent of residents have had a missile exploding in their neighborhood,” and in Palestine, “700, 000 of them were driven out of their homes.” At that rate, other countries were bound to intervene.

As indicated by the If Americans Knew Organization, the United Nation took it upon themselves with the “medieval strategy” to carve the land and divide it between Israel and Palestine. The way I see it, as I read through the website’s statistics, “0 Israeli homes have been demolished by Palestinians and 24,813 Palestinian homes have been demolished by Israel since 1967,” and "1,084 Israelis [were killed] and at least 6,430 Palestinians have been killed since September 29, 2000." Both states have over stepped boundaries. I feel as though Israel is pushing Palestinians by conquering more and more land, because "Palestinians have been living under Israeli military occupation... functions such as education, health care, infrastructure and policing, Israel retains overall power." On the other hand, the Palestinians have a strong case of antisemitism. They have sent their people to Israel for suicide bombing many times to kill as many as they can, and they massacred several hundred Jews in the 20's and 30's. There should be compromise. During Fiscal Year 2009 the “U.S. is providing Israel with at least $8.2 million per day in military aid,” and what are they using the money for?
At this point I don’t know how this conflict can be put right. Who is the US or the UN to decide what is best? And if no decision is made, will this battle continue for more decades to come?

References
http://www.voicesofyouth.org/en/posts/the-deadly-cost-of-home
http://www.ifamericansknew.org/

kiki said...

The Israel/Palestine conflict is an ongoing conflict between the Israelis and the Palestinians that has been occuring for many years now. This conflict is mainly about "who will gain control of one piece of land, the Israelis or the Palestinians"? These two territories have perspectives that differ from one another in many ways. First off the Palestinians believe that they should win over the land because they migrated on West Bank and Gaza first and they brought "democracy into this suffering world"(chomsky). While on the other hand, the Israelis feel like this land was promised to them by God himself. Both Israel and Palestine have performed dangerous acts towards one another due to this major conflict. One such as the Palestinians voting "the wrong of way" and therefore the U.S joined Israel and punishing Palestinians for their misconduct (chomsky). In response the Israelis "conquering seventy eight percent of Palestine; three-quarters of a million Palestinians had been made refugees" (Americans knew).

As previously said, this conflict does not look like it will resolve anytime soon. This back and forth between the two territories will keep on going until there is some sort of agreement present to state that both Israel and Palestine will come in contact with this piece of land. Since Israel has performed most of the destruction towards Palestine, i think most of the land should be given to them. But who knows both territories are at stake here and if and when President Abbas of Palestine agrees to stop all this destruction, then maybe we will see a bright future for Israel and Palestine.

References:
http://www.ifamericansknew.org/history/

http://www.newint.org/features/special/2007/08/20/chomsky/

elizabeth said...

Subsequently talking about the conflict the Palestinians are having with the Israeli, I've noticed how everyone has different views on the subject. There are those who think the Israeli deserve the land due to the fact that according to their religion, God promised them the land. But then of corse others believe the land belongs to the Palestinians since they are already there and don't even have the same religion, so to them the Bible's statement does not apply to them.President Obama believes,"For the Palestinians, efforts to delegitimize Israel will end in failure." I for one, agree with him. I believe the Israeli will not give up on such a promise. For example how it is said that prime minister Netanyahu, "used his three-day Washington visit to put an exclamation mark on his settlement views, telling the pro-Israel American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) that “Jerusalem is not a settlement. It’s our capital." I think their conflict will go on for ever, even though it has already been going on, so forever more. Probably in a few years the Palestinians will understand the Israelis' faith is very strong and on going, and they'l give up. What has this world gone to? People are risking their lives and loved ones over the ground, literally.

Resources: http://www.pbs.org/newshour/extra/features/world/jan-june11/obamaspeech_05-20.pdf

http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Foreign-Policy/2010/0324/Obama-s-strategy-in-Israeli-Palestinian-conflict-at-crossroads

mayra class said...

I've read the article " The Deadly Cost of home" and "A Synopsis Of The Israel/Palestine Conflict" since we have began this new unit. And this has just concluded my thought that maybe America should mind its own business. To many times we try to control other countries when in our own mother land we are having so many problems and we try to cover our own problems by focusing on other countries when the U.S. should be spending the money here were we need it and not in other places. The U.S. is giving 7 million dollars per a day it might look like a small amount to support a hole country but it does add up and America is in debt 4.00 billion per a day(U.S.National Debt Clock). We are in a crisis ourselfs so why would we get into more debt and as a result close doors for ourselfs? When America us to be the country at top and now we are slowly becoming a country that has power and no money which as a result is effecting our citizens and causing budget cuts.Religion is a very complex issue all over the world.And threw out the class today during E Block the question came up stating "if the Isralian are "Zionists who immigranted to Palestine" who follow the bible, what gurantees that they are interpeting the bible because people have differnt ways of breaking down a text. And if they are following the bible than why are they fighting and killing" and alot of people began to pounder on that thought. And if someone who answer that because I myself am a little confuse if this has more to do with religion or more about a group of people wanting a piece of land? In history we have witnessed many people fight for countries based on Greed and thats why we see the affects we see today. And its still around today history does repeat it self and this would be a perfect example to show that even in this time of the year people are still going threw conflicts we had before. So the U.S. I understand wants to help out because I know for a fact that the U.S. has resources that many wish they could and if it was the opposite way I would of wanted someone to help my people too.

Reference :
http://www.brillig.com/debt_clock/

http://www.ifamericansknew.org/history/

http://www.voicesofyouth.org/en/posts/the-deadly-cost-of-home

noelia said...

It seems that land is a mayor cause of war. Last Friday I read an article titled "The Deadly Cost of Home"(Voices of Youth), where it talks about the Israelis attacking the Palestinians for a piece of land. Although the land originally belonged to the Palestinians, the Israelis want to take over it.

Today, we read another article titled "A Synopsis of the Israel/Palestine Conflict"(If Americans Knew). This article went a little more in dept with the fight between the Israelis and the Palestinians over a piece of land. In this article it talks about how the combination between Hitler's rise to power and the Zionist activities and the Jewish refugees being placed in Palestine grew conflict. In my opinion, the Jewish people didn't have any fault because they where being kicked out and they had no where to go, but yet, they can't just take over. They know the land is not their land, so they might as well take it easy, stay but don't try to take over. In the other hand, the U.S. has nothing to do in this conflict so why are they getting involved if the conflict is not their business? The U.S. is always getting involved in other peoples problem and they always want to give aids to try to help which is why they always end up in war.

The Israelis should just give up and let the Palestinians keep the land that was originally theirs because kids are suffering from it and it's just going to end up as war once again.


References:

http://www.voicesofyouth.org/en/posts/the-deadly-cost-of-home

http://www.ifamericansknew.org/history/

Brandi Phillips said...

According to my research the conflict between Israel and Palestine is unjustified on both sides. I have read an article written by a youth leader name Kristine who is a supporter of the Israelis. She explains their existence and religious reasons why they are there, but plays on the abuse and brutal treatment of the children that are witnessing the war first hand. She summarizes that the presence of the Israelis are misunderstood and the Palestinians are not reasonable and they are effecting the youth in tremendous ways. In addition, to my reading I have read an article from a web site (ifamericansknew) that was in favor of the Palestine’s and is accusing the Israelis of abusing their land. Another factor that contributes to the conflict is the U.S, who is allied with the Israelites, which makes the conflict even more controversial. The involvement of the U.S leads to the involvement of the U.N which makes matters more sensitive since they have the final say (Middle East politicos). In my opinion I think the Israelites are abusing the Palestine’s Natural Rights that everyone is entitled to. Based on John locks interpretation of the Natural rights which are life, liberty, and the right to own property they are abusing the Palestine right to own property by trying to take over land that is not theirs, and invade the people who live there. This is unjust because they are not respecting the land that can be shared between both groups of people. The Palestinians are responding in a violent way that can result into more destruction of the land that they are fighting for. They should respect the Israelis and their coexistence in peace. In all, I think that both sides are wrong for fighting and should compromise to stop the war for both countries sake.

References:
http://www.ifamericansknew.org/
http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0511/55190.html

Anonymous said...

In class I learned more about the conflict between Israel and the Palestinians. This war has been going on for quite a while and the entire situation seems to be very complex. Unfortunately, there hasn't been any progress in resolving this ongoing situation between Israel and Palestine. Both sides believe that they are entitled to the land. One of the many reasons why the war was initiated was because of the “Jews biblical birthright and by the Palestinians, who seek self-determination,” as shown in the article “Israeli-Palestinian conflict” (trust). Palestine believe that they have the right to keep the land especially when it is theirs. The fight for the land has brought many economic problems for Palestine causing poverty and their territories have not gotten any better. As for Israel, they believe that they are reclaiming their religious legacy by taking over Jerusalem.
They will not give up until that land is theirs, which means they will do what ever it takes, even if it means destroying peoples lives. In the article “The Deadly Cost of Home,” it describes how 75% of kids from ages 4-18 in Israel were suffering health problems due to a rocket fire that had hit Israel because of Palestine. This was not the last rocket fire that had struck, so just imagine how many homes had been destroyed. Both countries involve religious reasons for taking the land, “In the end both sides believe that God gave them the land, and that to give it away or to give it up to another people is an insult to God,” as shown in the article “The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict”(historyguy). In the end,

This war has been going on for over 60 years and it has been a never ending situation. I believe that peace will be hard to find again because both Israel and Palestine will not go down without a fight. I have to agree with Zazil because Israel has initiated a war that they can't even seem to win. I find it very heart wrenching because not only is this war nonsense but it's also ruining the lives of innocent people. Each death of a innocent human being leaves a stain beneath the ground, a stain that represents the pain and sorrow of those who suffered. This is something no one can take back and I hope the war ends so that the innocent people receive a healthy life style.

Reference:

http://www.historyguy.com/israeli-palestinian_conflict.html

http://www.trust.org/alertnet/crisis-centre/crisis/israeli-palestinian-conflict

Bill said...

Death and destruction for a land that the Israelis believes, biblically, belongs to them oppose to the Palestinians that live there. The Israelis traveled to Palestine to "reclaim" their ancestral homeland(ifamericansknew), which at first, did not bother the Palestinians. It was until more of Israelis came and tried to take over the land completely. Fearing that they would be displaced, the Palestinians retaliated, which led to the conflict that is still being fought today. This conflict that began with a religious belief, a belief that masked the true intentions of the Israelis that came to Palestine. The Israelis came to Palestine with the intent of displacing the Palestinians and making Palestine a wholly Jewish state(ifamericansknew). They didn't go to Palestine based for religious purposes, they wanted a Jewish only land, religion would only serve to justify their pursuit.
{http://www.ifamericansknew.org/history/)
(http://www.ifamericansknew.org/history/origin.html}

Zazil said...

The war between Israel and Palestine has been going on since mid 1900’s. It first began in the late 1800s when, “a group in Europe [who] decided to colonize this land. Known as the Zionists, they represented an extremist minority of the Jewish population. Their goal was to create a Jewish homeland.” (A Synopsis of the Israel/Palestine Conflict) In the late 1800s there was not a lot of conflict. The highest percentage of people who lived there where Muslims with eighty-six percent, followed by Christians with ten percent, and the least where the Jewish with only four percent. This seemed to be a peaceful set up but, fighting broke out when Hitler rose to power. This is when many Jewish did not have a place to go because they were not in any countries universal obligation. Since the mid 1900’s there has been nonstop fighting between Israel and Palestine. Many people have died due to this war. In the reading The Deadly Cost, it explained how a man named Kamel Shraydeh went into a hiding in a refugee camp since he was thirteen years old. Now he is a seventy six year old. Both sides have risked many lives and I do not think it is correct for a certain racial group to go into hiding. It also does not make sense to keep fighting since both sides are losing. In addition, it is not correct to retrain one group of people from living in a land in which they once shared peacefully.
One side is receiving more money as Kevin pointed out; the U.S sends 7million dollars a day to Israel. This is obviously helping the Israel side a lot more than Palestine. I feel like both articles we have read are in Palestine side because they are not showing what Palestine has done wrong. To me I feel like both countries are at fault for what has occurred but I feel like Israelis have provoked a fire in the Palestinians.

References:
http://www.ifamericansknew.org/history/
http://www.voicesofyouth.org/en/posts/the-deadly-cost-of-home

Zazil Mardones

muller said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
muller said...

After reading the articles on the Israelian and Palestinian i think the feud between them is never ending.As i look over the article "the deadly cost of home" by krisrne she put the Palestinian in the wrong for what they were doing.therefore when the U.N. decided to intervene in this problem they added fuel to the fire,because of what the Jew belief was that the land was given to them due to the passage"Genesis 15:18". as a us citizen i think the us stuck its foot in a pot whole because they were sending 7 mill. a day of my hard earned tax money. therefore the 22% of Palestinian get mad and angry because they want the land. The Palestine’s are in charge for the violence that cause more destruction of the land that they are fighting for they should respect the Israelites and live in peace. According to (BBC News) the Israelites were willing to stop the ease blockade. so there willing to give in a little.

This battle may not end for a long period, due to the Palestinians not planing on giving up because of there beliefs. Also the Palestinian were killing Innocent kid and bombing the Israelites. Bombing the cause more tension like the when "Palestinians employing suicide bombers" (seattletimes). therefore this war isnt going to end anytime soon


reference:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle+east-10520844

http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/news/nation-world/mideast/wars/

Camila said...

Over the past two days my class and I have been reading articles and doing research about the Israeli/Palestinian Conflict. The conflict is that the Israelis and the Palestinians are both claiming the same land. The Israelis believe that the land belongs to them because in the Bible it states that the land is promised to them by God. The Palestinians however, believe that the land is theirs because they were there first. They have been fighting for over 60 years and thousands of people have died over this piece of land. Just last week “On May 15 Israelis celebrate their independence day, the fulfillment of their aspiration to have their own land and country. On the same day Palestinians commemorate the Nakba, the day of catastrophe when more than 700,000 of them were driven out of their homes. On its 63rd year last Sunday, the Nakba took a violent turn when thousands of Palestinians and Arab supporters marched towards Israel’s borders, resulting in a deadly clash with Israeli troops” (The Deadly Cost of Home). Each side refuses to give up what they believe is theirs and are willing to fight and kill one another until they reach victory. After so many people have died, the US felt as if it was their place to step in and be the negotiator. During a speech on May 19, 2011 at the State Department Obama stated "The United States believes that negotiations should result in two states, with permanent Palestinian borders with Israel, Jordan, and Egypt, and permanent Israeli borders with Palestine" (Obama lays out U.S. vision for supporting Arab democracy, resolving Israeli-Palestinian conflict).However, nothing is set in stone and both sides still haven’t made anything official. In my personal opinion I believe that the land belongs to the Palestinians because they were their first so I don’t think that the Israelis have the right to take something that wasn’t initially theirs.


http://www.voicesofyouth.org/en/posts/the-deadly-cost-of-home

http://news.yahoo.com/s/yblog_theenvoy/20110519/ts_yblog_theenvoy/obama-lays-out-u-s-vision-for-supporting-arab-democracy-resolving-israeli-palestinian-conflict

Nadine Jean said...

After reading a couple of articles about the Israel and Palestinian conflict, I have begun to form an opinion of my own. To what I believe this is a fight against religions for territory. For the US to put their ‘foot’ in some one else’s mess is ridiculous considering we have our own problems that are not solved yet. Though, I realize for the US to stay in boundaries is unrealistic after the many times in history we have intervened. If life was as easy to just make an agreement to split and share the land without any more fighting would be better for the people who now are victims of this war. Israel seemed to be pushing their way into conquering more land even though they have had more than enough already. They already had 78 percent of Palestine when the war was over. Why is it that in 1967 they were still going for more land? Why did they attack a US ship Navy ship, killing many American people and yet we still are helping Israel? Israel has gotten enough, and is pushing the limits. The Israel religion believes they should occupy all of Israel because the land had been promised to them by Abraham. This has been their goal and may remain their goal as long as they believe in their faith. The conflict goes back into biblical times as states in the bible, “this land, from the river of Egypt, to the great river, the Euphrates—the land of the Kenites, Kenizzites, Hittites, Perizzites, Rephaites, Amorites, Canaanites, Girgashites and Jebusites” (Genesis 15:18-21) is the land described to be what is now the Israel area. In the Bible God said to Abraham, "To your descendants I have given this land, from the river of Egypt to the great river, the River Euphrates" (Gen 15.18). Though the Bible claims that the land was to be inherited to the Israelites, agreeing with Kristine, a young teen from Voices of Youth, “A home costs dearly indeed and for nearly a hundred years, both the Israelis and the Palestinians have been paying for it with their lives. The latest in fact was just last weekend; at least 15 people dead.”

Many of my classmates shared in a group discussion that the US stepping in will not solve much. I agree, though putting in facts from history we, the US, is known for helping certain sides. In a nutshell, this is a conflict that can go for years and never be solved until one party is completely destructed.

Reference:

http://focusonjerusalem.com/ipl.html
http://www.voicesofyouth.org/en/posts/the-deadly-cost-of-home

Fabiola Privat said...

On Friday we have touched upon the conflict between the Israelis and Palestinians in the Middle East. We learned about how there has been an ongoing tension between the two groups dating back since 1900s. Their conflict even began with each group blaming other for problems which bloomed in their society, causing people around the world to have the own views on this topic. The article “The Deadly cost of Home,” which we discussed in class, describes the relationship between the Israelis and Palestinians. But thing escalate even more on May 15, the day Israel celebrates their independence. On that same day, the Palestinians were commemorating a disasters day, but it took a turn when “Palestinians and Arab supporters marched towards Israel’s border, resulting in a deadly clash with Israel troops” (Voices of Youth). But all this conflict becomes even worst when a strip of land is in sight of both the Palestinians and the Israelis.

For the Palestinians, they have occupied this land long than the Israelis have. Yet for the Israelis, they believe that the Bible promises them a Jewish homeland and believed they have found it. But, both groups calming the land is not what makes things worse for them, it is the constant act of violence develops this situation. Ever since the Israelis attacked the Palestinians, the child of their society has been exposed to the continuous violence on daily basis. Many people might see it as the Palestinians are face much great trouble because of the grate poverty the people live under. It became so bad that “poverty has force young people to drop out of school and earn some money by scavenging” (Voices of Youth). Yet this does not make since as to why the U.S has sided with Israel by aiding its economy a great deal. When I say largely, I mean an average of $7 million per day, which means “the most U.S funds to Israel than to any other nation (A synopsis of the Israel/ Palestine Conflict).

My view on this situation is very simple. I do not side with either side so I believe that the U.S should not either. Even though we are helping Israel on their self- determination, Palestine’s government is also suffering too. There should be a time that occurs where both sides decide how to peacefully solve this problem, but war is inevitable. So it the U.S support either side, there is the greatest chance that we will get pulled into the war and spend even more then $7 million dollars on this conflict. So it is fair to say that peace in the Middle East will take a while to occur.


References:
http://www.ifamericansknew.org/history/
http://www.voicesofyouth.org/en/posts/the-deadly-cost-of-home

Cynthia said...

Thomas Szasz says, “Two wrongs don't make a right, but they make a good excuse.” And I agree 100 percent with this quote.

According to Historyguy website, “the Israelis believe that they are entitled to the land no known as Israel, while the Palestinians believe that they are entitled to the land they call Palestine”. Their excuses goes about 2,000 years ago, “when the Roman Empire ruled this area, and in suppressing several Jewish rebellions, the Romans destroyed the Jewish temple in the city of Jerusalem” (Historyguy). That of course killed large numbers of Jews, and forced many others to leave their homeland in an exodus called "The Diaspora." However, some Jews remained in the area, but large numbers of Jews did not return until the 19th and 20th Century. Especially after the war and the Holocaust.

I believe Israelis and Palestinians are both wrong. If you’re not familiar with the movement called “Zionism,” It happen in 1940 when lots of Jews moved to Palestine which influenced many Jews from everywhere to move to Palestine to reclaim their ancient homeland. I think this is a mistake on their part. It’s common sense that once you lose something, it hard to get back and make it your own again, especially if it was taken from you. What I’m trying to say is that the Jews should have not been so confident thinking they can make Palestine their homeland again. The Historyguy article also stated, “While many Arabs were willing to sell land to the incoming Jews, many other Palestinian Arabs were worried about becoming a minority in a country they considered their own.” In reference to the article, obviously the Palestinians we’re not going to be so generous and let the Jews get too comfortable too fast in the land the made theirs. To me it seen like the Palestinians are proud of the the Romans work which killed most of the Jews population and forced many of to depart.. Seen to me like they’re proud of the fact that, “in the year 1900, the population of Palestine was 600,000, of which 94% were Arabs,” (Historyguy). I’m not surprise. Not one bit.

That is just the beginning of all this madness between the Israelis and the Palestinians. They both have excuses which only escalate the matter. It’s unfortunate that they’re still at war for something that should had be deciphered, for something that can still be solve. But they rather fight and kill innocent people! They rather fight for what they “believe” in! They rather fight till one surrender. It been years, no one ready to waive. Instead, they deliver their concepts to the next generation over and over again. It reached the point that other countries are now involve.

I agree with some of my classmate, for explain Vanessa Bertrand who believe that Palestinians should own the land. After all they was there first.

REFERENCES:
http://www.historyguy.com/israeli-palestinian_conflict.html

http://www.quotationspage.com/quote/27559.html

Melodie said...

Please make sure to check for grammar and have citations

Jocelyn S said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Jocelyn S said...

Since biblical times the Jews have been enslaved, prosecuted, and condemned. God's chosen people, Jews, were promised a land, where they are to be free. The conflict between Israelis and Palestinians will be a never ending battle, due to the fact that because Jews have been so oppressed in the past they believe they are now entitled to Israel, the land in which Palestinians, Jews, and Christians all lived in peace for centuries before. Now based on an article on CNN.com the key to any type of peace between Israel and Palestine, is Israel lessing up on the amount of land they occupy, but gaining control of the highlands where Palestine has made a perfect site to bomb Israel. Now, in pure honesty the way that the U.N. created Israel was VERY wrong, they had no right to just take an occupied land, without discussing with its government, or people for that matter. But historically I believe Israelis have a right to that land, God promised that land to the sons of Abraham (Genesis 15:18), and no man is to disobey the will of God. So both countries have fault in this war, yesterday Israel's Prime Minister, Netanyahu, agreed to make some "...painful compromises to achieve this historic peace" (CNN.com) but, yet the Palestinians refuse to even SPEAK of ANY compromise until the Israelis bring a complete halt to any construction in the land.

Quite frankly I feel as though both countries are being very childish, it seems as though when the Israelis are ready to compromise the Palestinians just want to turn their head and make MORE demands, its a constant back and forth battle. Last thing I think needs to be said, is about the U.S. funding Israel. Its just wrong, once again, do I believe Israel is promised that land, absolutely, but do I think that my school should be merged with another because the government cannot fund their own public education system mean while sending seven million to Israel on a daily basis? Absolutely not.

References:
http://www.cnn.com/2011/WORLD/meast/05/24/us.netanyahu.speech/index.html

http://inthearena.blogs.cnn.com/2011/05/24/1967-borders-new-policy-or-reiteration/?iref=allsearch

http://www.cnn.com/2011/OPINION/05/23/frum.israel.obama/index.html?iref=allsearch

shana said...

On Friday, I realized how much conflict was accruing between Israelis and Palestinians. Many countries, not only them, never want to fell in power. They always want to be at the top to have the most power. An example would be in the article "The Deadly Cost of Home", were the Israelis attacked the Palestinians because the Palestinians were on land that they were suppose to own. In the bible, the Israelis were promised from God that they would get that land and the most land and it states, “Gen 15.18, On the same day the Lord made a covenant with Abram, saying: "To your descendants I have given this land, from the river of Egypt (the Wadi el Arish) to the great river, the River Euphrates" (biblebell.org). However, I don’t think it’s necessary to take someone’s live away just because you want more land. They could have at least compromised and made an equal division. I understand that they were fighting to get what they wanted but they are really out to make more conflicts and that’s what happened because pay back came when the Palestinians had "a deadly clash with Israelis troops" (The deadly cost of home) after they killed many of their people. Everyone deserves equal rights to something of their own/have but it wasn’t right when Israelis celebrated their independence day while Palestinians cried. This conflict resulted in young children suffering from traumatic stress and living in poverty. Also, rockets being launched hitting south of Israel. They were angry and I think they had any right to be. However, another unfair advantage was brought in 1947 when the UN made decisions on how to split someone else’s own country and "giving away 55 % of Palestine to a Jewish state" (A Synopsis of the Israel/Palestine). This goes to show that they didn’t care about the outcomes that came with this because they were being selfish about "their" land. They state in the article "A Synopsis of the Israel/Palestine Conflict, that "Israel had conquered 78 % of Palestine” and “in 1967, Israel forces launched a highly successful surprise attack on Egypt" (A synopsis of the Israel/Palestine). Israel never stopped and still continued to take over more land. I think the current problems that happened were like slavery/prisoner experiences where people were beaten, sick, and killed. Every attempted that the Israelis achieved just to get their land was unjust. At the end of it all I think everything is going to remain worse if they don’t compromise.... Never because even now “Mr. Netanyahu rejected US President Barack Obama's call for a peace deal with the Palestinians based on pre-1967 borders, plus land swaps” (BBC.com).

Reference:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-13528158

http://www.biblebell.org/mbag/mailbagaj.html

http://www.ifamericansknew.org/history/

http://www.voicesofyouth.org/en/posts/the-deadly-cost-home

Ebony Beech said...

The Israelis and the Palestinians are two groups of people who have been fighting over the land now known as Israel since biblical times. With this arrangement the Palestinians have been displaced from their homeland, in modern times, since 1948. 1948 marked the birth of the nation of Israel; this is also the year that the Palestinians refer to as "Al-Nakaba": translates as "The Catastrophe." with the establishment of the State of Israel, most Palestinians lost their home, their money and their land, becoming homeless refugees forced to re-establish residences in adjoining countries, such as Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, etc. With the Israelis in control of the so called "Hold Land," the Palestinians have endured refugee states now for two generations.

The Palestinians, on the other hand, have collaborated with their Arab allies on at least six occasions attempting to regain control of their former homeland. Defeated by the Israelis, the Palestinians have resorted to the use of terrorism and wide spread resistance to what they term the occupation of their homeland. As a result of the Six Day War of 1967, Israel expanded its eastern boundary to the Jordan River, an area known as the "West Bank." Accordingly, for the past four decades, the Palestinians have been attempting to regain control of at least the West Bank and Gaza for a future homeland; although some of the more radical Palestinians seek to eliminate Israel as a national entity, and replace it with a solitary Palestinian sate, in which the Jews would be a minority.

While both the Israelis and Palestinians have good arguments regarding ownership of the "Holy Land," i would support the Palestinians two-state solution. The reason i fell this way is because the Israelis were allowed the return to Palestine at the end of the Second World War, and now the Palestinians should enjoy the same privileged, this right of return. I feel this way because the United Nations has declared Israel in violation of international law for illegally seizing territory during the Six Day War, namely Jerusalem and the West Bank. Modern Israel was created to right a wrong, largely because of Jewish suffering during the Holocaust; in the process the Palestinians suffered a wrong in their expulsion at the birth of Israel. As any school child would tell you, two wrongs don't make a right, allowing the Israelis to oppress the Palestinians.

yaritza said...

Last Friday, in class I read an article about the Palestinian and Israeli’s conflict. That article really got me thinking about why Israel is being asked to give up their land, while Jordan isn’t. It shocked me to know about the many acts of dehumanization being done against the Israelis as if they were less than everyone else. According to World Press Review, the Palestine British Mandate stated that, “The original Palestine was two-thirds in Jordan, and only one third in Israel. The partition, voted in 1948 by the United Nations, called for modern-day Israel plus a very small part of Jordan as the Jewish State.” The rest of the area knows, as Palestine became simply Jordan. Two thirds of the Palestinian people were in Jordan, but only Israel is called to give up its land.

The Palestinian Constitution calls for the total destruction of Israel! Between Palestine and Israel has been broken by the Palestinians (skirmishes blamed on “terrorists” who were one of the eight Palestinian factions). It is only the last few years that Palestine has been united under ONE FLAG. Never before has Palestine taken responsibility for the car bombs, suicide bombers, people going into schools in Israel and dropping children to their deaths---- these have always been blamed on terrorists, who in fact were Palestinians.

Although Israel has been suffering from many attacks for many years, and being a country targeted for its democratic government, many may think differently. Israel is surrounded by enemies, and was pro-USA when many of the surrounding Arab nations were supplied weapons by Russia. According to the platypus of 1917, “Jordan held two thirds of Palestine, (until 1948) and Israel was only one third.
Israelis are suffering from having to give up their land, but no one asks Jordan to do so, because it is an Arab nation.” The Arab nations do not want their women to live in a democracy. They do not want a “western” nation in the Middle East, and Israel is more westernized than their neighbors.

For many years it has been hard for Israel to fight back, because everywhere they look, their enemies are pointing weapons at them. During the Golf War, Palestinians cheered when Kuwait was invaded. During 9/11, the Palestinians cheered when the Twin Towers were destroyed. Check CBS news, ABC news, CNN--- there is footage showing Palestinians dancing in the streets when the Towers were bombed. The East (Middle East) is against the policies of the West (USA).


I believe that again, there is the dehumanization factor: When a Palestinian child dies, people get upset, it is front-page news, and people get upset about it. But when an Israeli child dies, no one really seems to care, as if it is supposed to happen. Suicide bombers, bombs thrown into cars --- last year when places were bombed, many Jewish children died, and no one did anything… as if they were “animals.” There is a double standard.


References:
http://www.worldpress.org/eduView.cfm/hurl/id=54

http://platypus1917.org/2011/05/05/marxism-and-israel-left-perspectives-on-the-israeli-palestinian-conflict/

lorena said...

Now in days, there has been many conflicts between countries around the world. For example, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is one of the world’s longest standing conflict. The Palestinian-Israeli conflict was a battle over territory. According to the article, The Deadly Cost of Home, Kristine argues how the ones being most affected during this combat were the children’s. Many of them, age 4-18, “were found suffering from post-traumatic stress after rocket fire from Palestinian militants targeted their town on a nearly daily basis”(Kristine. 2011). This was very sad, kids are innocent and they don’t deserve being involve in something that had nothing to do with them. In another hand, the article: A Synopsis Of The Israel/Palestine Conflict, articulates about the Palestine perspective. At first, it speaks about many Zionist who immigrated to Palestine in large numbers. Hitler’s rise to power made everything worse when population of Jewish people had increased in Palestine and conflict grew. Later on, Israelis had almost 78% of Palestine and their Prime Minister Golda Meir argued that there was no such thing as a Palestinian.
In my opinion, I believe that the land should go to the Israelis because it was the land promised to them by God. According to the bible, “remenber your servants Abraham, Isaac, and Israel to whom you swore by your own self: ‘I will make your descendants as numerous as the stars in the sky and will give your descendants all this land I promised them, and it will be their inheritance forever”(Exodus 32:13). The Israelis should wait till God’s promise fulfills, they should not solve this by fighting with one another. For Palestine, we can say that these both countries should come to an agreement because it might end up getting worse.
By reviewing my classmates comments, I can see that most of the have different opinions about this devastating conflict. I agree with Vanessa in some way because you have the U.S come in the middle of this event and gave money to the Israelis. Also, based on Noelia’s opinion, the U.S is always trying to intervene in almost everything. Maybe this will be helpful in some kind of way because they are being backed up. But it can also be bad since it can cause more problems. Lastly, Jocelyn point of view is so true when she quoted about, “no man is to disobey the will of God.” This is basically since God promised the land to the Israelis and no body can not go against God commandment. This topic is very debatable and is causing to much issues and who knows where this might lead to.


References:

http://bible.cc/exodus/32-13.htm

http://www.ifamericansknew.org/history/

http://www.voicesofyouth.org/en/posts/the-deadly-cost-of-home

angel said...

In my opinion, i think America shouldn't get in this type of problems between two countries. this is not in their universe of obligation. moreover, when the U.S has any problems nobody ever interferes with it, but once the U.S stops helping a community like the Israelite. Now their mad Obama because hes not helping them anymore. the U.S made the wrong decision by helping them. furthermore, i believe this is not a reason to be fighting about. people and kids being killed for no reason just because they Palestinians. "over 10,000 Palestinian men, women, and children are held in Israeli prisons."(ifamericansknew)

ifamericansknew.com

veronique said...

Okay we have the Israelis who believe on a religious view this land is there’s but then an on the other hand the Palestinians who believe it’s there land because they were there first. Finally the US who always tries to come in and fix everything. Nevertheless, to me it’s like this the US always find themselves in debt or in a recession because we waste millions of dollars on war but they put themselves in it constantly. If the Palestinians were there first shouldn’t they have the land? I mean think about it’s like the US conquering land and find themselves there first, but another group believe its there’s religiously. Come on if that’s the case spelt the land among them. Do we continue and kill loose innocent people or divide the land and be happy. Is a piece of land greater than the lost of thousand plus humans? I mean the Israelis honestly wont give up the land neither will the Palestinians. It is reported “:By the end of the war, Israel had conquered 78 percent of Palestine; three-quarters of a million Palestinians had been made refugees; over 500 towns and villages had been obliterated” do we honestly think this dispute is going to stop any time soon. Well I think not it’s only going to get worst and more bloods going to be shad even more.

http://www.ifamericansknew.org/history/

esteniol said...

I first heard about the Israeli- Palestinian conflict in sixth grade, but I never reflected on what I've learned until now. The twelve year old me easily of sided with the Israeli forces. However, after doing my own research and reading " A Synopsis of the Israel/Palestine Conflict", I've concluded, through introspection, that both the Israeli Jews and the Palestinians both have claims to land.

I believe the Zionist have a right to establish Israel because of the need of a "safe-haven" for Jews. The Jews have been oppressed for over a millennia and to prevent any more persecution and discrimination, a home must be established for them.

Because of the many attacks and massacres of Palestinians, like the one that took place in Deir Yassin, the Palestinians should receive land as restitution. The Zionist has committed 33 massacres against the Palestinians and has occupied most of the state of Palestine. This seems unfair for Palestinians who weren't even looking for war.

In all, I think the U.N. should no longer shoulder biased opinions and try to promote harmony between the two groups; the same goes for the U.S.

freiter said...

On Friday in Ms.miranda & Mr.Womack humanities 3 class we read an article based on the current and historical conflict between the israelis and Palestinians. before beginning to read the article i already had a small bit of prior knowledge of the issue, but after reading the article i felt as if i had grasped enough knowledge of what was going on until it was brought up that the blog was in a sense picking favorites. the blog was pushing toward sides of the israelis now today we recived a small packet that was assentially a general run down on the conflict.the packet talked about the history of the conflict and it explained how things were
before reading my opinion on this was probably like many others that the Palestinians were in the wrong but then after going through the article i had made my mind up. i had came to this conclusion that the israelian's are wrong.
my first reasons for saying this is because in the beggining the zionist people should have settle with what they were given,although religiously speaking they were in the right because this land was "promised to them". they should have taken what they were given and left it at that after the UN's intervened because obviously they were the clear winners in all of this. but they clearly didnt see it this way the israilis carried out massacares and palestinians only fought because of this,a means of defense. what is more significant to bring to the surface is that no battle was fought on israeli territory which clearly shows who was the ones who started the conflict, and they managed to carry out crossaides,large massacers of the palestinian people they even attacked a united states navy vessel.all and all i believe that the Palestinians are just mad that they have close to nothing in this day and age. lastly i dont belive this situation can be resolved as easily with out offending hundreds of thousands of people do to the delecasy of the conflict because it is not just any war it is a religious war.

lorena said...

i agree with Esteniol when he say that "the Zionist have the right to establish Israel" since they had been oppressed and discriminated for so long. Especially when Hitler was in power, he waned to get rid of all the Jews, i mean at least they should have the same right we all have.

Minh said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Minh said...

Most people talk about how Palestine and Israel fight to claim for little inch of land which result in large number of death. But the truth is they fight for more than that. Of the water available form West Bank aquifers, Israel uses 73%, West Bank Palestinian uses 17% and illegal Jewish settlers use 10%. While 10-14% of Palestine's GPD is agricultural, 90% of them must rely on rain-fed farming methods. Israel’s agriculture is only 3% of their GDP, but Israel irrigates more than 50% of its land. Israel consumes the vast majority of the water from the Jordan River despite only 3% of the river falling within its pre-1967 borders. Israel now diverts one quarter of its total water consumption through its National Water Carrier from the Jordan River, whereas Palestinians have no access to it whatsoever due to Israeli closures.

And with the help from the US with the amount of 8.2 million per day giving Palestinian a huge disadvantage. Resulting 6430 of casualties, 45041 injuries and 24813 house been demolished in Palestine. For Israel 124 casualties, 9226 injuries and no properties were destroyed. Increasing unemployment rate to 40% in Gaza, 16.5% in West Bank and 6.4% in Israel.

With this number it look like the war going to be very long, because the US help would end up attracting another power to help the Palestine and end up to be like other big war. But if the US did not help them this war could have already been solved. So i think that the US should left that problem for them to handle by themselves.

Reference:

http://www.ifamericansknew.org/cur_sit/water.html

http://www.ifamericansknew.org/

elijah said...

After humanities class today i have read two articles about the israle and palestine. The two articles were about how the palestine is trying to take over a pieceas of land in isreal.

After reading these two articles i feel like the whole situation is going to get worse before it gets better. I feel this way because the different countries are getting in it.

Sterling said...

In my research of the Isaeli and Palestine Conflict struggle, I thought they should had sare a government. Palestine and Israel were fighting over land. this led into a six days war against Israel's neighbors including Egypt and Syria. When that battle was going on, one of the U.S. had a ship bombed because it was in the middle of the battle. (MSNBC.com)This cause Gaza and the West Bank oppressed by Israel. Israelis imprisoned Palestenians and tortured them all while doing so. to slove the Israel problem the U.S. taxspayers give Israel an average of seven million dollors in aid per day (tundratabloids.com)

Reference:

http//:today.msnbc.com

http//:tundrabloids.com/jordans-is-palestine