Please summarize and discuss the different perspectives on the Conflict in Sudan. Make sure to share your own opinions and make sure to comment on others. Please use citations and have at least 2 sources as your references. Make sure to comment on another person's blog too.
34 comments:
In Ms. Miranda's class she explained a simple yet powerful quote about how history always leads to the future but we as people can change that. There will always be historic reasons into why conflicts develop in many countries. Sudan at first in my eyes seemed to had have just one conflict within the north and south of Sudan but from the BBC i learned "Since then Sudan has been ruled by a succession of unstable civilian and military governments. The country has been in a state of civil war for many years, and human rights abuses are widespread." (BBC NEWS)In class we talked about how most countries faced problems with their government but the problem wasnt the government it was the people ththemselfs. "Sudan has experienced a long-running conflict between the Arab Muslim northerners of Sudan, (the base of the Government), and the black Africans of the south, who practise mainly Christian or animist beliefs." (BBC NEWS) I tried to do some reseach and find news articles about people's perspectives but for me religion is a very hard topic to cover without offending the other person so my perspective is very hard to put into words. I feel that these two split nations, south and north Sudan, should come to some treaty without the U.N.'s help because we are putting a lot of pressure into these nations to stay together. I found out by Ms. Miranda that two UN officials were killed and of course the Southern Sudan people are blamed which is kind of bias towards the northerns. If the UN were to just have let the nations find some sort of agreement where they are equally set with each other. Religion is a big topic to dicuss because of the many conflicts that are occuring in the world because of religion. Sudan should just try to become one country and not split.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/84927.stm
Sudan Headed Towards Civil War: Again- Reading
So I've been reading numerous articles about the conflict thats happening in Sudan. Based on my research and my reading I have found out that Sudan is the most poorest and largest country in the continent of Africa. I also discovered that Sudan is most important because of its oil wealth. I read online in the New york post that "The southern Sudanese have fought for independence for decades, and in January, nearly 99 percent of the region’s voters approved a split from northern Sudan in an internationally backed referendum. The referendum marked the end to the nearly one-million-square-mile experiment called Sudan, which for many troubled decades served as a bridge between the Arab and African world. Southern Sudan will be named the Republic of South Sudan upon independence" so this is basically showing how the two Sudans came about.(North and South) now since the spilt, bigger problems must be solved and faced. North Sudan and South Sudan both are concerned with how they would share the south’s sizable reserves of crude oil and what to do about the Abyei region, which straddles the north-south border, which is claimed by both of them. People from North Sudan are not jumping for joy at all because of the Split. Heres a quote I read on AlertNet "We feel an incredible sadness that a ... very loved part of Sudan will separate from us but we know that this is their right," says Sara Nuqdullah, an opposition Umma Party official, who broke down in tears. "For us it is very painful as if a part of our body has been removed." However people of South Sudan are truly excited about the split. They feel that this is a time for them to gain their own independence. since they feel the North has been mistreating them for years. Heres a quote that backs up that statement "The people of South Sudan, for the first time since 1898, are going to determine their own future." This was said by President Omar al-Bashir.(topix.com) As we see, both North and South have different perspectives about the two splitting. I honestly feel that they should stick together regaurdless of their disputes, and work things out. Being one makes their country stronger, and if they are one, they dont have to worry about what to do with Abyei and the oil. & NO im NOT judging but I FEEL that the country can barely function on its own. It will just be a repeat of Ethiopia/Eritrea with ethnic and religious feuds. But hey thats my openion, and thats a whole different topic.
Refrences:
http://topics.nytimes.com/top/news/international/countriesandterritories/sudan/index.html
http://www.trust.org/alertnet/news/sudans-north-mourns-as-south-looks-to-split/
http://www.topix.com/forum/afam/T9R2LR46GHUNAANMG
Today in Class, we learned about the conflict that is occurring in Northern and Southern Sudan. This conflict has been going on for a long time now and it is time to come to an end. As South Sudan's leader Salva Klir said "I will not lead my people into conflict with the north over the disputed region of Abyei". "We will not go back to war, it will not happen" (bbn). This shows that the leader of southern Sudan wants all complications between the North to diminish knowing that this conflict has been going on for several years. It is still undecided on wether the area of Abyei should be given to the North or the South. William Hague says "I call on all sides to cease hostilities immediately. All unauthorized forces should be withdrawn from the entire area of Abyei in accordance with past agreements by the parties" (sudan,reading). All this commotion that is happening i feel should come to an end. There should be a peace agreement/treaty that resolves all of their problems. Just like the leader of southern Sudan implies. The war between the North has to stop. Therefore, not only we the people have concerns about this conflict, but so does the leader of southern Sudan himself. I wouldn't blame him. A complicated conflict that has been going on for a while needs to be resolved. As Kyane says, Sudan should finish their troubles on their own and leave the UN out of this commotion so they can do their own job.
References:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-13560829
Sudan headed towards civil war: Again! reading
I class we have been reading articles about Sudan. There have been a lot of conflicts, the burning and looting increased tension in Sudan. There has been further violence in Sudan’s dispute of accusing each other of attacks. They felt as if they had to retaliate. Abyei was border region with both southern and northern armies. This region was oil rich and had ethnic and economic issues. Southern Sudan fought for their independence and that made tension raise more and more the north feared confrontation with them because they didn’t want any alliance. Tension was happening and lots of people in Southern Sudan were being killed. This lead to President Omar al-Bashir announces provocation by a northern overreaction, and made sure it wouldn’t affect southern independence. People still have a hard time believing the tension will settle soon.
When I think about the tension I see it as Sudan has been in the war since 1898 when they had tension with the French, They deserve their independence as a country, Even though that may be difficult to accomplish when North Sudan thinks their region is better and more superior then South Sudan just because they have light skin better weapons. While southern Sudan wants closure because they are a small piece of land with two sides and has to suffer with undeniable rights. Which could affect them in the future?
http//globalpublicsquare.blogs.cnn.com
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-13502845
The Sudanese have always had cultural and religious differences, the North and South conflicts within Sudan have slowed down its economic and political development. Which has lead to massive internal movement of its People. Tensions in Abyei grew once a referendum scheduled for January, on whether to join the North or South did not take place in Sudan. The Northern Sudanese group Misseriya uses Abyei for grazing their cows. The southern Sudanese group is called Dinka Ngok who lives in Abyei ,both North and South Sudanese want to claim Abyei, because it produces oil and outside its borders there are other oil fields. Sudan president Omar al-Bashir states “Abyei is Northern Sudanese land we will not withdraw from it” (BBC News).
The Abyei conflict is more ethnic than economic, Because the southern Sudanese are darker and practice different Religion’s, they say the acts of the Northern Sudanese can be categorized as Genocide. I think that yes they are all Sudanese so in a way the acts could be considered as Genocide. Because they are being discriminated against by their own race, and have been referred to as the “Black” Sudanese. Abyei was taken by force from the South and the North has only just recently taken control over Abyei. I think the Southern Sudanese are right, because the Northern Sudanese had no right to storm into Abyei, they just decided to take control over it. especially without talking to the people who live in Abyei, or the soon to be leader of the seperate Southern Sudan Salva Kiir.
References: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-13531611
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-13502845
For a brief history on the conflict in Suddan, "War broke out in Sudan in the early 1980s, largely based on racial, ethnic and religious divides just like the current conflict in Darfur. Unlike the present, the rest of the world looked the other way, while the government launched a persecution of the African tribal groups of the south," (help sudan international). North Sudan is highly influenced by European traits with an Islam religion, while the South has a diversed amount of religions. Sudan is also segrated racially. With the people of lighter skin in the North and the people of darker skin in the South. On the borderline that splits Sudan, is a city known as Abyei. Abyei is known for having alot of oil. Both North and South Sudan want to occupy this land, which has tensions rising. As for the President of Sudan Omar al-Bashir, he is (like the North) Muslim and sticks up for the North.
In a recent article, "Al-Bashir said that Abyei belongs to North Sudan and the Sudanese army will not pull out of it," (xinhuanet). What kind of President chooses sides in their own country?! This is where my opinion comes in, because i believe what is going on in Sudan is in fact a Genocide. Not only does Al-Bashir allow his country to segregate themselves from one another, he also backs up one side due to religious prefences so they can obtaian an oil-rich area. The thing that makes this a Genocide is that the North chooses to do this by any means necessary using the Sudanese army, with the President saying "I have given instructions to the Sudanese army to respond to any provocations by SPLM, anyway," (xinhuanet). While (as my classmate KIKI has said, and i agree with) South Sudanese leader Salva Klir does not want to get into any conflict with the North. Therefore, i stand by the South Sudanese side in their fight for independence against their greedy oppressors.
Reference :
http://www.helpsudaninternational.org/sudan/html
www.xinhuanet.com/english2010/world/africa/htm
As you may or may not know, Sudan’s military has taken control of the disputed oil-rich region of Abyei and the largest country in Africa. They have been at war for many years and have been in “a long- running conflict between the Arab Muslim northerners of Sudan, (the base of the Government), and the black Africans of the south, who practice mainly Christian or animist beliefs” (BBC news.org). These two sides are very different; they have different ethnicities, economy disagreements, and religion differences. In addition, the northern side is more modern then the south. However, they all have different perspective. The south feels like they are oppressed while the north feels as though they are being attacked. The south wanted to be split from the north and officially become an independent nation. On the other hand “Northerners, who have traditionally controlled the country, have sought to unify it along the lines of Arabism and Islam despite the opposition of non-Muslims, southerners, and marginalized peoples in the west” (Years of Civil War (1955) (Background Information)). I think it would be better to be separated because yes there would probably still be competition but there wouldn’t be as much conflicts and tension between the north and the south. Secondly, they were already divided away from each other when they were one nation so, it just would make more sense to permanently split them from one another. As a result, "Those who voted for unity were 44,888, that is, 1.17%. Those who voted for separation were 3,792,518, that is, 98.83%," commission head Mohamed Ibrahim Khalil said (BBC new.org). This shows how much the south’s independence was supported. I too would support them and also agree with the statement, "The (freedom) of the south is not the end of the road, because we cannot be enemies. We must build strong relations," said Mr Kiir, who is also Sudan's Vice-President. I believe that even if any one would have got their independence or rights, it doesn’t mean the outcome of it all has to be tension and problems building up. Kyane said that religion is a big topic and many conflicts happen because of it, is true and thats a big part of this conflict with Sudan. I think because of it, they SHOULD be split though because they probably wont form a way to connect with eachother.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-12379431
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/world/analysis/84927.stm
With this large country approaching a day of possible separation, will this benefit the UN or will it truly be a step towards ending the military violence taking place along the boarder of this oil rich city. If the Northerners have been oppressing the Southerners, what will the benefit be for the southerners? Can there be any common ground when both sides feel that they are in the position to lead the other side?
Today in class we discussed the conflict in Sudan, and I was so naïve and thought like Kyane as though it was only a little battle between North and South. But as we learned today it’s much more than that it has to do with generation of oppression that even here in the U.S. we have expressed (Whites VS. Blacks). The quote that stood out to me while Ms. Miranda was trying to explain “People are trapped in history, and history is trapped in them”-James Baldwin The north part of Sudan are simply just acting like their oppressor which is why the quote came to mind. Ms. Miranda also made the analogy by explain how what we know as the U.S. now once was about to be two different places and President Lincoln didn’t want that to happen because it shows weakness in the leader which is similar to what should be going through Omar al-Bashir who is the current president of Sudan. It astonishes me how the same event is having in what soon will be North and South Sudan but if you were to ask someone from the North what they thought was occurring they would say its just a way to have control and to keep everything organized but in the South things are seen a different way its seen as a “genocide”. People often only see what they want to see or what the government tells them. So many people are dying because of people like Omar who states “my army would respond to any possible provocation”-bbcnews so just by this statement you can see that he just wants to control and dehumanize these groups of people. Which as we all know is known as a war crime. Which as a result making those who live in the south lose their homes, loved ones, and go hungry. When will fighting for land and goods ever end ?
Reference
http://www.miamiherald.com/2011/05/26/2236520/hungry-and-scared-sudan-villagers.html
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-13531611?print=true
The conflict between north and south Sudan is very controversial in Africa at this point. The conflict has continued for years despite the fact of many peace treaties such as; Machakos Protocol and the peace agreement in 1997(BBCNEWS). The southern Sudanese had succeeded from the country in 1956 which announced the conflict between the two. The differences between the countries both political and religious have separated the north and south greatly. The south advocated for the people’s right to discussed and decided matters in the country, which would be there way of government, but would conflict with the northerners way of government. This led to the political differences with the newly independent county. The religious differences between the two are that the south is mainly Christian and a mixture of other religons. Also one of the more economical issues that are dividing the country is the occupation of the land Abyei. Abyei lies on the boarder of north and south Sudan and is a gold mine for oil. Both countries want to acquire Abyei to become richer and the superior country which resulted into war between the two. The north’s political beliefs are different from the south because they believe in a strong central government that can control the country. Also there are mostly Muslims in northern Sudan including their leader who merges politics and religion together causing conflict between the south. In all many innocent people have suffered from the difference between the two countries “since 1983 over 1.2m people have been killed” (BBCNEWS) during the war. Also the Sudan government has spent 1.5m a day to support the needs of the conflict that has been destroying their country. Also this has caused frustration and separation of many families that live in Sudan leading to 30,000 people to leave their country (WorldWires). In my opinion the conflict in Sudan is an extreme civil war that is overpowering the people that will eventually end in destruction of the country. I define the war as a civil war because although they are killing many of people a day they are not officially two different countries yet. Furthermore, they have different opinions on government that can be crucial but there are many methods to solve difference then war. Also civil wars just like this have happened in the past like; the civil war in the United Sates and the civil war in the Soviet Union. If these major countries can get through their civil wars why cant Sudan?
http://www.miamiherald.com/2011/05/26/2236520/hungry-and-scared-sudan-villagers.html
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/84927.stm
Couple days ago, my Humanities class was able to touch on the subject of the conflict of Sudan, that is apparently happening at this moment. Sudan which is the largest country in Africa yet the poorest, has been at war for nearly 50 years due to three main reasons in which are: a brutal 21 year civil war between the North and South that ended in 2005, going on humanitarian crisis in Darfur in the west at least a proximately 300,000 people had died and 2.7 million been displaced by fighting since 2003, and last but not least the slow recovery from conflict in East Sudan, where insurgents threatened to challenge the government for a shore of the country’s power and natural resources.
According, to the article of Sudan Headed Towards Civil War Again, one of the reasons where that “Sudan’s Military has taken control of the disputed oil-rich of Abyei” and a spokesman for the military wing of the movement that governs Southern Sudan confirmed that Sudan’s militarily controlled the area. As a result, it causes the south to be really furious. However, according to Trust the real reason why this conflict is happening is because colonizers drew the boundaries of present day Sudan without heed to the different religious and ethnic groups that already inhabited the territory, which was under joint Anglo-Egyptian control until 1956. Furthermore, “this set the stage for showdowns between the north, populated predominantly by Arab Muslims, and the south, populated largely by animists and Christians of African origin.”(Trust.Org)
However, I find it extremely humorous how every dense conflict always happened due to pieces of lands and religions. I am starting to get tired of hearing such stupidity. Why can’t human juts compromised? Like really. You would rather kill to gain or gain knowing that you did not have to kill? Moreover, as I watch this video of the fight between the same race, I find it ridiculous how “300 of women and children where to flee and dozen were dead” in three days of unecerary fight. Lastly, I agree with Kyane statement, religions is a big topic to discuss because of the many conflicts that are occurring in this world are because of that. People tend to try and judge your belief, especially when you are part of an organization; if the head has a different belief towards yours, you would have to obey his belief or else you are going to pay the consequence, especially in foreign countries. As a conclusion, I believe that Sudan should remain as one because once a huge nation falls apart, the more conflict would occur in this world, because every where you going to turn they will always have a side that hates one and another, in which is a ridiculous thing to see, because the more we have that, the more innocent people tend to die and the more animalistic us humans gets.
*Reference:
http://www.trust.org/alertnet/crisis-centre/crisis/sudan-conflicts
http://www.trust.org/alertnet/multimedia/video-and-audio/detail.dot?mediaInode=a9aefaec-8b52-44e3-a538-3896a2f4992b
Sudan Headed Towards Civil War: Again- Reading
Both North and South Sudan differ in many ways. The Northern Sudanese being Muslim and follow Islam, while the Southerners are much darker skinned and are Christians. South Sudanese feel that they being targeted for not being like the North, but the North is at war because of "southern soldiers mutinied rather than follow orders transferring them to the North"(state). To the North, its seen as a civil war, however, the South feels like its genocide. To me, it seems that this conflict is the North trying to gain the South's resources. One thing the south has over the north is that "it is resource-rich, and has a number of oil reserves"(SBS). Having control of the South means having control of the oil, which is why they are both fighting over Abyei.
Reference:
http://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/1463147/factbox-north-vs-south-sudan
http://www.state.gov/r/pa/ei/bgn/5424.htm
Sudan has been unofficially separated into two-halves ever since its independence in 1956. North Sudan is mostly Islamic, while, south Sudan’s population is mostly Christian and Animist. The north believes it is their destiny to convert the whole country to Islam as well as making Arabic the official language. The oil rich, controversial city of Abyei lies on the undeclared border between the north and south. Just weeks before “southern Sudan was supposed to split from the north and form its own country” the north proclaimed the city of Abyei to be its own (New York Times, 2011).
The south would like to become its own independent nation and keep its practice of Christianity alive. They too would like to have control over Abyei, but, haven’t made any suggestions toward the matter thus far. The northern Sudanese have sent janjaweed militias to Darfur to instill fear in its residents through the use of violent tactics. Furthermore, the south would like to become its own nation and allow all its exiled residence the ability to no longer be a refugee and return home. July 9, 2011, is when the south would officially like to become a new sate to the world.
I side with the Republic of South Sudan because they should have the freedom of religious expression. If ruled by the north they will be forced to practice the Islamic way of life. The north has also been supporting “ethnic cleansing,” and proving this to be true in Darfur (New York Times, 2011). The prime minister of north Sudan had been indicted for war crimes and could be arrested anywhere outside of Sudan. Ninety-nine percent of southern Sudanese are voting for their country to become an independent state, and if it was up to me their wish would be granted.
References:
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/26/world/africa/26sudan.html?pagewanted=1&ref=todayspaper
North Sudan’s leader is Omar Hassan al-Bashir and South Sudan’s leader is Salva Kiir. These two regions have not been getting along for some time now. They had an ongoing civil war for twenty two years. The war was finally settled in 2005 with a peace deal, by then about 1.5 million people died (BBC). Then in January, 2011 the voters of the region voted that the south will become an independent country as of July 2011 (New York Times). As of right now the country is a little bit more peaceful then before but the north and south are now arguing about Abyei. Abyei is a county that is border line between North and South Sudan, and as of now both sides want to claim it. Salva Kiir said about the south “[we] Have fought enough” (BBC). I think that Abyei should be given to the South because they will need a lot of resources to begin their new country.
Reference:
New York Times World
http://topics.nytimes.com/top/news/international/countriesandterritories/sudan/index.html
BBC News
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-13560829
On this very day Sudan is having conflict within its own country, still. Since 1955 north Sudan have been in a civil war with south Sudan. For years now the north have been feeling as though they are being oppressed, while the south have felt like they're being attacked. The reasons behind this is because the north are traditionally the ones who have had power over the country, they also mostly have the Muslim culture, whereas the south are more Arabic and Islamic. So basically they are fighting because of their religion views. While reading a handout Ms. Miranda gave us in class I came upon and interesting fact, “A month after coming to power, Nimeiri proclaimed socialism (instead of Islamism) for the country and outlined a policy of granting autonomy to the South”. I really think that was a very good move from him, and maybe in this long lasting situation it would do a lot of good. But in recent news it has been said that they will be splitting on July 9th and I honestly think that’s the only way to go. There are others too, for example, "We need peace. We do not need war. If there are people who need war then they have a challenge to explain why they are doing the opposite at the time the region desperately needs stability and development. I repeat we need peace not war," explained Mawien Baak, a former child soldier who left the southern army in 2006.”
Another point I would like to add is, I’m on Vanessa’s side, the south should become independent from the north, they also deserve Abyei. Abyei is a city right between the north and the south , it is rich in oil, and both are fighting for it. After all those years of being oppressed I believe so. The north and south might as well split since they have different cultures, customs, languages, features, religion and more. It would be nice for them to have a “melting pot” type of country like us, but it sounds easier than it is.
Recourses:
Departmentofjustice.com
http://talkofsudan.com/sudan/item/7717-views-in-wau-south-sudan-we-must-make-strive-for-our-own-peace
Today in class I read an article that talked about the conflict that is currently happening between Northern and Southern Sudan. For many years the Sudanese have had much conflict between each other due to religious and political reasons. Sudan has been separated into two-halves ever since 1956. Abyei has become a very controversial topic and conflict for the Sudanese, due to the reason that Abyei lies in between the border of Southern and Northern Sudan and happens to be a gold mine for oil. This was what arose the conflict of which side does Abyei belongs to? And this is when the North entitles Abyei as theirs. For more than over 10 years, South Sudan has been fighting with North Sudan. As the leader of South Sudan Mr. Kiir said, “The South had fought enough as Northern troops were reported to be massing near the border. We will not go back to war, it will not happen!” He stated that it was time for peace and he described the North’s invasion of Abyei as an over-reaction, and said, “The area would eventually be reclaimed by the south.” According to BBC, Analysts fear the dispute could reignite the north-south conflict.
The status of Abyei was left undecided, due last January, on whether the area should be part of the North or South has been postponed indefinitely. Although it makes much sense for the leader of South Sudan Mr. Kiir to request peace in his country others think differently. Like the President of Sudan, Omar al-Bashir who has refused to withdraw his troops from the region, despite UN condemnation of the move. This decision has caused much destruction between both North and South Sudan, many families fleeing Abyei have been split up and children are missing. According to BBC, “Aid workers say some 40,000 people have fled the fighting around Abyei - mostly southerners, heading further south.” On account of all this conflict, South Sudan only wants to become independent and be its on nation together with Abyei. For many years South Sudan has been address for not being much alike with North Sudan. Like for having several and various religious belief, while North Sudan only practices the Islam religion.
I comply with South Sudan, because it’s enough with the violence and destruction that has been happening. And it needs to stop! It seems like once again these our acts of dehumanization, because the destruction and death keep spreading much more on South Sudan. Also I agree with South Sudan trying to become its own nation, because that way they would be in peace and able to keep on with their diversity of religious belief. South Sudan siding with North Sudan can only create much more tension between them.
I also agreed with my fellow classmate Vanessa, they should stand alone and fight for their independence because those are greedy oppressor, and South Sudan shouldn’t get involve with North Sudan in any way because their religious belief are very different.
Reference:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-13560829
http://www.miamiherald.com/2011/05/26/2236520/hungry-and-scared-sudan-villagers.html
Abyei isn't just an oil-rich piece of land with an abundance of green grass for cattle that both North and South Sudan want and are willing to start another civil war for, it is a home for men, women, and children. The Abyei population is fleeing from the land trying to avoid the explosions and save their families, but end up scattered, exhausted, starving, or dead from the military attacks (AP). Once again, government leaders are focusing more on the potential resources and uses that a piece of land can offer. North, mostly light skinned Muslim, and South Sudan, mostly dark skinned Christians, has been in a civil war from 1983-2005 and finally on July 9 2011 there will be a National border separating both countries officially (BBC News). The problem is, who will take Abyei?
Well, I must say I disagree with Sade and agree with Ebony regarding the split of Sudan. Southern Sudan can stand on its own and can be strong given time to built their militia and government. North Sudan has so much more land and powerful armed forces, why should they take Abyei too? They have sent their tanks in Abyei to take over before the South does and the National border is finalized (BBC News). To me, that is just low because the Northerners know South Sudan’s President "Kiir, has at least two reasons to refrain from immediate military action to retake Abyei: It could scuttle the peace deal that promised the south its January independence vote and subsequent July 9 separation. And the north has military might that the south does not," (AP).
The Northerners have been looting, burning, and killing in Abyei, with the excuse of “responding to Southern aggression,” (AP). The Southerners have also done things that are looked down upon, the Associated Press states that a Misseriya tribal chief reported, "Six months ago, the southerners forced all Arabs to leave their houses in Abyei. All left. They were forced to leave. They storm the houses of the Arabs and tell them, 'Either leave or you will be killed.'"
Either way, both presidents are pretty confident, "Kiir said he will not send his forces to retake Abyei, but he promised that the land would end up in southern hands eventually. Nimir feels equally strongly that Abyei will stay in the hands of his northern tribesmen," (AP).
I feel as though Abyei should belong to South Sudan, though, whatever side of the National border Abyei is located, I hope the decision is soon made, and that it doesn’t result to violence. I highly doubt it…
References
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-13502845
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5jgKg_LF6gZE4tHAOFlaxQ6x3rgew?docId=5bf9ba85c6894952a92902841e6a5f74
Sudan has gone through a lot in the past but sadly it is still suffering some issues. Sudan was at war for about 50 years and through out those years, Sudan has had many negative impacts. The situation in the western Darfur region of Sudan has been labelled the “worst humanitarian crisis in the world
today,” (parliament). The reason why it was known as the worst is due to the 10,000 and 30,000 people who died, also 1.3 people moved from their homes because of a conflict between rebel forces on the one side,
and the Sudanese Government and the government backed Janjaweed militia on the other.
Many civilian suffered from poverty due to the lack of food and care and people are still being affected till this day.
Also Abyei produces oil and it is claimed by both the North and South but it caused tensions and more violence for the South because of the oil, “including those in 2008 over the disputed oil rich town of Abyei,” (insightonconflict). The South then receives their independence and it is expected to separate from the north on July 9, 2011, “As the overwhelming referendum result of over 99% voting in favor of independence were announced,”(insightonconflict). This was an issue for many people because about 2 million South Sudanese are now living in the North. In 2005 there was a peace deal that ended Africa's longest-running war. After the war was over, the South suffered the most and it's going to a long time to get out of poverty and this is the reason why many people flee their homes each year.
Also, to answer Roudia's question on “Why can’t humans just compromise?” In my opinion I believe that history will always repeat itself but in different ways. There will be people who have different mind sets and goals but I do feel as though there should be a limit of going to far. When a war is initiated like the Sudan war that lasted many years, people all around are being affected especially those who encounter violence in their country. It's not fair that so many innocent people don't have the opportunity to be something when they grow up, instead they have to work twice as hard.
Reference:
http://www.insightonconflict.org/conflicts/sudan/?gclid=CKL95ZaBh6kCFcJ05QodaxZGpw
http://www.insightonconflict.org/conflicts/sudan/conflict-profile/
http://www.parliament.uk/documents/commons/lib/research/rp2004/rp04-051.pdf
There has been many disputes between the North and the South of Sudan. This conflict is mostly based on religious differences and Abyei, the border of the North and the South. Abyei is in the middle of these two sides and they are combating to get this land. This little country is very rich in oil. Generally speaking, many will say, “Abyei has been under attack by the Sudanese armed forces from air and ground”(State.p.1). Southern Sudan voted to split the North and wants to be independent in July. But doing this can lead to many issues because if they get separated then problems between them will grow more. In the Southern part of Sudan, there is mostly dark skidded people and a mix of Christians and other religion. While in the Northern part we have Islamic and Muslims. Darfur, which is located in Western Sudan, sponsored groups to kill those black Sudanese. They would do that based on their ethnicity. Many have died in large number, “the genocide in Durfur has claimed 400,000 lives and displaces over 2,500,000 people. More than one hundred people continue to die each day”(Durfur.com).
Its terrible how people died and how in history, problems can be solved by combating with one another. In my opinion, these two country should be a whole country united. Because, innocent people keep dying, and is not fair to those who don’t want to be involve in this kind of conflict. I believe they should stop fighting for land when they can get together and help one another. In other hand, if they do remind separated, it would get things worse because people will still fight for the land and hatred will be still in them. Maybe if they try to work things out, the country can be strong one.
My classmates have different opinions in this debatable conflict. I agree with Bill in some way because when he stated that ‘having control of the South means having control of the oil, because that is why they fighting over Abyei.’ This is already a problem since the Southerners are the one with more resources like he stated. That is why they should get together and not split like Kyane articulated.
References:
http://www.darfurscores.org/darfur
http://www.state.gov/r/pa/ei/bgn/5424.htm
Ever since there have been violent interactions from the people of Sudan, both the North and Southern Sudan has not gained a good relationship as a country. While the Northern part of Sudan are lighter skinned and influenced by the Islamic religion, the Southern part is known as the Black Sudanese and mostly practices Christianity. With the conflict of color and religion, there are extreme tensions amongst the separated county. For example, there have been multiple events where the Sudanese president Omar al-Bashir allowed troops to attack and kill a number of innocent Southern Sudanese. But right now there greatest battle is not only the murders, but for oil- rich land called Abyei.
As of July 9, 2011, it is planned for South Sudan to become independent from the north due to recent votes back in January. The only problem is that Abyei is claimed by the southern group the Dinka Ngok, and the Northern group the Misseriya’s. As president “Omar al-Bashir said the area belonged to the North,” he is somewhat correct because most of Abyei is on the Northern side (BBC News). But, it is far to say that part of Abyei also lies on the Southern parts of Sudan. As southern both southern and northern troops are in Abyei, the north has become more successful with the southern homeowner leave Abeyi, but with no place to go. In response, Southern leader Salva Kiir, has claimed that they “will not go back to war, it will not happen” (BBC News). He is referring northern forces pushing people out of their homes, but he hopes that conflict will not grow between the north and the south.
Yet because Abyei is between both the north and the south, I believe that a boarder should physically be established with guards from both sides on watch. I feel that it is the only way that there will be peace in Sudan. But as the leader of the south, Kiir is handling the situation more efficiently, while al-Bashir is just creating for conflict in the country that he is suppose to be leading. And the action that he allows to carry out should be considered as genocide for the simple fact that he is allowing the death of innocent people, who are still technically part of Sudan. I also agree with Brandi and how a war will eventually cause destruction for the country, but I feel like it will mostly hurt the south, especially if they end up becoming independent. That is because the south already lack of a strong economy, food, homes, education, and even sanity water. So if by any chance they do get to keep part of Abeyi, the south will be able to use the oil to become strong as their own country.
Reference:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-13560829
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-13531611
As we studied the conflict in Sudan in class today, I was given two perspectives on the matter.
The North "sees it as a counterinsurgency campaign." (PBS) Nothing more than a simple civil war between the two. The South, however, believes it is a genocide. A genocide is "the deliberate and systematic extermination of a national, racial, political, or cultural group." (Dictionary)
In my own personal opinion, I believe it is a genocide. The South is defending itself at the best of their abilities to create a peaceful coexistence between the two groups. The North has been looting, raiding, destroying, and annihilating villages and innocent citizens. I see this as a form of "power abuse" where the government is abusing its power over the people and making the country how it wants it.
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/counterinsurgency
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/genocide
http://www.pbs.org/frontlineworld/stories/sudan/
Makayla Campbell
“Sudan is not greedy for the carrot of America, and does not fear from its stick”-President Omar al-Bashir (BBC News). Such statement from the controversial President of Sudan sent the people in an uproar. Obama has arranged for the Country to split into two separate countries, which will soon be known as North and South Sudan this coming July. I’m unbiased on whether or not the country should split and become independent. It’s good that they will finally be liberated and be granted their long time over due freedom, but the split is causing conflict for Abyei. The split is bad for Abyei because they’re on the border of the soon to be North and South. Since we were all made to think differently, the variation of opinions are causing violent disputes between the people, resulting in a genocide. The North claims they were only acting in retaliation after their troops were harmed.
Bashir’s refusal to withdraw troops makes the matter worse. I believe he does not want to remove troops because it may read as a sign of defeat. If Sudan becomes split, he will lose power and no longer be in charge of both sides. It seems as though Bashir is focused on keeping his power, than helping his people.
I agree with Billy. They are discriminating against one another, which is pointless because they are of the same kind. Different practices of religion and advantage of resources also play a part in the violence over Abyei.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-13531611
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-13531611
In class we have been studying the conflict between Northern and Southern Sudan. This conflict has been going on since the early 1980 reason being because of l racial, ethnic and religious divides just like the current conflict in Darfur. Northern Sudan is primarily Muslim and Southern part of Sudan has more diverse religons. Not only that it has been reported over 2 million people have died. If this war continues many more will loose their lives. Also Sudan is divided racially with lighter skin and darker skin people. On the border of Sudan is a city called Abyei,. Abyei has large amounts of oil. And BAMM that’s were it goes both north and south want to take the land for themselves. As for the President of Sudan Omar al-Bashir, who is for the North believes they should occupy the land. Wow really Omar al-Bashir you pick sides with your country rather than what’s best for it seriously this is how a country stays divided. I so agree with Vanessa to side with one part of the country is ridicules because if the cost is to loose thousands of your people that shows you are corrupt. I would agree with the Southern Sudanese any day to fight for equality and peace.
http://globalspin.blogs.time.com/2011/05/23/south-sudans-bloody-birth/
http//www.the-african.org/blog/?p=466
As i research the conflict in Sudan North and South Sudan have many different points of view.the religion are different the north Sudanese are Muslim the South Sudanese are Christian."We will never pull our troops out of Abyei as long as they want to take over Abyei. They have started the assault on us,"said Amin Hassan Omer, a state minister(los angle time). The south is still governed by the north because they haven't got their independence yet. this conflict has cause a lot a death throughout Sudan, "President Bashir puts the death toll at 10,000" (bbc new). most of the people said the reason for this was Mr Bashir.
referesse.
http://articles.latimes.com/2011/may/23/world/la-fg-sudan-clashes-20110523
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/3496731.stm
Southern Sudan no longer wants to be under North Sudan's power. People believe that if the country is divided, power will no longer be an issue for the south. Others believe that north should continue to control all of Sudan just to avoid and changes in the government. You have to remember that once people gain power, they'll want more and will eliminate anyone who gets in their way. I agree that North and South Sudan has their differences. So maybe when they are officially divided, the conflict will decrease. Nobody wants to share power and that's why there are people dying and suffering in Sudan. Abyei is needed in both North and South Sudan, and the oil they supply should be shared. But it should be up to Abyei. According to a source, "The Status of Abyei was left undecided in 2005 peace deal and referendum..." (BBC News). And President Omar Al-Bashir claims that the area belongs to the north. But the "UN Security Council, which toured Sudan earlier this week, has urged northern forces to withdraw" (BBC News). Sudan should be divided because I believe it will solve the conflict. And the oil in Abyei should be shared.
Resources:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-13531611
Not only do I agree with Vanessa but also the two perspectives on the North and South are the North believes in different political views as if their government is stronger and have morals. However, the South Sudanese believe the only reason why their not getting it because their targeted by their skin color. This is a type of genocide which isn’t fair to the people from the South of Sudan. Finally the North may make an agreement that they don’t have is their rich resource and oil reserves. So I mean hey these are two good points.
Sudan has been in several civil wars for decades, and in 2003 they were faced with yet another one. The ongoing war in Sudan has cost "..at least 170,000 to 255,000 lives" (NationalGeographic.com) . So what disagreement could possibly cause such ciaos in a single nation? Religion, poverty, and a bias government. To be more clear on each of these allow me to explain just how all three of those combined have created a formula of destruction, using the land of Darfur. The land has been neglected by the government for several years due to its distance from Khartoum, Sudan’s capital. Darfur, left in poverty, is separated by two kinds of people herders whom are Arabs, and farmers who are African. “Droughts, famine, and desertification have added to rising tensions” (NationalGeographic.com) leading the African farmers believe that the government has taken favor of the Arab herders. Such beliefs caused the formation of rebel groups, in attempt to fight the government. Unfortunately the government, instead of attempting to handle the task at hand peacefully confirmed the Africans beliefs by installing government based militias. Although the government of Sudan does own up to this, they argue it was solely for “self defense” purposes, and have denied any involvement with “the Arab Janjaweed militia - who are accused of trying to drive out black Africans from large swathes of territory. (BBC.com)
In my opinion it was irresponsible of the government to set up government influenced militias amongst the Arabs. President Omar al-Bashir and his officials should have definitely chosen another route of “self defense”. But even before making that mistake, the government should NEVER forget a land, men, women, children, because of their geographical placement. I mean seriously, imagine the U.S. forgetting California, solely because, whoops they happen to be on the West Coast as opposed to the East Coast, where cause capital happens to be! People are dying at an outrageous rate because all of Darfur, felt abandoned and instead of a government instilling helpful government programs, they instill more tension and destruction.
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2006/09/060914-darfur-video.html
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/3496731.stm
Sudan is a wel known place for its oils. But within Sudan there is a conflict going on. This conflict has been going on for years none stop and because of it the South Sudan's leader Salva Klir said "I will not lead my people into conflict with the north over the disputed region of Abyei". "We will not go back to war, it will not happen." South Sudan feels like Abyei belongs to North Sudan just so the conflict can stop.
Abyei is a city that splits Sudan. North and South Sudan is fighting for Abyei because it is an “oil- rich area”. (Xinhua Net) Though, the North and South do have differences that include race and beliefs. North Sudan has more of a European influence and south has a more of the darker skinned complexion Sudanese people. The North’s major religion is Islam, and the South has many others including the Christian belief. The President of Sudan, Al-Bashir, “said that Abyei belongs to north Sudan.”(Xinhua Net) Al- Bashir is Islam so it is a little obvious that he would side with his own kind. I agree with Yaritza about them fighting this batter on their own. We should not step in on a war within its own people. As said, “Sudan has been at war with itself for more than three-quarters of its existence.”(State)
Reference:
http://www.state.gov/r/pa/ei/bgn/5424.htm
www.xinhuanet.com/english2010/world/africa/htm
Post a Comment